Saxophones Baritone - Startone vs Thomann lowJAZZ vs vintage

My other horn I have is a (slightly leaking) King Zephyr low Bb.

I expected to like the Kings tone more, but this wasn't the case. I prefere the modern sound. And I need a low A for Bigband, which I didn't expect either. So you never know....
Intonation and ergos are not bad on the King but I think I'll sell it sooner or later. I don't need two baris.

This thread inspired me to revisite my King Zephyr Bari again. I found a little leak which I think was the reason for a certain unstability and could fix it. And I absolutely loved how it plays and feels in a jazz standard setting!
It wouldn't be ideal for fluent bigband or classical playing - but for a mulligan vibe it's wonderful.
I'll keep it, that's for sure!
 
The Selmer Mk VI was introduced over 75 years ago in 1954, and from what I can gather it helped revolutionise saxophone design with several new features. Like any radically new design (and its associated manufacturing process), it’s not surprising to me that problems were encountered and corrected during its production run of 20 years. In the case of the Mk VI this included corrections to intonation problems. Clearly intonation issues are a very poor feature in any instrument and one which manufacturers will make great efforts to avoid or correct. Presumably nowadays saxophone designs are stable, and manufacturing methods are greatly improved compared with yesteryear. Are there any examples of modern (say post-2000) or currently produced saxophones that are known to experience intonation problems?
Regarding the Mark VI, the two biggest innovations were the tilting Bb lever on the pinky table, and the logo on the octave key. I’m sure there were some other changes to bore and tone hole location between the SBA model that preceded it. But as you point out, those kinds of changes happened during the 20 year run of the Mark VI too.

I own a SBA alto, and the horn I had previously was a Mark VI (which I sold to buy the SBA), and from an ergonomic standpoint, there was no change in where I placed my fingers, or indeed in the overall experience of playing the horn.

Regarding intonation, no saxophone made is perfectly in tune. Most can be PLAYED in tune, but we need to use our old-fashioned flesh and cartilage appendages, attached to the sides of our heads, for that.

Bottom line, the VI is a great horn, and IMO stands out as the pinnacle of hand-made saxophone manufacture. But it’s definitely an evolutionary step, not a radical change. Were they the β€œbest” in their time? Absolutely. Are they the β€œbest of all time”? Not so sure of that, there are some really great modern horns out there. That said, my Mark VI tenor is not for sale, and my daughter has strict instructions on how to dispose of it when I pass on!
 
Regarding the Mark VI, the two biggest innovations were the tilting Bb lever on the pinky table, and the logo on the octave key. I’m sure there were some other changes to bore and tone hole location between the SBA model that preceded it. But as you point out, those kinds of changes happened during the 20 year run of the Mark VI too.

I own a SBA alto, and the horn I had previously was a Mark VI (which I sold to buy the SBA), and from an ergonomic standpoint, there was no change in where I placed my fingers, or indeed in the overall experience of playing the horn.

Regarding intonation, no saxophone made is perfectly in tune. Most can be PLAYED in tune, but we need to use our old-fashioned flesh and cartilage appendages, attached to the sides of our heads, for that.

Bottom line, the VI is a great horn, and IMO stands out as the pinnacle of hand-made saxophone manufacture. But it’s definitely an evolutionary step, not a radical change. Were they the β€œbest” in their time? Absolutely. Are they the β€œbest of all time”? Not so sure of that, there are some really great modern horns out there. That said, my Mark VI tenor is not for sale, and my daughter has strict instructions on how to dispose of it when I pass on!
For anyone interested there is a list of mk vi production changes here. As you mention there were changes to the cone angle of the body as well as three variations in bow length.
 
Regarding intonation, no saxophone made is perfectly in tune. Most can be PLAYED in tune, but we need to use our old-fashioned flesh and cartilage appendages, attached to the sides of our heads, for that.
Actually in the early 1970's whilst a member of the 264th Army Band, Honolulu (the Army Band of the Pacific), the supply room had about 8 saxes that were older Bueschers about to be excessed. I tried them, the intonation on them was truly bad, difficult to play in tune. (The oldest in the inventory, they were in deep need of tech attention.)

Based on that experience alone, I'd be of the impression that Bueschers were the worst domestic brand available.
For anyone interested there is a list of mk vi production changes here. As you mention there were changes to the cone angle of the body as well as three variations in bow length.
Seems today with other manufacturers, they would introduce these changes as a new different model.
 
Actually in the early 1970's whilst a member of the 264th Army Band, Honolulu (the Army Band of the Pacific), the supply room had about 8 saxes that were older Bueschers about to be excessed. I tried them, the intonation on them was truly bad, difficult to play in tune. (The oldest in the inventory, they were in deep need of tech attention.)

Based on that experience alone, I'd be of the impression that Bueschers were the worst domestic brand available.

Seems today with other manufacturers, they would introduce these changes as a new different model.
Setup matters. Key heights can make a huge difference in how in tune a saxophone plays. And then there is the issue of mouthpiece placement / embouchure / voicing. Finding the right spot for a your mouthpiece is, IMO, critical to being able to play in tune. And of course, there are those older (1920's and '30's) vintage horns that require large or medium chamber pieces because of the neck geometry.

I have not heard that Bueschers in particular are less in tune than, say, Conns or Selmers. I suspect that your experience with them is not typical; lots of people play them and have no issues. I played a Buescher tenor in high school, it had been refurbished, and it played very well. With a Brilhart LevelAire πŸ™‚
A very good point, well made! πŸ™‚ But no doubt some are less imperfect than others πŸ˜‰
They don't call it the devil's horn for nothing...
 
I have not heard that Bueschers in particular are less in tune than, say, Conns or Selmers. I suspect that your experience with them is not typical; lots of people play them and have no issues. I played a Buescher tenor in high school, it had been refurbished, and it played very well. With a Brilhart LevelAire πŸ™‚
Perhaps I was not as clear as I should have been. My point was that this appeared to be an isolated incident. Also I would not rule out the government's habit of seeking the lowest bid, which sometimes results in work that reflects marginal technical competence.
 
I think my GAS is fairly well suppressed at the moment I have a BW baritone plus BW curved and straight sopranos which are currently my main instruments / back ups for each other. A localish store has both a straight and a curved BW sop for sale at the moment. Second Hand Bauhaus Wallstein Curved Soprano Sax
That’s all really interesting, thank you. I noticed that there are two build versions of the BW saxes: standard and deluxe. As far as I know, deluxe versions are indicated by the letter D at the end of the model number. For the brass-finished baritone, for example, this would be BS-YD instead of BS-Y. Do you have the deluxe or standard models, and do you think it makes any particular difference?
 
As far as I am aware the upgrades on the D suffix models consisted of adjustable point screws (see Stephen Howard’s website on the advantages Point or pivot screw types for woodwind instruments) and possibly better pads.
I bought a Sopranino first (I think the code was β€œSOP” - not deluxe) for travel. The size was good and as it was in Eb I could squeakily practice baritone parts in key as I was mainly playing baritone at the time l).
I was impressed and compared a curved CSS-P soprano from Studio Saxophones with my Yanagisawa curved 800 series sop. P= phosphor bronze, it was an original model, not a deluxe β€œPD”. it was better than the Yani especially in sound, intonation and ease of playing at the top which I couldn’t get my head around how could it be better?. So I got the Yanagisawa serviced and went back and tried them head to head again. Still the CSS-P was better so I bought it and sold the Yani. It served me well and I found myself playing it more and the baritone less. I then bought a SSS-YD. I found I had to work really hard on the intonation of bottom C on the CSS-P but with some really helpful advice from this forum I worked out how to play it with out too much of a battle. The pads did tend to stick but occasional application of lighter fluid to the offending pads did the trick (especially the G# pad)
I tend to use curved mostly for practice and gigs as I travel by in bike, it is best for clip on mic and it fits in my Brompton T bag. I leave the straight one set up at home in the corner of the room to encourage me to pick it up and practice.
It is difficult to say which is better as both are good. The straight deluxe has a better lower end esp low C, the curved may be better at the top. The pads seem to stick less on the SSS-YD but it rarely gets long rehearsal / gig playing like the CSS-P.
 
There will of course be within model variation no doubt (eg good and bad in both standard and deluxe). I did try a D model that I didn’t think was as good as my curved standard and a curved D model that I thought was a bit better but all pretty close.
 
From a marketing point of view, a different set of screws doesn’t sound as though it would be a convincingly deluxe improvement to the average punter, but perhaps quality was the driver instead. My soprano is a curved phosphor-bronze standard model, CSS-P. The intonation seems fine to me. The pads were sticky when it arrived, but it hadn’t been played for several years apparently and lighter fluid did the trick. The supplied (presumably original) mouthpiece seems to work fine, as long as it’s pushed on right to the end of the cork - otherwise low Bb (and B) seem to warble. Probably a fault with my technique rather than the sax, but fortunately the sax plays in tune at this position. Also, there doesn’t seem to be anything peculiar about the intonation of low C on this one. In general I have been getting a bit of condensation forming under the reed, which has then been getting a bit waterlogged. Presumably just a case of me getting used to the difference compared with a tenor? That reminds me, I’ll have to take @ghostler β€˜s advice and dig out my feeler gauges.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,237
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom