Saxophone beginners Where do I start? (complete beginner)

Absolutely. But pros - and most talented amateur/semi-pros - have not, for the most part, encountered the problems of late starters. People who haven't played music, maybe, since they where a kid if ever... But has learned about themselves, how they learn etc.
A really good teacher understands that. But a lot of teachers are just surviving between proper work.
They may well have, as they’ve certainly put in more time (and maybe had the time to work through those problems).

I can also tell you that each one of my instrumental teachers was fantastic, and I found out how lucky I was shortly after leaving college. Some of my other lecturers at college were terrible though, but that was less impactful for me as a player.
 
There is a huge difference, I can look at online material at my leisure and without pressure and fear of embarrassment, no cutting my day in half because I had to take that personal lesson. And, there is a risk of misunderstanding the one or other thing or getting hung up on a specific word, which is why I referenced @skeller047 's post for alternative ways of teaching the same thing.

Yes, there will be a point where a personal interaction with other sax players will prove beneficial but OP or Ann appears to be a smart person who can figure things out by herself. And for sure I had enough bad teachers in my life to understand why she rather goes her own way.
If I didn't know better I'd think you were being deliberately obtuse.

"No cutting my day in half to take that personal lesson"? You have to take the time to watch the video content you shared. There's little difference from a time perspective. I had a lesson last week, I'm still reviewing and absorbing that content and discussion now, working on the things talked about, sending the odd email for clarification etc. It's not like it all happens during the lesson time as some epiphany, anymore than watching a video suddenly makes you great. You review and go over that content again and again.

If you're embarrassed with a teacher then there is something seriously wrong; either with the teacher or with you. A teaching relationship needs to be a safe space, from both sides.

The risk of misunderstanding is far greater without interaction: with a teacher you can simply ask (and usually demonstration by either party, which happens naturally, will clarify something in any case.) With an online, non interactive course, the risk of misunderstanding is the same with the exception that immediate correction won't happen. And then you end up with the guy who taped his Front F fork shut.....
 
I can’t get past the notion that “not everyone needs a teacher “ = “I don’t need advice from anyone “
That's not the same thing. The first one does not exclude the possibility of taking advice, most likely from several people instead of following a single person's idea of how to go about a specific subject.

My only saxophone "teacher I ever had was an Airforce band player who I knew and I just wanted to get an opinion on my "new used alto" and he forced me to come up on stage during a jam (I had only been playing for a few weeks). I told him he was nuts, I did not know how to play at all and he positioned himself in front of me and said, just watch my fingers and do the monkey see, monkey do thing. In the next 30 minutes I learned more than what I could have learned from "the average teacher" in 6 months.
 
I we all lived next door to our favourite player, would we not be over there all the time (assuming they hadn’t gotten a restraining order)?
 
Also, it’s interesting how most self-taught, and taught players argue for their own “upbringing “
Almost everyone does!
And that's a problem. Ability to learn changes radically in different phases of life for all sorts of things; languages, physical movement; and probably many aspects of music.
Someone who thinks what worked for them, aged 10, will work for someone aged 60 may well be making a mistake.
 
I wasn't referring to your responses as piling on. Piling is all the "get a teacher" posts. It's a collective action.
Maybe, just maybe, the fact that the overwhelming recommendation is in favor of quality in-person instruction ( not just any in-person instructor), might be a hint of something?
 
Almost everyone does!
And that's a problem. Ability to learn changes radically in different phases of life for all sorts of things; languages, physical movement; and probably many aspects of music.
Someone who thinks what worked for them, aged 10, will work for someone aged 60 may well be making a mistake.
Well, it's a sample size of one, but I will say that I learned piano and flute the standard way, starting at age 9; it worked OK; I learned saxophone almost 100% self-taught (and even then, I already had a solid background in music theory, reading, and some of general wind instrument practice with flute, started saxophone at 16; and I learned double-bass starting at 50 with traditional instruction.

So in my case, what worked at 9 years old worked at 50. What I did on saxophone, starting at 16, "worked" in the sense that I was playing and performing quickly; but it also gave me some bad habits and holes in my knowledge that took decades to clean up.

Of course it's 100% true that OP is an adult and can make her own decisions, and it's 100% true that nothing meaningful will be harmed if she goes ahead and her self-taught methods create some issues. I just have trouble understanding why, if you can choose between a path that demonstrably gets the majority of people playing faster, easier, and with fewer issues - and one that for MOST people will take longer, be less effective, and likely to leave bad habits - that you'd consciously choose the second one.
 
Maybe, just maybe, the fact that the overwhelming recommendation is in favor of quality in-person instruction ( not just any in-person instructor), might be a hint of something?
But that's one of the key issues. I bought my first sax from a music (saxophone) teacher who's passing words were "keep in mind that unlike a guitar with several strings, there is only one fingering for every note. Luckily I came across Randy Hunter's YouTube video about the 5 different fingerings to play bis, which probably saved me a bunch of trips to take the guy up on his offer to give me lessons.

I found out later he had a bad reputation but who was I to know. I would have probably learned all the bad habits, which is worse than developing them on your own.

The primary role of a teacher should be to instill interest and enthusiasm for the subject and THEN show the ways to accomplish it.
 
That's not the same thing. The first one does not exclude the possibility of taking advice, most likely from several people instead of following a single person's idea of how to go about a specific subject.
Whoever said taking lessons means going to a single teacher, and only one teacher? This past year I've had lessons with two saxophonists, one pianist (a saxophone/jazz lesson) and a member of two online teaching groups.

One thing that's absolutely certain in my case, is that all the lessons (7 in total at about 8.5 hours) have been WAY more valuable than the teaching groups. That's not to say the groups aren't useful, but the lessons are like those group tutorials on steroids: because of immediate feedback. Information is provided, you get to try it out in the presence of then person who gave it to you, and they can comment on that, correct etc and you can ask questions or further clarification.
 
The primary role of a teacher should be to instill interest and enthusiasm for the subject and THEN show the ways to accomplish it.
In academic study, sure. But not in all things that are physical. Nobody is going to get you work out belaying for yourself, for example; they'll show you how to do it and make sure you can do it before they let you belay someone whilst climbing. If not, someone has an accident....

Obviously, aside from the aforementioned baby kittens dying, nobody gets hurt from someone figuring out the saxophone. But the majority of players quit from frustration in their first few weeks and months, and I'd wager very strongly most of those don't have an instructor. Check out Jay Aye's Facebook group as an example; nobody there wants a teacher, and there's a lot of rage quitting.
 
Have fun with your sax!!! I also suggest finding a tutor. In our early steps we can't self-validate if we are doing things right or wrong just by watching a video. On the other there's a ton of information online and you could get an easy answer after you've progressed a bit.
Have fun !!! Welcome
 
Hope Annw feels welcome..we seemed to have lost sight of her thread and spent 6 pages debating the pros and cons of a tutor. She mentions fun and the fact that she has bought some guidance from online..she says that she isn't oppossed to lessons but might it be good to start the journey so as she knows what she needs help with..isn't the usual advice a Yamaha 4 or 5 c mouthpiece and a selection of 1 5 to 2 reeds just to get going..enjoy your journey @annw..
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom