Saxophone beginners Where do I start? (complete beginner)

Personally I don't believe in traditional "student - sax teacher" teaching when it comes to adults. It's different with children.It's very strange for me that an adult person is "graded" when it's music education on voluntary basis.
I'm an adult. I have lessons from a number of teachers in different ways. "Grading" has never once been mentioned.

Why do you think that lessons/teachers mean that grading is required? I don't think anybody saying that having a teacher being the best way to get started equates that with playing through a series of grades and passing exams. 🤷‍♂️

It seems that you have a very narrow and specific perception of what a saxophone teacher is and what the resulting lessons and practise would look like..... I think you may find there is a whole world of other lessons and teaching available.
 
From the day one as sax honker I've been searching for input for my sax playing. Recordings, magazines, books, sax playing persons .... and I solve my "problems" with the info I got. I'm still doing this. That's how most people are working. When I say I'm self-learned I mean that I haven't haven't followed the traditional way like playing in concert bands or having sax lessons from a sax teacher. I took some lessons back in the mid 70's. I played football back then and I thought a teacher could help me to play more and in a more efficient way. It didn't turn out well for me. So without the blues and rock jam sessions in Copenhagen I would probably not been honking today.

I've been flourished with the saxophone for nearly 60 years. I've met lots a sax players/sax owners on different levels through the years. I'm a curious person, so I often ask questions. And they ask me questions. I don't think it's so special to play an instrument in the way I do. It's like playing football, hockey, cooking .... you need enthusiasm, dedication, some basic skills and to be in the right environment.

I made friend with a Rock & Roll saxophonist, Andrew Clark, who was writing in Saxophone Journal; "Rock & Roll Saxophone". Andrew was the leader at the workshops, I made them happen. I didn't play at the workshops. But I was there.

Personally I don't believe in traditional "student - sax teacher" teaching when it comes to adults. It's different with children.It's very strange for me that an adult person is "graded" when it's music education on voluntary basis.

I consider my self as an autodidact RockSax player. I don't believe in traditional saxophone teaching. I live in Sweden. You, Pete Effamy, prefer traditional sax teaching and you live in UK. That's great. A well educated sax teacher and a fine player and a woodshed honker (self-learned and not particular good as player) can work in the same direction to avoid that the sax depression is not going too deep. Maybe we shouldn't share the same "arena" to promote sax learning?
I haven’t said that I advocate everyone having the traditional teacher and student every week lesson Thom. I did, and I’m lucky to have lived in a part of the UK where standards across the board in teaching music are high and informed.

In fact, none of the others from my side of the fence have said that. What we do say is, don’t get bogged down and waste time when you could have the odd check-in with someone who can give informed advice. Nutshell.

You played football. All footballers have a coach at every level - there’s the parallel. You didn’t directly answer my post to you earlier about me saying that you were obviously not self-taught through all the Rock Sax sessions. They count as lessons.

The OP used Eric Clapton as an example for being self taught, but he went on the road with a great Blues band at an early age and cut his teeth there.

Other than that Thom, the sax has obviously been a fantastic companion for you for many years and that is fabulous.
 
I'm an adult. I have lessons from a number of teachers in different ways. "Grading" has never once been mentioned.

Why do you think that lessons/teachers mean that grading is required? I don't think anybody saying that having a teacher being the best way to get started equates that with playing through a series of grades and passing exams. 🤷‍♂️
I did mention it, but only as being part of the problem and an example of what isn’t great but it exists because of the way school music is set up and driven by “results on paper”.
 
I find it interesting gleening from comments of those in UK and others in US, CA. secondary school education varies accordingly. Perhaps more woodwind student musicians receive personal tutoring from a private personal instructor in UK?

I certainly cherish the personal instruction that I received. At the US Army Element, Naval School of Music in Nov. 1972 to May 1973 (6 months), as a young man just out of high school, I had a burly Navy Chief, Lani, who one on one, once a week gave me instruction during the first period in the morning, for an hour. This was my first private tutoring received.

He helped me to correct my intonation, to be able to express myself further on the various genres of music he put me through. Even though it was only 6 months, that helped me from that point on to launch me further in my woodwind musicianship.

I can imagine how those in college, who pursue a music degree benefit from a private tutoring class with one of their instructors.

Also what benefitted me was 3 periods daily of concert band. They would change the music every several days, to build up my sight reading ability. The military often may have a sight reading concert with the public. It is possible a last minute gig came up, with just time enough for the music librarian to stuff the music folders.

Compared with high school, we may only have a couple rehearsals at most before a performance.

An adult doesn't need constant tutoring, however, having one for a season can help immensely in furthering a person to perform that much better.
 
I haven’t said that I advocate everyone having the traditional teacher and student every week lesson Thom. I did, and I’m lucky to have lived in a part of the UK where standards across the board in teaching music are high and informed.

In fact, none of the others from my side of the fence have said that. What we do say is, don’t get bogged down and waste time when you could have the odd check-in with someone who can give informed advice. Nutshell.

You played football. All footballers have a coach at every level - there’s the parallel. You didn’t directly answer my post to you earlier about me saying that you were obviously not self-taught through all the Rock Sax sessions. They count as lessons.

The OP used Eric Clapton as an example for being self taught, but he went on the road with a great Blues band at an early age and cut his teeth there.

Other than that Thom, the sax has obviously been a fantastic companion for you for many years and that is fabulous.

Autodidatic/self-learning means to acquire knowledge/skills without getting them through formal education. A keen interest in education without guided instruction, high self-motivation, the pursuit of unconcern with institutions ........

I just want to say that it's possible to learn to play the saxophone without lessons from a teacher. The OP wrote that she didn't want a teacher.

Most of things I like to do are self-learned. And when I was young there were no adults involved when I/we played football in the garden, pond hockey ...... .

I disagree with your definition of what is a lesson. Phone calls to friends on the other side of the pond and talking about RockSax music, or to auscultate a RockSax workshop ..... count as lessons?!?!?!?!
 
Autodidatic/self-learning means to acquire knowledge/skills without getting them through formal education. A keen interest in education without guided instruction, high self-motivation, the pursuit of unconcern with institutions ........

I just want to say that it's possible to learn to play the saxophone without lessons from a teacher. The OP wrote that she didn't want a teacher.

Most of things I like to do are self-learned. And when I was young there were no adults involved when I/we played football in the garden, pond hockey ...... .

I disagree with your definition of what is a lesson. Phone calls to friends on the other side of the pond and talking about RockSax music, or to auscultate a RockSax workshop ..... count as lessons?!?!?!?!
You've long talked about Rock Sax workshops - it's not information passed on by someone with knowledge?

Why are we getting into "teacher" definitions? All I'm sayings is:

there are many ways to get stuck that could seriously curtail your enjoyment of whatever your journey with music might be. It doesn't have to be so. Take advice, at least occasionally. Yes, it might take the form of a phone call if you like.
 
I hope @annw is laughing in between playing of course..are you still there, hows it going..My personal feeling goes along with @Pete Effamy , in the words of the blues brothers " everybody needs somebody".. guess the cafe is a form of lesson too..I to agree with @thomsax that you can self teach i think traditional methods work for traditional players...there has to be some kind of grading to establish progress..I think it would be nice if there was an alternative approach to lessons..For me reading music or should i say playing from music sheets hasnt been imporrtant..I wont ever play in an orchestra, or band but just do my singalong sax as a fund raiser..certain elements of music are pertnent I need to transpose, and convert music into my condensed format..but backing tracks are my timing the length of a crotchet or quaver isn't so important..For me look at your goal work out how to achieve it and find someone to help if needed..thats hard..at the moment im stuck on improvising over the instrumentals and outros not ssure anyone can teach that..
 
Why not? Good teachers can teach, whether the student learns is up to them.
Good morning..always prepared to learn @Pete Thomas..not found anyone who can teach this..still looking.. I know keys, pentatonics, blues, always write down the notes of the scale on my lyric sheet, relative minor and as above..Do you not think that some things just take time..guess it delves into playing by ear..
 
Yes everything takes time. I was just commenting on your statement about people not being able to teach impro.
I agree. If we are all agreed that someone can “teach”/ advise you on the makeup of a scale or any series of notes, then you can certainly be taught to use them in varying orders.
 
Good morning..always prepared to learn @Pete Thomas..not found anyone who can teach this..still looking.. I know keys, pentatonics, blues, always write down the notes of the scale on my lyric sheet, relative minor and as above..Do you not think that some things just take time..guess it delves into playing by ear..
But you can be taught to play by ear, and learn to hear what sounds are. You have to practise that, and train your ear to hear them, and methods and ways of doing this effectively can be taught.

Personally, I believe everything in life is actually taught to people. Walking is taught by the simple act of walking about in front of a child, talking is taught by the simple act of speaking in front of a child. Behaviour is taught. Reading is taught. Music is taught by singing to children when they're small. Nobody starts in isolation.
; we all imitate others. All a teacher does is help you by pointing out things to imitate in a more structured manner.

Learning to improvise is no different than learning to compose; it's just composing in the moment.
 
You've long talked about Rock Sax workshops - it's not information passed on by someone with knowledge?

Yes, I like RockSax Workshops (group "teaching"). Life is full of "knowledge, skills, experience ...... transfer". Everyday we learn something new and most of the times is not a teacher - student situation. I led some workshops on my own .... and they went out quiet well.

The OP wrote that she wanted to learn without a teacher. I liked that, still do. Then some members began to talk her into "sign up". Why didn't we respect the OP's standpoint?
 
Yes, I like RockSax Workshops (group "teaching"). Life is full of "knowledge, skills, experience ...... transfer". Everyday we learn something new and most of the times is not a teacher - student situation. I led some workshops on my own .... and they went out quiet well.

The OP wrote that she wanted to learn without a teacher. I liked that, still do. Then some members began to talk her into "sign up". Why didn't we respect the OP's standpoint?
Because of the words “where do I start”…
 
Yes, I like RockSax Workshops (group "teaching"). Life is full of "knowledge, skills, experience ...... transfer". Everyday we learn something new and most of the times is not a teacher - student situation. I led some workshops on my own .... and they went out quiet well.

The OP wrote that she wanted to learn without a teacher. I liked that, still do. Then some members began to talk her into "sign up". Why didn't we respect the OP's standpoint?
Because i think tradition dictates..Not a bad thing but a thing none the less...most of the teachers ive had have been to uni or a conservatoire and the cycle continues..both have been flexible and helped and its good to have the ability when stuck to go and see someone..their msin strengths have been jazz focused..rock workshops or any workshops sound brilliant. Any ive wanted to attend you have to be at least grade 3...its frustrating..
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom