Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

Could you play it on the piano? Have you tried? Just with one finger.
A piano or an electronic keyboard, even a cheapie, is a huge help in learning to play by ear. In earlier days of saxophony I often resorted to a piano to find what note I should be playing because on sax it's so easy to bend an note a semitone either way, I often found myself playing the wrong note and bending it into something approximately but not quite right. You can't bend notes on a keyboard and its easy to find the right one.

I know that Jeanette struggles with playing by ear and I strongly recommend starting with a keyboard, finding the notes on it then playing them on sax. I think that she'd find this easy and she'd soon be able to find the notes on her sax without the keyboard.
 
I would ask myself one question. "Can the tutor at the improvisation workshop improvise better than I can?" If the answer is yes, then I would at least try to implement some of the ideas being taught rather than reject them out of hand and just play the way I have always played. Why attend a workshop in the first place if you are just going to dismiss everything being presented anyway? That doesn't make any sense to me.

I didn't know what was going to be presented when I signed up for the workshop. I didn't know I was going to dismiss what was presented until it was presented and I'd had a chance to think about it. Can the tutor improvise better than me? He's been playing sax for decades longer than me. My problem with improvising isn't with having ideas, it's with putting the ideas into practice, playing the notes I want fluently without mistakes.

After the first couple of classes I emailed the tutor to suggest changes to his approach. For example I suggested that if he said something like "chord x leads on to chord y", he should play the chords on the piano, rather than just naming the chords. He didn't take any notice. I would have stopped going to the classes, but I'd paid in advance. And one of my main reasons for going to the classes was to meet other musicians playing at around my standard. That worked out nicely and I've formed a little band.

The other workshop participants weren't much impressed with this tutor's approach, he has said he won't be leading any more workshops, the jazz co-op have recruited somebody different to do the next group of workshops, and they are emphasising that he will take a different approach.

Does that make more sense to you now?
 
Yes I have an old Casio that my son had but I'd rather learn on the sax, I understand what Richard is saying but I need to connect my ear to the noise that is made when certain fingers are in position......

Jx

I completely understand that you don't want to be distracted from the sax, I am possibly even more bloody-minded than you about things like that, but a relatively small amount of saxual infidelity could deliver major benefits for you here. Nobody is saying "learn to play the piano": just have a try at playing some nursery rhymes or any simple tune, and see what you can learn.

I bet this would do you more good than the theory course you're considering, in a lot less time. Do the theory course later.
 
Yes I have an old Casio that my son had but I'd rather learn on the sax, I understand what Richard is saying but I need to connect my ear to the noise that is made when certain fingers are in position.
Try practising a major scale slowly. Try to pre-hear each note before you move onto it. Then the triad apreggio. Then play simple tunes in that key in the same way, "Happy birthday", "Twinkle Twinkle", etc. Eventually you start to get the sound of the different scale degrees (and the finger postions that go with them) in the context of that key into your ear. Takes time though. Took me a lot of time and I'm still not satisfied, but it's a lot better than it used to be.
 
ry to pre-hear each note before you move onto it.

The whole thing is a two ways process.
In the example of my favourite dorian mode: first you put the fingers in place. Not much creative at this stage, but you start "pre-hearing" what you are going to play. With practice the two sides are supposed to come together: thought and sound.
 
And it's this kind of improvisation that's musically boring. Doesn't say anything, just wastes time.
I think you're missing my point entirely Kev.
Never mind, I enjoy lying on my back like desperate beetle, waggling my arms and legs into a frenzy.

Here's one of my musically boring solos, I'm just regurgitating, and being sick and in your opinion I'm wasting the audience's time as well as my own. I bet you can't spot what tune it comes from.

http://thesax.de/sounds/whatsit.mp3
 
Last edited:
I fail to see the conflict between knowledge of the "theory" of which scales (modes) and notes go with each chord and playing "by ear". Notes are the "building blocks" used to create a melody---either by composing or improvisation. Knowing which notes fit within the harmony helps one to know which "blocks" to use to construct the melody from. With that foundation, the player then can use his/her creativity to select the timing and order of the blocks. As the player's skill level improves, chromatic passing tones, stylistic effects, and favorite "licks" and "quotes" can be inserted as the player chooses.
 
Tunes and melodies are in themselves improvisations.
Where do they come from? Were they always there?

I'm still trying to give up metamorphosin' - it all started with my sister's father-in-law frightening me with tall stories about ear wigs.
 
Last edited:
"Tunes" miss the spontaneous aspect that is supposed to be the essential element of improvisation.

Which brand of canned worms is better for jazz, by the way?
 
images
 
Try practising a major scale slowly. Try to pre-hear each note before you move onto it. Then the triad apreggio. Then play simple tunes in that key in the same way, "Happy birthday", "Twinkle Twinkle", etc. Eventually you start to get the sound of the different scale degrees (and the finger postions that go with them) in the context of that key into your ear. Takes time though. Took me a lot of time and I'm still not satisfied, but it's a lot better than it used to be.

I had a go at happy birthday, bit of a cheat as I was playing this a couple of weeks or so ago but whilst I remembered some of the notes some I had to find. Thought I had cracked it but when I checked with the music I had one note wrong!!

Jx
 
I had a go at happy birthday, bit of a cheat as I was playing this a couple of weeks or so ago but whilst I remembered some of the notes some I had to find. Thought I had cracked it but when I checked with the music I had one note wrong!!
Only one sounds pretty goo d to me Now you know it. Next time playit again, slowly, with the sound of the scale fresh in your head, being aware of whuich scale degree each note is. Then play another simple tune and compare them. Another day, try a different key, etc etc etc for the rest of your life.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom