Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

If you mean a tune that someone sings to me and I have to play it on the saxophone, I wouldn't call it improvisation.

This for me is playing by ear

If I am playing something that nobody heard before, not even myself, I'd call it improvisation.

But surely there is a connection here to playing by ear?

You must be able to connect what you hear in your head with the notes/fingering and/or the chords you are playing over?

Jx
 
I think that there is a difference between playing by heart (from memory?) Or playing by ear.
I think that playing by ear must be playing from memory: you play what you remember as the tune. But playing from memory surely also including remembering where your fingers go for a certain tune. It may also include remebering the dots and playing those. A case of, all elephants are animals but not all animals are elephants.
 
It's quite interresting how the 2 words Improvisation, and Composition, is in an eternal fight about in which one of the symbols, creativity "should" belong or originated from for that matter.

It seems there's good argument for both being equivalant sources of creativity, just as there is good argument for the highly theoretical musician(reading musician) to make good music, so there is for the self-taught/improvising(ear player) musician to make good music.
 
It's quite interresting how the 2 words Improvisation, and Composition, is in an eternal fight about in which one of the symbols, creativity "should" belong or originated from for that matter.

It seems there's good argument for both being equivalant sources of creativity, just as there is good argument for the highly theoretical musician(reading musician) to make good music, so there is for the self-taught/improvising(ear player) musician to make good music.

Even more: performing, say, Bach's cello suites can be equally creative, if it allows the performer to "say" something (apart from the fact that he/she/it has technical skills)
Creativity can hide in many places. Art, instead, requires some craft skills too, to put creativity in the best context. When we think of Michelangelo...

But I can see this debate steering on philosophy that, as everybody knows, is unsuitable for a British based forum. 🙂
 
Thinking about it. What you must have is an excellent and intuitive appreciation of intervals.
Yes, learn your intervals. I think we should be careful of that word "intuitive". It makes it sound like it can't be learnt. I've spent a fair amount of time on this over the last few years (seems to me if you can't do this you can't hope to improvise fluently) and have improved quite a bit. If I know the tune well (by sound, ie i can sing it) and it doesn't change key too much (eg Christmas carols) I can usually have a pretty good go at playing it first time now. I was rubbish at at first. Ear training helps a lot.
 
Yes, learn your intervals. I think we should be careful of that word "intuitive". It makes it sound like it can't be learnt. I've spent a fair amount of time on this over the last few years (seems to me if you can't do this you can't hope to improvise fluently) and have improved quite a bit. If I know the tune well (by sound, ie i can sing it) and it doesn't change key too much (eg Christmas carols) I can usually have a pretty good go at playing it first time now. I was rubbish at at first. Ear training helps a lot.

Intuitive used because I have never known if it can be learned. I looked at some tests on the web once, I could not believe that I, so musical from birth etc etc get a tune out of a cheese sandwich etc, could have such a pathetic score. I can look for a note down from a reference note when it is really up. How is that? Ok, I cant get a tune out of sandwich but I am quite, well, musical. I suppose its a big subject and I good at some things, very good at others, and the pits on pitch. I have been thinking of revisiting this subject, maybe I should do that. I have to get a guy in the band to give me a note and a nod when I am in tune. I can do it with a tuner of course but I can barely see the thing when its near the bell and frankly, this guy's ear is better.

Or in this case, mind's ear. And the answer is yes. You can train just about anything.

I would have to agree with this in my experience of things that I have tackled so far. But how to train an ear or a minds eye is a bit daunting to someone who has a dozen guitar tuners, always looking for the one that will be as good as a good ear. To harp (ha ha) back to guitar, there are some shapes that are not possible for some individuals, the stretch is too much or the finger wont bend, whatever. But fact is if you practice these things you get there. I have always fallen back on blind faith for these impossible things because I know it can be done. My ear I have more doubt about.

I heard that, pardon. (what sitcome was that from?)
Mike
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom