Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

I looked at some tests on the web once, I could not believe that I, so musical from birth etc etc get a tune out of a cheese sandwich etc, could have such a pathetic score.
The thing is, not to take it as an insult and get discouraged. Just be honest with yourself. This is where I'm at now, and I'll chip away at the frontiers of what I can't do until I can. This site has some good ear tests:

https://www.teoria.com/en/exercises/

I've been working with a program called EarMaster. Not too expensive and pretty good IMO.

I have to get a guy in the band to give me a note and a nod when I am in tune.
Very much what I used to do when I played clarinet in a past life. You can sort of get away with it, but you know you're not really doing it properly and it undermines your confidence.

My ear I have more doubt about.
We are all taught (at least subliminally) from an early age that you need talent to play music and if you haven't got it you never will have. It's nonsense. Western 12-tone music is a really unnatural thing to do. What were all the "gifted" pianists doing before the piano was invented? Since I took up the sax about five years ago I decided to make my ear as good as I could. It's now much better than I thought it could be, and still improving. I'd like it to be better than it is now so I'm still working on it.
 
There is no real mystery or even difficulty to "playing by ear" in my experience. For me it is hearing a tune over and over until it is in my head, and then "figuring it out" on the saxophone without having to refer to a written page of music. The figuring it out doesn't need to be fast or spontaneous. Often it is done by bits and pieces a little bit at a time.

I grew up in a small town where the closest music store was 200 miles away, and of course there was no internet. If I wanted to play a tune, I couldn't just go out and buy the music. After I had learned most of the notes and keys on my saxophone when I heard a song like "Take Five" on the radio, I bought the record and learned to play the melody a few notes at a time by hearing it over and over again. Eventually, I could play right along with Paul Desmond picking up his tone and style as I went along. I did the same with Stan Getz's Desifinato, Plas Johnson's The Pink Panther, and Boots Randolph's Yakkety Sax. The more I did it, the easier it got.

After a while I began to think in terms of musical intervals which opened the door to playing tunes in different keys than the one I learned them in. My advice to anyone wanting to learn to play by ear is to start with Twinkle Twinkle Little Star and go on from there.
Funny you should suggest Twinkle Twinkle etc, only yesterday my tutor gave me an exercise which is to work out the notes for TT! Had a little fiddle about with it and so far it is not really "Twinkling!" Have another go later this afternoon!
 
I think playing music is a skill which can be taught and learned. In my experience there are many skilled musicians who enjoy playing and are pleasing to listen to. The talented ones who don't put in the work don't seem to get very far. Musicians who study hard, put in the hours of practice and stick at it for decades are classed as "gifted".

Who was it that said "The more I practice the more talented I seem." Or did I make that up?

To get good at something you need to enjoy doing it. That way you'll put in the hours.
 
I think playing music is a skill which can be taught and learned. In my experience there are many skilled musicians who enjoy playing and are pleasing to listen to. The talented ones who don't put in the work don't seem to get very far. Musicians who study hard, put in the hours of practice and stick at it for decades are classed as "gifted".

Who was it that said "The more I practice the more talented I seem." Or did I make that up?

To get good at something you need to enjoy doing it. That way you'll put in the hours.
Gary Player the Golfer once said "the more I practise the luckier I get" !!!
 
There was an item on the news this morning about a guy having laser surgery to his brain to remove a tumour. They had him awake and singing to make sure his language centre wasn't damaged. I've seen something similar with a guy playing banjo. I can't remember if they were trying to miss or hit the banjo part of the brain . However it seems that musical skills reside in the communication section of the brain. So it's a language.
 
We are all taught (at least subliminally) from an early age that you need talent to play music and if you haven't got it you never will have. It's nonsense. Western 12-tone music is a really unnatural thing to do. What were all the "gifted" pianists doing before the piano was invented? Since I took up the sax about five years ago I decided to make my ear as good as I could. It's now much better than I thought it could be, and still improving. I'd like it to be better than it is now so I'm still working on it.

Nature vs nurture? Or perhaps better, nature and nurture Nature provides us with a great many abilities, a lot of which we never take advantage of. Nurture pushes us in certain directions where we naturally develop them so we think we have a natural ability. Sometimes through more or less random events we change direction and discover talents we never knew we had.
 
You can train just about anything.

I've always thought that because of its intuitive nature anyone can learn and more importantly enjoy mathematics.

When I express this thought out loud I am deafened by cries of rubbish, "I hated maths at school", "maths is too difficult", "normal people can't do maths", "cool people don't do maths" and variations of my parents, friends, school mates all said maths is hard.

I agree you ought to be able to train just about anything ... its just there is this great big hurdle that needs to be overcome first. And I have to ask why the hurdle is so prevalent in our society. Perhaps it means that in practice you can't train some things?


As an experiment - how many would say that maths is easy and anyone can learn maths?

Substitute 'maths' for 'ear training' or 'improvisation' and re-consider this thread. Is it now easier to understand people who say these things are too difficult for ordinary mortals. And possibly easier to understand those who say anyone can learn with enough practice. 🙂
 

🙂

Precisely. Does learning maths have limits ... but learning to play music does not?

As a very inadequate musician I am in the position of the "I can't do maths" person reading posts from people who appear to find instinctive stuff that I find impossible. And reading advice like just give to a go, its easy once you try, it will come in time, and suchlike. (OK I'm exaggerating a lot for effect but...)

From observing my children I have an inkling as to how maths can get to be hard for some who are perfectly capable of doing it. But applying that to my own learning of music is another thing entirely.

Have yet to find a teacher able to get around the block in my learning and read these threads in the desperate hope I might find it.

Is it accepted that however motivated, however well taught, however much they practice ... there are people ( the majority of people) who will never be able to play by ear, sight read fluently etc? If so it should be said more openly, if not there seems to be a huge gap in addressing the issue.

After all playing music (and maths) tends to be extremely self selecting. A huge proportion of the public never dream of going there, so the teachers start with a cherry-picked set of students. (At least in terms of adult pupils.) One might therefore expect very high success rates.


There's a gauntlet for all the teachers 🙂
 
Last edited:
🙂

Indeed. My point - does maths have limits that learning to play music does not?
My secondary school math program got up to derivatives, some combinatory, some inductive reasoning (at 19 I could do these).
Much more articulated than any music theory, that can be sorted in one or two books.
Music theory is just a bunch of instructions to describe existing compositions and allow the student to do the same.
Applying those concepts takes a lifetime, though.
 
My secondary school math program got up to derivatives, some combinatory, some inductive reasoning (at 19 I could do these).
Much more articulated than any music theory, that can be sorted in one or two books.
Music theory is just a bunch of instructions to describe existing compositions and allow the student to do the same.
Applying those concepts takes a lifetime, though.


Sorry edited to expand my post while you were replying.

The stuff you could do at 19 is well beyond the average level of achievement in maths. That puts you alongside me with at least one foot in the maths was easy camp. 🙂

Maths does tend to build on layers of what went before, so I suspect people fall by the wayside early on. in the case of my daughter a weeks illness at late primary school created a gap in skill sets that left her unable to implement the more complex maths taught 5 years later ... despite her clearly understanding the complex concepts perfectly she couldn't complete the simple working out to show it.. And no amount of effort seemed able to fix that gap. She had become blind to the simplest algebra and beleived 'maths is difficult'.

I think the same can happen with music, and teachers find it very difficult to fix.
 
I've always thought that because of its intuitive nature anyone can learn and more importantly enjoy mathematics.
I'm not so sure aboput the "enjoy" part. If you don't enjoy learning it, you won't work at it so you won't learn it. There has to be some motivation there to start with. Unfortunately I think that gets squashed early on for a lot of people.

When I express this thought out loud I am deafened by cries of rubbish, "I hated maths at school", "maths is too difficult", "normal people can't do maths", "cool people don't do maths" and variations of my parents, friends, school mates all said maths is hard.
Yes there is a lot of prejusdice to be overcome. Nobody says to musicians " I hated music at school".

As an experiment - how many would say that maths is easy and anyone can learn maths?
Well I'd say that, like music, it's not easy until you make it so by learning it and training yourself to do it. But yes, I think anyone (barring physical brain abnormalities) can learn it if they have both the motivation and the belief that it's possible. I think the latter is important. I never quite "made it" as a mathematician, because I had a crisis of confidence at the post-doc stage. If I was in that position again, I hope I'd have the self-belief to work patiently through the stuff I was struggling with. That's what I'm doing now (at a much lower level) with music.

Substitute 'maths' for 'ear training' or 'improvisation' and re-consider this thread. Is it now easier to understand people who say these things are too difficult for ordinary mortals. And possibly easier to understand those who say anyone can learn with enough practice. 🙂
Agreed.
 
My secondary school math program got up to derivatives, some combinatory, some inductive reasoning (at 19 I could do these).
Much more articulated than any music theory, that can be sorted in one or two books.
Music theory is just a bunch of instructions to describe existing compositions and allow the student to do the same.
Applying those concepts takes a lifetime, though.
Sounds about right to me. There's much more theory to learn in mathematics --- more than anyone can lean in one lifetime, you have to specialise. But the gap between learning the theory and being able to apply it is much smaller in maths than in music.
 
When I was 16 a maths teacher said "you are going to fail your exams unless something changes" and he (very kindly) offered to give me some extra tuition. After three of these sessions he told me "you seem to have a mental block" and he gave up. For several years after that I would avoid any maths, saying "I have a mental block". Then one day I saw book in the library called "Why Are You Afraid Of Maths?" and that explained to me why I was afraid of maths, and I stopped being afraid of it and I did take some exams.
 
I've been thinking a lot about this discussion over the last few months while I've been sitting in a weekly improvisation workshop, listening to the tutor talking endlessly about what notes are in each chord and what scale you should play with that chord. I don't believe any of the participants made any progress with improvisation as a result of these workshops. I just carried on improvising the way I always do, embroidering the tune, making up little phrases that match the chord sequence, and the people who look at the dots just kept looking at the dots, not really daring to improvise.

We would tackle just one tune a week, which I found tedious, so I suggested we might try two tunes. One of the other participants objected strongly to this: his reason was that it takes him a whole week to analyse the tune, work out what scales fit where, and then COMPOSE AND MEMORISE HIS IMPROVISATION.
 
Allow me to clarify my remark. Making broad assumptions about how beginners are taught when one has never set foot in a music classroom or taken music lessons is both ill informed and presumptuous in my opinion.

I never said I have never set foot in a music classroom or taken music lessons. As it happens I have had lessons, I can read music, I can play Bach on the piano from music.

I could understand all the theory the tutor at the improvisation workshop threw at us: I just don't use that theory at all when I am playing jazz on the sax, and I don't think it helped my fellow course members at all.
 
I think as so far I have really only played by following a sheet of music apart from a couple of attempts at IOTM this has to be my next step, twinkle twinkle here I come 🙂

Jx

Nope am away without a sax but will have a go when I get home. Problem is there is so much to do!

Jx

I'm curious to know if you have found time to Twinkle yet Jeanette.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom