- Messages
- 2,778
- Location
- Black Forest
No, I answered your direct question to me, just like now, a matter of courtesy.And so your retort here falls under the same piling on..... 😉

No, I answered your direct question to me, just like now, a matter of courtesy.And so your retort here falls under the same piling on..... 😉

They may well have, as they’ve certainly put in more time (and maybe had the time to work through those problems).Absolutely. But pros - and most talented amateur/semi-pros - have not, for the most part, encountered the problems of late starters. People who haven't played music, maybe, since they where a kid if ever... But has learned about themselves, how they learn etc.
A really good teacher understands that. But a lot of teachers are just surviving between proper work.
If I didn't know better I'd think you were being deliberately obtuse.There is a huge difference, I can look at online material at my leisure and without pressure and fear of embarrassment, no cutting my day in half because I had to take that personal lesson. And, there is a risk of misunderstanding the one or other thing or getting hung up on a specific word, which is why I referenced @skeller047 's post for alternative ways of teaching the same thing.
Yes, there will be a point where a personal interaction with other sax players will prove beneficial but OP or Ann appears to be a smart person who can figure things out by herself. And for sure I had enough bad teachers in my life to understand why she rather goes her own way.
Yep this.I can’t get past the notion that “not everyone needs a teacher “ = “I don’t need advice from anyone “
That's not the same thing. The first one does not exclude the possibility of taking advice, most likely from several people instead of following a single person's idea of how to go about a specific subject.I can’t get past the notion that “not everyone needs a teacher “ = “I don’t need advice from anyone “
Almost everyone does!Also, it’s interesting how most self-taught, and taught players argue for their own “upbringing “
I thought we’d already labelled this as “teaching “. The OP seems to suggest other - but I could have misunderstoodThe first one does not exclude the possibility of taking advice, most likely from several people instead of following a single person's idea of how to go about a specific subject.
Maybe, but you never had any of my teachers. Which is an impasse 😀Someone who thinks what worked for them, aged 10, will work for someone aged 60 may well be making a mistake
"No cutting my day in half to take that personal lesson"? You have to take the time to watch the video content you shared. There's little difference from a time perspective.
Maybe, just maybe, the fact that the overwhelming recommendation is in favor of quality in-person instruction ( not just any in-person instructor), might be a hint of something?I wasn't referring to your responses as piling on. Piling is all the "get a teacher" posts. It's a collective action.
Well, it's a sample size of one, but I will say that I learned piano and flute the standard way, starting at age 9; it worked OK; I learned saxophone almost 100% self-taught (and even then, I already had a solid background in music theory, reading, and some of general wind instrument practice with flute, started saxophone at 16; and I learned double-bass starting at 50 with traditional instruction.Almost everyone does!
And that's a problem. Ability to learn changes radically in different phases of life for all sorts of things; languages, physical movement; and probably many aspects of music.
Someone who thinks what worked for them, aged 10, will work for someone aged 60 may well be making a mistake.
Sure. What worked for you aged 9 worked for you after 40 years of playing music. But isn't compatible with someone else who picks up playing music aged 50.Well, it's a sample size of one
Did you ask?I just have trouble understanding why...
But that's one of the key issues. I bought my first sax from a music (saxophone) teacher who's passing words were "keep in mind that unlike a guitar with several strings, there is only one fingering for every note. Luckily I came across Randy Hunter's YouTube video about the 5 different fingerings to play bis, which probably saved me a bunch of trips to take the guy up on his offer to give me lessons.Maybe, just maybe, the fact that the overwhelming recommendation is in favor of quality in-person instruction ( not just any in-person instructor), might be a hint of something?
Whoever said taking lessons means going to a single teacher, and only one teacher? This past year I've had lessons with two saxophonists, one pianist (a saxophone/jazz lesson) and a member of two online teaching groups.That's not the same thing. The first one does not exclude the possibility of taking advice, most likely from several people instead of following a single person's idea of how to go about a specific subject.
In academic study, sure. But not in all things that are physical. Nobody is going to get you work out belaying for yourself, for example; they'll show you how to do it and make sure you can do it before they let you belay someone whilst climbing. If not, someone has an accident....The primary role of a teacher should be to instill interest and enthusiasm for the subject and THEN show the ways to accomplish it.
