SOTM SOTM December 2025: Wexford Carol

Messages
2,355
Location
Breda
Level
Amateur (for 30 years)
I offered to host a SOTM for December and decided to go for a Christmas Carol. My favourite is the (15th-16th Century) ‘Wexford Carol’ (background + lyrics). You can find a whole host of example performances on YouTube. Two are shown below.

As in all carols (and many songs), the basic melody is repetitive over different verses. I have a few favourite vocal and instrumental recordings. What makes them (for me) appealing are three main things:
- the 'expression' of the soloist (dynamics, variations, etc.) both within and between verses
- variations in the 'backing' which often start relatively simply, gradually become richer and either continue or wind down to again become relatively simple
- (occasionally) the way soloists tailor their 'expression' to match the changing 'richness' and dynamics of the backing

@rhysonsax has worked his magic (and has gone above and beyond!) in producing two different versions. You can find them on Box. As a bonus for all sax players, @rhysonsax has added 'backing track with guide melody' mp3's so members can hear how a sax sounds against a backing track. And he added a special bonus for B♭ sax players, giving them the choice to play the melody in either the lower or higher registers (or alternate between them).

The first two-verse version (at 66 bpm) has fairly easy-to-play sheet music.

The second four-verse version (at 55 bpm) more closely mirrors Alison Krauss/Yo-Yo Ma’s version (see below). Both in terms of instrumentation and in terms of the vocal inflections included in the sheet music. You are of course free to include, ignore or simplify these ‘inflections. The second version provides more scope for variation and/or improvisation on one or two verses.

The basic melody is the same in both versions so (with two minor differences) you can play the sheet music for the first version against the backing track for the second or vice-versa. The only two differences are:
  • Version 1 has a 4-bar intro while Version 2 has a 3-bar intro
  • Version 2 has an added 9-bar (backing) outro
And a last point: if this Carol doesn't appeal to you, then just play one that does! 🙂

Wexford Carol (Alisson Krauss/Yo Yo Ma)
View: https://youtu.be/yxDZjg_Igoc?si=oJ2LMro6mkfpPb73


Wexford Carol (Sam Levine)
View: https://youtu.be/jRr4B6CF4dY?si=nnHxe_PrFYG4dQdU
 
There is an article that gives the background to this Irish carole:
It also has a couple renditions. The first on Spotify not only gives the song but a verbal discourse on its history, which is pleasant to casually listen to.

It was a bit of history that I knew not previously. This is the first time that I have heard this carole. Thank you for sharing and including this as the SOTM for December, @MikeMorrell . It is fitting.
 
It was my very first solo! I joined our New Horizons band in March of 2020 and had two rehearsals with the band before everything shut down due to Covid. Our ever-innovating director put together an online recital during the Christmas season of that year for any of us that wished to volunteer. I jumped right in, choosing that song because I remembered it from my Firestone Christmas album that featured Julie Andrews. I don't have a recording of it from then, but here is the photo of me playing in front of my computer:
1764541121761.webp


I had hoped to play it, along with Masters in this Hall, at church the following year, but became ill a few days before I was scheduled. My thoughts were to focus on the celebratory and contemplative aspects of Christmas.

Here are the lyrics. It's a very beautiful and meaningful carol.
THE WEXFORD CAROL
(Contemplation)
Good people all, this Christmas time
Consider well and bear in mind
What our good God for us has done
In sending His beloved Son

With Mary, holy we should pray
To God with love this Christmas Day
In Bethlehem upon that morn
There was the blessed Messiah born

Within a manger He was laid
And by His side the Virgin maid
Attending on the Lord of Life
Who came on earth to end all strife

With Mary, holy we should pray
To God with love this Christmas Day
In Bethlehem upon that morn
There was the blessed Messiah born​
 
One thing to be aware of is that Version 2 (based on the recording by Alison Krauss and Yo-Yo Ma) has different numbers of beats/bars between the verses, so people should look carefully at the first, second and third time bars which are all slightly different. There is also a single note from the triangle on the beat before each verse starts.

I think of the Wessex Carol as having verses of 16 bars with an A-A-B-A type structure. Each of these verses consists of two of the stanzas as set out on the post by @ESJohn above. There are also more stanzas in that Alison Krauss recording.

The harmony doesn't move much, but you can hear that it changes in the B sections such as "With Mary holy we should pray" where there is a concert Gb in the melody.

Will anyone try a vocal recording ?

Rhys
 
Last edited:
I was hoping to get in first so that the bar would be set very low. Outstanding work, Mrblackbat!
Here is my effort of a much simpler version via 8notes.com, arranged by Christian Morris. Shifting from F to Eb, especially the second time around, seemed to be my nemesis. As our band is always told, a performance is the best rehearsal!
Thanks for the opportunity. Great pick, Mike!
 
Ads are not displayed to logged in members. Yay!
One with headphones, one without. Was one method better than the other?
Ahhh a bit of experimenting on my part

The one with headphones was videoed whilst I recorded the audio in audacity.

The one without headphones, I am playing, but the audio you're hearing is a previous take, I'm playing along to that recording through the speakers.

Headphones is better, in that the actual audio should align perfectly with the video, and the mic picks up the sax only, backing is in my ears.
 
I still have delay issues, even with headphones that connect directly to my computer while using Audacity. I'm still learning the best way for me to record. I miss the old days when all I had to worry about was the saxophone!
 
I still have delay issues, even with headphones that connect directly to my computer while using Audacity. I'm still learning the best way for me to record. I miss the old days when all I had to worry about was the saxophone!
Issues with delay as in the audio doesn't recording doesn't align with the backing? It could be Latency and it can be adjusted theres a tutorial here.
 
Issues with delay as in the audio doesn't recording doesn't align with the backing? It could be Latency and it can be adjusted theres a tutorial here.
Thank you x50!
With the headphones plugged in to the computer, I, after several guesses, found that +50 was perfect.
I'd still like to send in the Alto 1 part for Hark if I can figure out a good time. Today is shot.
Thanks again!
 

Popular Discussions on the Café

Forum statistics

Topics
27,393
Messages
508,059
Members
7,137
Latest member
Buzzymost
Back
Top Bottom