Saxophone beginners Where do I start? (complete beginner)

Hope Annw feels welcome..we seemed to have lost sight of her thread and spent 6 pages debating the pros and cons of a tutor. She mentions fun and the fact that she has bought some guidance from online..she says that she isn't oppossed to lessons but might it be good to start the journey so as she knows what she needs help with..isn't the usual advice a Yamaha 4 or 5 c mouthpiece and a selection of 1 5 to 2 reeds just to get going..enjoy your journey @annw..
I know what you’re saying Eddie, but isn’t that the crux of what we’re debating - don’t toil away and chuck the thing because you hate it?
 
I know what you’re saying Eddie, but isn’t that the crux of what we’re debating - don’t toil away and chuck the thing because you hate it?
Hey couldn't agree more..It takes commitment to learn the sax for me a tutor is commitment but i feel that annw is a stage behind. The naive having fun part before it grabs you by the googles..Bet if you ask her in a month shed be looking for a tutor because she will know what she needs..I dont necessarrily think having a teacher stops people giving up..I think thats the sax..also the cost of lessons is or can be an issue..I know the investment teachers put in and the cost but if you set your goal at the beginning as playing for fun lessons can not seem worth it..though of course they are when your stuck..
 
Last edited:
I'm surprised that no one has suggested "buy a Buescher".
Play tunes in a week.

1000001707.webp
 
With a teacher you don't get the nice feeling that you get when you have done something on your own. I know many good players who are self-taught. I talked with other players about alternative fingerings, reeds, tone/sound ..... so I'm not 100% self-learned. A young sax player needs a teacher more than an adult. Playing an instrument should, IMO, lead to some kind of "independence". As sax player we had to deal with many questions that we had to solve on your own. Bad habits can be very refreshing in the perfect music world.
 
With a teacher you don't get the nice feeling that you get when you have done something on your own. I know many good players who are self-taught. I talked with other players about alternative fingerings, reeds, tone/sound ..... so I'm not 100% self-learned. A young sax player needs a teacher more than an adult. Playing an instrument should, IMO, lead to some kind of "independence". As sax player we had to deal with many questions that we had to solve on your own. Bad habits can be very refreshing in the perfect music world.
I disagree. A good teacher shows you the possible, you still have to put the effort in and get that sense of achievement. And also can open eyes to things that would never discover yourself.

On top of that, and something I've reiterated here several times, just because you have one or more teachers, doesn't preclude from still looking into other aspects of the saxophone that they aren't covering right now. You're free to do all that self learning as well!
 
Of course everyone benefits from havng someone more experienced to learn from..The cost puts people off ,£50 here for 45 mins..If youre young and going to to be the next Dexter sure invest in yourself you have to. The joy of sax is that there are many ways to learn you have to find your own path.. I play to backing tracks Ive had 20 lessons or so but can honestly say to date only 3 have been worthwhile..Teachers ive had have been flexible but probably only 3 lessons have taught me anything..Ive probably got a greater need for lessons now after 8 years playing.

I can play tunes and am taking the singalong a sax forward.Ive done 2 fund raisers now and raised 1k for charity..its fun..For me group learning would reduce the cost of learning ive tried to start over the hall but theres little to no interest..you can always see a guitar player in a pub but the sax is less well promoted..It would be great if the cafe did a fund raiser for the cafe a small roadshow raising money and showing what the sax can do...
 
I disagree. A good teacher shows you the possible, you still have to put the effort in and get that sense of achievement. And also can open eyes to things that would never discover yourself.

On top of that, and something I've reiterated here several times, just because you have one or more teachers, doesn't preclude from still looking into other aspects of the saxophone that they aren't covering right now. You're free to do all that self learning as well!

I think all kind of teaching/instructing should have a goal. Not a vision! A goal next week, next month ..... . I met an adult sax player that have been taking sax lessons for many years. Just playing from a book with his teacher!! Once a week for many years. I invited him to our RockSax meetings. He told me he was not ready!!! Soo sad.

I remember the good feeling I had after my first Blues & Rock Jam. I took the ferry from Scania to greater Copenhagen to play at Blues & Rock Jam. I learned a lot on these Saturday afternoons. Things that a teacher can't teach. Also friendly and honest comments from most of the musicians. Good tips from older sax players, and the other musicians as well.

Maybe the right teacher would be ideal for me. A Rock & Roll Saxophone teacher. The other things I learned without a teacher.
 
I met an adult sax player that have been taking sax lessons for many years. Just playing from a book with his teacher!!
Those of us who advocate having a teacher/mentor/experienced friend to give advice are not advocating finding an old-fashioned by-the-book teacher.

It seems to me that argument against a teacher/guide/coach always seems to involve worst-case scenarios.

All I/we are trying to do is keep you going, get the best out of it, don’t “descend into a sax-depression “ through being right royally stuck or going down the wrong route since forever.

Thom, I also think you’re on my side of the argument actually because you’re not really self-taught are you - lots of Rock Sax workshops and this guy and that guy - it’s a hive of a learning community, not a lonesome shed.

Reminds me of a quote from Richard Bach:

“Argue for your limitations and, sure enough, they’re yours”
 
By and large a full-time teacher will be teaching age 8 - 18 (maybe, not always the whole school age range) and will have to be results driven, and also be expected to deliver all players into the school ensembles.

This will mainly point towards an exam-based learning. If you find a teacher like this you are likely to get these lessons. It’s good time-honoured grounding but it might not be what you want.

Then you’ll be better off with maybe a “gigging” player or a pro player. Some pro players make terrible teachers. Some instrument owners make terrible students.

Certainly on a forum, you can ask if anyone can recommend a teacher from their area - you never know. We all go on recommendation for electricians, plumbers, builders, mechanics etc and recognise that some are awful. What we don’t do is never engage another mechanic because the first guy never fixed the problem
 
Ive probably got a greater need for lessons now after 8 years playing.
I have a greater need for lessons and mentorship and guidance after 30 years playing. I find, as with many things, the more I know, the better I get, the more I realise how much I don't know.

£50 for 45 minutes is steep. You can have an hour online with Dean Masser for £40; Iain Dixon charges £75 for an hour and a half.

But I also agree with @Pete Effamy here, those advocating against lessons only seem to take a worst case scenario view. I'm almost inclined to create a poll - to find out who has had lessons, how frequently they had those lessons (or are still having them) and so on. If I was being cynical, I'd imagine that many of those advocating against them haven't had many, if any.
 
Of course everyone benefits from havng someone more experienced to learn from..The cost puts people off ,£50 here for 45 mins..If youre young and going to to be the next Dexter sure invest in yourself you have to. The joy of sax is that there are many ways to learn you have to find your own path.. I play to backing tracks Ive had 20 lessons or so but can honestly say to date only 3 have been worthwhile..Teachers ive had have been flexible but probably only 3 lessons have taught me anything..Ive probably got a greater need for lessons now after 8 years playing.

I can play tunes and am taking the singalong a sax forward.Ive done 2 fund raisers now and raised 1k for charity..its fun..For me group learning would reduce the cost of learning ive tried to start over the hall but theres little to no interest..you can always see a guitar player in a pub but the sax is less well promoted..It would be great if the cafe did a fund raiser for the cafe a small roadshow raising money and showing what the sax can do...

To learn to play the saxophone is nowadays a matter of money/paying. It's been like this for many years but today I see a new type of hobby players (not only sax players) who are willing to pay 4000.00 - 5000.00 s e k for Rock ensemble (4-8 persons/group, once a week over 10 weeks). No problem to get participants and the music teacher is doing a fine job ..... but who took Blues and Rock 'n' Roll out of Rock?

We need new ways to learn to play. I'm going to do some on-line Rock ensemble with my
friend (professional Rock sax player and music teacher). I must have a long cable from the woodshed to the router and get better equipment to pick up the noise, and moves, the bands are making. 1-2 hours/group. From 6.00-8.00 pm our time (12.00. 2.00 pm east coast time). 90% of the playing the band do on it's own. Free for the participants. The only condition; 100 % Blues and Rock & Roll, must be able to play a 8 bar rocksax solo or play the intro chord to Berrys " No Particular Place to Go " on guitar ....... I have to see how this will turn out?
 
Last edited:
The whole idea of a teacher is to be a guide, a motivator, to move players in the right direction, all the work is still done by the player, this is why when kids are 4yrs old they go to school and learn, its not perfect but it is still the way to go, I also think that online learning has a place.
£850 down the drain - far more than I've got to throw away out of my pension.
It doesn't matter what you do in life there is always a cost, true some can afford things better than others, but nothing free theses days.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom