Saxophones Baritone - Startone vs Thomann lowJAZZ vs vintage

Are you agreeing with me, or disagreeing? Or are you just doing that British internet thing of trying to generate controversy for the sake of generating controversy?
I don't know why you're being so hostile. All I'm saying that - with the posible exception of Japan, which only really has two sax manufacturers, both of which produce good saxes - you get good and bad from all countries.

What is 'that British internet thing'? No idea what you mean by that, and I am not 'trying to generate controversy for the sake of generating controversy'.
 
Are you agreeing with me, or disagreeing? Or are you just doing that British internet thing of trying to generate controversy for the sake of generating controversy?
I will leave Jon to confirm his meaning but it's not just the British that make a statement to generate controversy and not just on the internet in my experience 😉

Jx
 
To me, the evaluation of the overall financial cost encompasses initial outlay, set-up cost, ongoing maintenance costs and (especially in the case of an experimental purchase) future sale price. Choosing the "right" second hand machine hopefully means minimising both ongoing maintenance cost and the difference between initial outlay (however large) and future sale price. I was able to keep the initial outlay down, thereby reducing risks should my sax get beaten up, lost or destroyed. I realise set-up cost is potentially a gamble but I have my fingers crossed. I may take up your advice and get it fettled. Good word that. The other features I was looking for were good ergonomics, good intonation and (possibly) good sound. From what I believe, and am now starting to experience, the BW should fulfil these categories. I believe the responsibility for a good sound being emitted by any sax is likely more closely aligned with the player than the machine.

Of course the word "good" may be a matter for further debate. Refer to comments from @Colin the Bear and @h4yn0nnym0u5e on value, and my previous quote from Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance (apparently it is possibly the highest selling book on philosophy) which has subtitle "An Inquiry into Values".
 
By the way, I'm certainly no philosopher, nor am I a bookseller, but I know that good, value & quality are hard things to define, be it in a saxophone, a saxophonist, a mouthpiece, a piece of music or anything else for that matter. 😉

It was interesting to read the posts above about Antigua Winds, I'd never considered that brand!
Also.... I have to admit I stumbled across a cheap second hand BW curved soprano during my wait for a BW bari, I couldn't resist picking that up as well! The opposite end of the scale I was looking for but it's great fun! 😀
 
I don't know why you're being so hostile. All I'm saying that - with the posible exception of Japan, which only really has two sax manufacturers, both of which produce good saxes - you get good and bad from all countries.

What is 'that British internet thing'? No idea what you mean by that, and I am not 'trying to generate controversy for the sake of generating controversy'.
Sorry about the misunderstanding. Please accept my apologies for an overly combative style.
 
By the way, I'm certainly no philosopher, nor am I a bookseller, but I know that good, value & quality are hard things to define, be it in a saxophone, a saxophonist, a mouthpiece, a piece of music or anything else for that matter. 😉

It was interesting to read the posts above about Antigua Winds, I'd never considered that brand!
Also.... I have to admit I stumbled across a cheap second hand BW curved soprano during my wait for a BW bari, I couldn't resist picking that up as well! The opposite end of the scale I was looking for but it's great fun! 😀
I have a BW curved sop. It will be extensively used next week at a duo (with a drummer) gig instead of either of my two Yanag sops purely because it’s easier to put a clip-on mic on it. I have no doubts it will perform perfectly. See here.
 
Wake up call. What you just experienced is how normal the Café is and what a pit the other place is. Leaving that place did me well. Unsolicited advice, dump the place. It’s making you less than human.
Well, I dunno about that. I spent 10 years in a boys' school and then four years in engineering school, so the motto there was "if you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen". Compared to those environments, most of the internet is pretty weak tea.

The lesson to be learned - and I suppose I will have to keep re-learning it all my life - is to read the audience and respond accordingly to the cultural norms of the place where you actually are. The "shock and awe" responses that worked well in teh boys' school, or the maintenance shop, or the commercial kitchen, won't fly in other places.
 
The mouthpieces that came with the bari and the soprano are both unbranded, presumably they came with the saxes from new? Does anyone know anything about BW-supplied mouthpieces? The tip openings seem quite narrow. I think I’m getting used to the bari one - all the “standard” notes come out ok now, so I’m not convinced there are any significant leaks. I threaded an LED tape light (like this) through the whole length of the horn and I didn’t see any obvious gaps.
 
The mouthpieces that came with the bari and the soprano are both unbranded, presumably they came with the saxes from new? Does anyone know anything about BW-supplied mouthpieces? The tip openings seem quite narrow. I think I’m getting used to the bari one - all the “standard” notes come out ok now, so I’m not convinced there are any significant leaks. I threaded an LED tape light (like this) through the whole length of the horn and I didn’t see any obvious gaps.
Similar to automobile or motorbike setting of valve clearances, one can set the mouthpiece face down on a flat surface like a kitchen countertop, take a stack of feeler gauges, measure what the tip gap is. Where there is a slight touch of drag, bingo, value found. Then see where daylight breaks, measure the facing length with a fine rule.

They are mild mouthpieces so a starting saxist can be assured success with a reasonable reed, but any saxist can make it play right off. Perhaps it is equivalent to a Yamaha 4C or not too far from it?

The debate on mouthpieces is about as bad as discussions on motorcycle engine oils on motorcycle discussion forums.

There is ranting and raving about this and that "jazz mouthpiece", then one hears some experienced geezer hitting it off in jazz play with a Yamaha 4C and sounds good. (Projection can be made up for by today's sax microphone systems, just saying.)

But, to make things good with all the fuss, 2 days ago I ordered myself a Bari Esprit sop mouthpiece kit complete for $20 US, shipping free, with tax $21.57 US.
I have used the stock beginner mouthpiece that came with my 2012 Venus sop in venues like a small dining room with 80 guests max. The idea is to play soft enough so they can converse but still enjoy the music. (Otherwise, there's no invitation back.) It was a rather tight room with me playing in a corner.

This is an example of a venue where one doesn't want projection. So, there are places to use a milder mouthpiece. :sax:Milder doesn't mean inferior.

Anyway, good luck in your quest for a better mouthpiece. With a little patience, I'm sure you'll find something you're happy with to make those saxes sing.
 
@ghostler , 10 machines off an assembly line will never preform exactly the same. The precision of the maker will limit the “range” of differences. Engineered tolerances. Add the variance of human anatomy…. virtually unlimited. The task is to make anything work well with the least possible amount of effort. Hence the search for the golden combination. Sax-mouthpiece-reed-lig & position of the moon’s.

I’ve found my golden alto & C melody MPC combonation. It took years. Tenor I’m still seeking. I rarely play a Bari or soprano, so ??
It’s called a musical journey for many reasons.
 
10 machines off an assembly line will never preform exactly the same. The precision of the maker will limit the “range” of differences. Engineered tolerances. Add the variance of human anatomy…. virtually unlimited. The task is to make anything work well with the least possible amount of effort. Hence the search for the golden combination. Sax-mouthpiece-reed-lig & position of the moon’s.
Perhaps the best treatise on manufacturing tolerances was best expressed by Pete, current proprieter of The Woodwind Forum. About the well loved and respected Selmer Mark VI (alto and tenor), he wrote under the topic midway down, Old Wives Tales:
... and here's one that's actually true: some VI's have rather poor intonation. This is due to the fact that the VI is hand-finished and hand-assembled. Some just don't sound as good as others. The vast majority have good intonation, tho.

That is why we have you. 😉 Do more players bring in a sax for repair during full moons or new moons?

Back in the early 1970's, the Army had just gotten some brand new Buffet Crampon Bb soprano clarinets, professional grade in Grenadilla wood made in France. I tried out a few but retained my used loaner because they overall did not play as well in tune. (Army had a policy to keep used instruments repaired until about a decade and half old, unusual wear and tear excepted, or something to that effect.)

Then, the most experienced clarinet player told me that the clarinetists at the Honolulu Symphony sent their clarinets to a specialist who completely tuned them. (Today would you be that specialist?) Being the woodwind section leader, his own personal clarinet was tuned. I saw for example in his clarinet, one of the tone holes on the upper edge had been lined with a thin sliver segment of some sort to adjust the tone location.

Of all things, the first clarinet I played that was the best in tune throughout its range was a brand new ebonite Selmer Bundy that I was issued in 1986.

Maybe I got a clarinet that came from fresh and not worn out moulds?
 
The Selmer Mk VI was introduced over 75 years ago in 1954, and from what I can gather it helped revolutionise saxophone design with several new features. Like any radically new design (and its associated manufacturing process), it’s not surprising to me that problems were encountered and corrected during its production run of 20 years. In the case of the Mk VI this included corrections to intonation problems. Clearly intonation issues are a very poor feature in any instrument and one which manufacturers will make great efforts to avoid or correct. Presumably nowadays saxophone designs are stable, and manufacturing methods are greatly improved compared with yesteryear. Are there any examples of modern (say post-2000) or currently produced saxophones that are known to experience intonation problems?
 
Presumably nowadays saxophone designs are stable, and manufacturing methods are greatly improved compared with yesteryear.
My 1952'ish Beaugnier Vito Model 37 Low-Bb Bari plays very well in tune. It plays in the altissimo range very easily.

The book I bought, The Leak Light Speaks mentions that overall prior to 1967, all beginner saxophones were of intermediate grade.

Regarding tuning, my 2012 Eb Sopranino Venus ebonite Clarinet's intonation isn't that great, although I can play it in tune. It is a hoot to jazz improv with, my "budget sopranino Eb sax". (Paid less than $100 US for it.) 😀
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,193
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom