Saxophone beginners Where do I start? (complete beginner)

In a human, it’s like a brick post or a 8x8 piece of lumber in your belly, holding the sound up. It’s the key to tone on a wind instrument. This is the best demonstration I have seen of the principle of breath support, and it works exactly the same for ALL wind instruments from piccolo to tuba.
I agree with the importance of breath support and the need for a brick post in your belly. But this is a wonderful opportunity to explain the benefit of a rebel's approach versus "conventional" music teacher wisdom.

Playing the Sax is not the most efficient way to develop that brick post. 😱

Most musicians tend to be fat and unfit and eschew physical exercise. Most music teachers have either no scientific training in physical exercise or worse, advise unscientific if well-accepted (within their own narrow music discipline) wrong advice that would be laughed at by trained physical educators.

Scientifically, the best way to develop that brick post is physical exercise for the body core: yoga, pilates, weight training, sprinting. Most conventionally trained music teachers are neither qualified, nor educated, nor interested in such appropriate physical training.

Scientifically, you should develop body core strength, strength endurance, power using physical conditioning away from the sax and only then layer upon that the specificity of saxophone playing. (There are separate physical conditioning exercises for facial muscles for the embouchure, too but this post is not about how that can be better by combining exercises done away from the sax, too).

Indeed, trying to develop core strength solely by saxophone playing arguably produces poor sax technique because overtired muscles hardwire (automate) the wrong neural system pathways. No, saxophone playing should be done when rested to optimally automate neural pathways.

Developing core strength scientifically with a multi-disciplinary approach will accelerate a sax player's development, enabling many more hours of effective on-the-instrument practice, months or even years sooner than the traditional approach of single-discipline music teaching.

Multidiscipline approach should include advice/training from a phyiotherapist or Sports Science-trained physical coach for core training, a speech therapist for facial exercises as well as a music teacher (if desired).

😱😱😱
 
Last edited:
Sorry gonna step in one more time. This is part of a longer video from the great trumpet player Clark Terry. Here he talks about the “sound post”. In a violin this is the little hard stick that supports the upper plate so the strings don’t bend it, and also transmits sound to the lower plate.

In a human, it’s like a brick post or a 8x8 piece of lumber in your belly, holding the sound up. It’s the key to tone on a wind instrument. This is the best demonstration I have seen of the principle of breath support, and it works exactly the same for ALL wind instruments from piccolo to tuba.

View: https://youtu.be/lFUm92uARiU?t=4m49s
Thank you, I will watch that later.
 
Ann, did we get to hear what make and model sax, MP, reed?

Apologies if you already said... I fell asleep...
I bought a cheapo....if I am still playing this time next year, I might be asking on here for recommendations of better saxophones! It's a Sakkusu alto, with whatever mouthpiece that comes with, and some sort of Rico reeds - sorry to be so vague, but it is packed away in a wardrobe because I am decorating, so I haven't even started playing it yet!!
 
I agree with the importance of breath support and the need for a brick post in your belly. But this is a wonderful opportunity to explain the benefit of a rebel's approach versus "conventional" music teacher wisdom.

Playing the Sax is not the most efficient way to develop that brick post. 😱

Most musicians tend to be fat and unfit and eschew physical exercise. Most music teachers have either no scientific training in physical exercise or worse, advise unscientific if well-accepted (within their own narrow music discipline) wrong advice that would be laughed at by trained physical educators.

Scientifically, the best way to develop that brick post is physical exercise for the body core: yoga, pilates, weight training, sprinting. Most conventionally trained music teachers are neither qualified, nor educated, nor interested in such appropriate physical training.

Scientifically, you should develop body core strength, strength endurance, power using physical conditioning away from the sax and only then layer upon that the specificity of saxophone playing. (There are separate physical conditioning exercises for facial muscles for the embouchure, too but this post is not about how that can be better by combining exercises done away from the sax, too).

Indeed, trying to develop core strength solely by saxophone playing arguably produces poor sax technique because overtired muscles hardwire (automate) the wrong neural system pathways. No, saxophone playing should be done when rested to optimally automate neural pathways.

Developing core strength scientifically with a multi-disciplinary approach will accelerate a sax player's development, enabling many more hours of effective on-the-instrument practice, months or even years sooner than the traditional approach of single-discipline music teaching.

Multidiscipline approach should include advice/training from a phyiotherapist or Sports Science-trained physical coach for core training, a speech therapist for facial exercises as well as a music teacher (if desired).

😱😱😱
How interesting, Clive! I do yoga and swimming, and have just joined a gym to do strength training and cardio. Helping me play sax better by working out gives me just another reason to force myself to go to the gym!!

I am actually a qualified personal fitness trainer, although I haven't worked in the industry for decades; but I still work in the healthcare industry so I know physios, speech therapists etc - I'll start picking their brains 🙂
 
How interesting, Clive! I do yoga and swimming, and have just joined a gym to do strength training and cardio. Helping me play sax better by working out gives me just another reason to force myself to go to the gym!!

I am actually a qualified personal fitness trainer, although I haven't worked in the industry for decades; but I still work in the healthcare industry so I know physios, speech therapists etc - I'll start picking their brains 🙂
I have post-grad qualification in Exercise Science. I coached elite middle and long distance runners for many years. My science degree means I tend to use the scientific method to investigate things. (I stopped formally coaching athletes decades ago).

Music teachers may be experts in music but others are experts in the physical conditioning needed for wind instruments. It only makes sense to consult the correct expert for the pertinent field.
 
I am actually a qualified personal fitness trainer
So this is probably a great example again, as to why a teacher, or instructor, can be a great idea.

I used to spend a lot of time running; and got into various stretching habits to help. But I did it all myself, looking stuff up online or from books. I got to the point where I was running a sub 44 minute 10k, which I was pretty happy with. But unfortunately because of certain issues with my physiology and having not spent time really working on my core, I ended up with am awful lot of pain in my left leg, a form a sciatica from my piriformis muscle being over large compared to other muscles that were underused. And so I had to let it all go to waste.

I'm sure that if I'd engaged with folk who understood how to run, how to build core strength and so on, that I might have had a more balanced exercise program that helped develop my core rather than just pure leg strength.

And that's sort of where I'm coming from with a sax teacher - a good one will nip bad habits in the bud, and help direct you to the right things to work on without introducing detrimental habits that may take years to undo.
 
So this is probably a great example again, as to why a teacher, or instructor, can be a great idea.

I used to spend a lot of time running; and got into various stretching habits to help. But I did it all myself, looking stuff up online or from books. I got to the point where I was running a sub 44 minute 10k, which I was pretty happy with. But unfortunately because of certain issues with my physiology and having not spent time really working on my core, I ended up with am awful lot of pain in my left leg, a form a sciatica from my piriformis muscle being over large compared to other muscles that were underused. And so I had to let it all go to waste.

I'm sure that if I'd engaged with folk who understood how to run, how to build core strength and so on, that I might have had a more balanced exercise program that helped develop my core rather than just pure leg strength.

And that's sort of where I'm coming from with a sax teacher - a good one will nip bad habits in the bud, and help direct you to the right things to work on without introducing detrimental habits that may take years to undo.
I'm coming round to the idea of having a teacher for a short time to ensure I am playing the instrument correctly, and then maybe having occasional lessons in the future if I get stuck. But really, my goal is to be able to play some tunes on the sax. I'm not looking to continually improve and be able to play complex pieces, just to be of a basic standard, and have fun.

I have found a teacher who I will contact soon - he plays in a rock band, and teaches all sorts of styles, so I think he would understand me more than teachers whose focus is to teach the more traditional way, if that makes sense?
 
I'm coming round to the idea of having a teacher for a short time to ensure I am playing the instrument correctly, and then maybe having occasional lessons in the future if I get stuck. But really, my goal is to be able to play some tunes on the sax. I'm not looking to continually improve and be able to play complex pieces, just to be of a basic standard, and have fun.

I have found a teacher who I will contact soon - he plays in a rock band, and teaches all sorts of styles, so I think he would understand me more than teachers whose focus is to teach the more traditional way, if that makes sense?
 
I'm coming round to the idea of having a teacher for a short time to ensure I am playing the instrument correctly, and then maybe having occasional lessons in the future if I get stuck. But really, my goal is to be able to play some tunes on the sax. I'm not looking to continually improve and be able to play complex pieces, just to be of a basic standard, and have fun.

I have found a teacher who I will contact soon - he plays in a rock band, and teaches all sorts of styles, so I think he would understand me more than teachers whose focus is to teach the more traditional way, if that makes sense?
I think everyone will concur with this approach!

I'm not looking to continually improve and be able to play complex pieces, just to be of a basic standard, and have fun.
Improving isn't always about playing something ever more complex/fast - it's about being able to do more with tunes rather than just the bare minimum. That's where much of the enjoyment comes from, hearing a nice tune being played nicely - friends and family potentially enjoying your rendition rather than enduring. 😉😀

- think of something like the alto sax lead in Henry Mancini's Lujon: beautiful sound, placement etc nothing fast or "technical".

View: https://youtu.be/RjsG3i6L9vw?si=Z7qEFaeCqNtBygB4
 
Last edited:
I think everyone will concur with this approach!
Not quite:
25353928._UY630_SR1200,630_.webp
 
I think everyone will concur with this approach!
Not quite. There are people who do perfectly fine without a teacher. I did some teaching once and remember one student who really didn't need lessons. he was perfectly capable of advancing without.
 
Not quite. There are people who do perfectly fine without a teacher. I did some teaching once and remember one student who really didn't need lessons. he was perfectly capable of advancing without.
Until he doesn’t. Then he’ll be better served by having a lesson or two.
Or a good conversation with a trusted fellow player - taking the part of teacher in this case. Doesn’t have to be formal.

You feel you added nothing as his teacher?? 😮
 
Last edited:
There are situations where a teacher is needed, classical playing, refining some technical issue, if you get to a stage where you are stuck or you've reached such a level that pro advice is the way to go.

Generally though I find this blanket response to newbies to get a teacher is just irritating. You don't need a teacher to get going and until you've got some hang of the instrument it's a waste of your time and money. The best way to learn and progress is by playing with others, what you will hear and what other players will tell you is where the real value is.

Sitting in a room with somebody who may, or may not, be able to spot what you need can be a depressingly easy way to spend money on something that isn't worth the price.

A teacher is not necessarily a magic bullet, and often they are just blanks.
 
AS i dont read music i found it difficult to find a teacher flexible enough to try my way of playing..even though i always took the music sheet..that said i have had to have lessons at varying poibts to overcome blocks..I feel the best time for one is when you know what you need from a lesson. Or are going the traditional route grades etc as a younger learner..
 
Some of us aren't able to learn by the formal way teachers teach and need to find our own way.
You know, there exist multiple teachers, with multiple ways of communicating and instructing. They don't all get the "this is the one true way" chip implanted.

Rather than throwing out the baby with the bathwater, it might be worth actually interviewing multiple instructors, pointing out one's own particular status, and ASKING "so, what would you sugggest for me?"
 
Generally though I find this blanket response to newbies to get a teacher is just irritating. You don't need a teacher to get going and until you've got some hang of the instrument
I have a swathe of anecdotes that refute this: a lot of people DO need a teacher to get going, and DO need a teacher to stop developing a whole load of habits that aren't conducive to learning the saxophone.

For example, someone who taped shut their front fork F because "it was making them squeak when they played a B". They had their fingers in completely the wrong place on the horn.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom