richardr
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,697
I cheated. I copied Colin the Bear's improvisation.At least participants at the London and Manchester workshops did.
I cheated. I copied Colin the Bear's improvisation.At least participants at the London and Manchester workshops did.
A piano or an electronic keyboard, even a cheapie, is a huge help in learning to play by ear. In earlier days of saxophony I often resorted to a piano to find what note I should be playing because on sax it's so easy to bend an note a semitone either way, I often found myself playing the wrong note and bending it into something approximately but not quite right. You can't bend notes on a keyboard and its easy to find the right one.Could you play it on the piano? Have you tried? Just with one finger.
Not tried...
we all improvise whem we talk.
I would ask myself one question. "Can the tutor at the improvisation workshop improvise better than I can?" If the answer is yes, then I would at least try to implement some of the ideas being taught rather than reject them out of hand and just play the way I have always played. Why attend a workshop in the first place if you are just going to dismiss everything being presented anyway? That doesn't make any sense to me.
Can you get a keyboard from somewhere?
Yes I have an old Casio that my son had but I'd rather learn on the sax, I understand what Richard is saying but I need to connect my ear to the noise that is made when certain fingers are in position......Can you get a keyboard from somewhere?
Yes I have an old Casio that my son had but I'd rather learn on the sax, I understand what Richard is saying but I need to connect my ear to the noise that is made when certain fingers are in position......
Jx
Try practising a major scale slowly. Try to pre-hear each note before you move onto it. Then the triad apreggio. Then play simple tunes in that key in the same way, "Happy birthday", "Twinkle Twinkle", etc. Eventually you start to get the sound of the different scale degrees (and the finger postions that go with them) in the context of that key into your ear. Takes time though. Took me a lot of time and I'm still not satisfied, but it's a lot better than it used to be.Yes I have an old Casio that my son had but I'd rather learn on the sax, I understand what Richard is saying but I need to connect my ear to the noise that is made when certain fingers are in position.
ry to pre-hear each note before you move onto it.
I think you're missing my point entirely Kev.And it's this kind of improvisation that's musically boring. Doesn't say anything, just wastes time.
Try practising a major scale slowly. Try to pre-hear each note before you move onto it. Then the triad apreggio. Then play simple tunes in that key in the same way, "Happy birthday", "Twinkle Twinkle", etc. Eventually you start to get the sound of the different scale degrees (and the finger postions that go with them) in the context of that key into your ear. Takes time though. Took me a lot of time and I'm still not satisfied, but it's a lot better than it used to be.
Keep practicing you've got a year !!I had a go at happy birthday, bit of a cheat as I was playing this a couple of weeks or so ago but whilst I remembered some of the notes some I had to find. Thought I had cracked it but when I checked with the music I had one note wrong!!
Jx
Only one. And it's not wrong it's imrov. 😉I had a go at happy birthday, bit of a cheat as I was playing this a couple of weeks or so ago but whilst I remembered some of the notes some I had to find. Thought I had cracked it but when I checked with the music I had one note wrong!!
Jx
Don't you know you're supposed to keep your ears on your own work. 😉I cheated. I copied Colin the Bear's improvisation.
Only one sounds pretty goo d to me Now you know it. Next time playit again, slowly, with the sound of the scale fresh in your head, being aware of whuich scale degree each note is. Then play another simple tune and compare them. Another day, try a different key, etc etc etc for the rest of your life.I had a go at happy birthday, bit of a cheat as I was playing this a couple of weeks or so ago but whilst I remembered some of the notes some I had to find. Thought I had cracked it but when I checked with the music I had one note wrong!!
