Saxophones Baritone - Startone vs Thomann lowJAZZ vs vintage

“The test of the machine is the satisfaction it gives you. There isn’t any other test. If the machine produces tranquility it’s right. If it disturbs you it’s wrong until either the machine or your mind is changed.” Robert M. Pirsig, Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance
 
Right. If a Chinese horn is good enough for @Pete Thomas (BW), @Colin the Bear (Startone), @jonf (Jupiter), @JayeNM (Jupiter) and others, then it is certainly very much more than good enough for me! I took the advice of @ghostler and waited a while. A secondhand basic model BW in good condition came up at less than the 2013 new price quoted by @h4yn0nnym0u5e and it has just been delivered. A minor adjustment was needed on the low C# key stop screw and I think there may be a minor leak somewhere else that I've not yet tracked down, but otherwise it's looking and sounding good to me so far...! 🙂
 
Right. If a Chinese horn is good enough for @Pete Thomas (BW), @Colin the Bear (Startone), @jonf (Jupiter), @JayeNM (Jupiter) and others, then it is certainly very much more than good enough for me! I took the advice of @ghostler and waited a while. A secondhand basic model BW in good condition came up at less than the 2013 new price quoted by @h4yn0nnym0u5e and it has just been delivered. A minor adjustment was needed on the low C# key stop screw and I think there may be a minor leak somewhere else that I've not yet tracked down, but otherwise it's looking and sounding good to me so far...! 🙂
My Jupiter is actually Taiwanese, not Chinese, but your point is still very valid. And, in fact, one of the four baritones I've owned over time was a BW. I thought it was an excellent sax, and I only sold it as I had bought a vintage bari (also since sold). I was really impressed with the tone and playability of the BW, consistently right through the range. I think you'll enjoy it very much.
 
“The test of the machine is the satisfaction it gives you. There isn’t any other test. If the machine produces tranquility it’s right. If it disturbs you it’s wrong until either the machine or your mind is changed.” Robert M. Pirsig, Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance
Anyone who loves motorcycles is an alright person in my books. 😉

I am glad to hear that you waited until the right sax came along at the right price.
 
Right. If a Chinese horn is good enough for @Pete Thomas (BW), @Colin the Bear (Startone), @jonf (Jupiter), @JayeNM (Jupiter) and others, then it is certainly very much more than good enough for me! I took the advice of @ghostler and waited a while. A secondhand basic model BW in good condition came up at less than the 2013 new price quoted by @h4yn0nnym0u5e and it has just been delivered. A minor adjustment was needed on the low C# key stop screw and I think there may be a minor leak somewhere else that I've not yet tracked down, but otherwise it's looking and sounding good to me so far...! 🙂
Well, "A chinese horn" can cover the range from very good to very bad.
 
Thank you, I think I'd like them more if there weren't so many cars around! I liked the Zen quote. Do you think it's applicable to a saxophone....? 🙂
I'm not sure what the Zen quote is. I live rurally in a small city of 38,000 people, so we don't have the heavy traffic one has in a large city, ideal motorcycle country.

One goes to a motorcycle rally, say Muleshoe, Texas 30 miles from here at their official "convention center" (looks more like a barn, 2022 population: 5,054)
Muleshoe, Texas (TX 79347) profile: population, maps, real estate, statistics, jobs, schools, etc.

There will be say 80 Harley-Davidson street tourers/cruisers and 20 others (Japanese, Canadian, US Victory, Big Dog and a few English, Italian) bikes.

No one really cares what bike one rides, just glad they do. I kind of compare saxists and their saxophone make/models to that.
 
You could also say exactly the same about an Italian horn, a French horn, a US horn.......
Are you agreeing with me, or disagreeing? Or are you just doing that British internet thing of trying to generate controversy for the sake of generating controversy?
 
Since you said all thoughts are apreciated, here are a few of mine 🙂
I played some baris and own two at the moments:

I'm glad I found a Jupiter 889 low A used for a fair price and like it a lot. Used Jupiters 700 series and higher should be good, solid horns.
My other horn I have is a (slightly leaking) King Zephyr low Bb.

I expected to like the Kings tone more, but this wasn't the case. I prefere the modern sound. And I need a low A for Bigband, which I didn't expect either. So you never know....
Intonation and ergos are not bad on the King but I think I'll sell it sooner or later. I don't need two baris.

When I was shopping I tried a Chateau and a Antigua Pro One - the first one was ok and the Antigua was very good.
I think the better Thomann horns are made by Chateau.
The cheaper Thomann TBS 150 is really ok for the money.

I once bought a startone tenor as a cheap instrument for school, and it was the same as the entry level thomann but with felts and corks falling off after a short time. I don't know if one can generalize this, but since then I think of startone as a brand with very bad built quality.
 
When I was shopping I tried a Chateau and a Antigua Pro One - the first one was ok and the Antigua was very good.
I have an Antigua Winds BS3220LQ Low-A bari. In 2014 it went for $4,400 US with Musician's Friend. I bought it by mail from Quinn Music Store, Seattle area for $2,371 US new in 2021 on clearance, shipping and tax included. It is stated to be of intermediate quality, but plays extremely well, I am very happy with it. Came with a heavy duty luggage grade case with wheels.

I'm glad I found a Jupiter 889 low A used for a fair price and like it a lot. Used Jupiters 700 series and higher should be good, solid horns.
I got a used JTS-689 (best match) disguised as a Le Blanc 7133T tenor (lacks altissimo F# but easily made up for by alternate fingering). with it newly serviced, I have developed a liking for it over my Venus tenor. Although the Venus has a nice overal tone and plays well, the Jupe has a slight edge over it in having a fuller, rounder tone in its bottom end. Metallurgy is the stoutest I have seen in a sax.

About the only neg on it is it has a small octave key thumb rest that is convex, tends to tire the thumb under a long session.
 
The same could be said for most other countries' manufacture.

My point is that characterizing something as "a Chinese horn" really tells you almost nothing about it.
Apologies, you are perfectly correct. My choice of wording was bad! Actually I decided to go for what I considered was a cheap but good enough option, waiting a while for a BW to turn up, with Startone as a fallback option. Both of these horns are Chinese as far as I know, and together they represent the extent of the Chinese horns I was referring to.
 
Apologies, you are perfectly correct. My choice of wording was bad! Actually I decided to go for what I considered was a cheap but good enough option, waiting a while for a BW to turn up, with Startone as a fallback option. Both of these horns are Chinese as far as I know, and together they represent the extent of the Chinese horns I was referring to.
Something that's worth keeping in mind is that although a Chinese horn may not be as well-built as, say, a Yamaha - it's nonetheless cheap.
If you find it has the playability you want, it may well be worth having it properly fettled to bring it up to scratch.
Yes, it might cost you a pretty penny but there's an excellent chance that you'll still come in way under the cost of even a secondhand well-regarded model.
And you'd be very much better off than the folks who'd splashed out 4-5k+ on a horn only to find it needs half a grand of remedial work before it's up to scratch ( which reminds me...Ishimori alto review in the pipeline).

I see a lot of players in the workshop who have no issues with where a horn is built or what's written on the bell. They just have an eye on the price, the possibilities...and the playability. These tend to be be happy people 🙂

I had a Gear4Music bari for a while. Yamaha 62 copy. Yes, it needed some tweaking but it was frighteningly close to the real thing. I only sold it because I can no longer be arsed to lug a bari to a gig.

The BW bari was a monster horn - as indeed were the rest of the range. Is anyone else making them? I've yet to see anything that compares. "Baby out with the bathwater" is perhaps the phrase that could be levelled at the manufacturers.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,193
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom