Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

... and then COMPOSE AND MEMORISE HIS IMPROVISATION.

Don't mock guys. That could be me 🙂 (And a thousand others.)

The trouble with not having the basic tools off pat, not having the aural skills, having always relied on reading, and not being the kind of person to have music sprouting in your head at the relevant time, is you don't have much alternative.

You know its not the right way to go about it but what else are you to do if you have to be ready for next week's class?
 
You know its not the right way to go about it but what else are you to do if you have to be ready for next week's class?

I was talking to one of the non-improvisers after the final workshop, trying to figure out what else he could do, seeing that the 20 hours of workshop hadn't helped at all. I asked him if he ever sings to himself, and he looked at me as if I had said something ridiculous.

Do you sing to yourself jadoube? That's one of the first things I would do when I'm learning a new tune. Listen to it until you can sing it. Then you can trying singing improvisations.
 
Well, if you have a pencil and a piece of paper, you can draw something.
Maybe ugly the first time, but things will improve. You don't need hundreds of colours or mastering perspective.

If you have 7 available notes that are never harmonically "wrong", you can create melodic fragments. At least participants at the London and Manchester workshops did.
 
I was talking to one of the non-improvisers after the final workshop, trying to figure out what else he could do, seeing that the 20 hours of workshop hadn't helped at all. I asked him if he ever sings to himself, and he looked at me as if I had said something ridiculous.

Do you sing to yourself jadoube? That's one of the first things I would do when I'm learning a new tune. Listen to it until you can sing it. Then you can trying singing improvisations.

I'm not a singing aloud person, one of my weaknesses unfortunately. In the situation you describe I'd not have looked as if you'd said something ridiculous, I'd have shamefacedly confessed I didn't sing.

I will listen repeatedly to a new tune when I'm learning it, and I'll try to learn the words, which I find is helpful. I 'sing' internally when playing it.

I agree that if I did sing it could well make things a lot easier for me
 
I will listen repeatedly to a new tune when I'm learning it, and I'll try to learn the words, which I find is helpful. I 'sing' internally when playing it.

I agree that if I did sing it could well make things a lot easier for me

Do you sing internally when you're not playing? When you're just walking about or doing the washing up I mean. Could you sing aloud, if there was nobody else around?
 
That brings to mind the famous line by Aled Thomas:

"If a pianist plays in a hotel lounge, and nobody listens, does he really make a sound?"

Back to improvisation, we all improvise whem we talk. Some know less words or have an Italian accent, but we improvise.
 
we all improvise whem we talk. Some know less words or have an Italian accent, but we improvise.
Exactly, that's a great way of putting it, right now I'm improvising, I'm just writing letters down and making them into words and trying to express some kind of idea that's in my head to answer this thread. I've been learning words all my life so I've got quite a few of them at my disposal that I can use to get some kind of idea across. When I improvise musically it's the same thing, there might be a thread of an idea that I want to get out through the saxophone or whatever instrument it is that I'm playing so I just draw on all the musical vocabulary that I've accumulated and pick out the notes and make phrases and sentences, paragraphs and chapters of sound. Bla bla blackship have you any wool, no but I've got a light mac and I just ran out of water . . . good night.
 
I never said I have never set foot in a music classroom or taken music lessons. As it happens I have had lessons, I can read music, I can play Bach on the piano from music.

I could understand all the theory the tutor at the improvisation workshop threw at us: I just don't use that theory at all when I am playing jazz on the sax, and I don't think it helped my fellow course members at all.
I would ask myself one question. "Can the tutor at the improvisation workshop improvise better than I can?" If the answer is yes, then I would at least try to implement some of the ideas being taught rather than reject them out of hand and just play the way I have always played. Why attend a workshop in the first place if you are just going to dismiss everything being presented anyway? That doesn't make any sense to me.
 
Exactly, that's a great way of putting it, right now I'm improvising, I'm just writing letters down and making them into words and trying to express some kind of idea that's in my head to answer this thread. I've been learning words all my life so I've got quite a few of them at my disposal that I can use to get some kind of idea across. When I improvise musically it's the same thing, there might be a thread of an idea that I want to get out through the saxophone or whatever instrument it is that I'm playing so I just draw on all the musical vocabulary that I've accumulated and pick out the notes and make phrases and sentences, paragraphs and chapters of sound. Bla bla blackship have you any wool, no but I've got a light mac and I just ran out of water . . . good night.
And it's this kind of improvisation that's musically boring. Doesn't say anything, just wastes time.

If someone's improvising, I want to hear them take the tune and say something, not mindlessly regurgitate. For me, as a listener, theory is just one of the bases on which improve can come from.

I find theory only based improve unpleasant - there's no message, just sterile rule following. Like the difference between a great orator and someone reading a speech. You can see the tricks - time to get louder/quieter. Pause for emphasis... But an orator senses the mood of the audience, the message in the text and does all of this and more - completely naturally. Same with music and improv.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom