Not sure I understand playing by ear here. I am pretty sure I do not do this, but I can pick out a melody or accompaniment on a guitar, or notes a saxophone, and I can improvise within my own limits. But thats just knowing a few scales and chords. I recently learned Lily Was Here. Like Colin I studied it up and now can play it without reference to music though I often put it on the music stand as a security blanket, which is daft. So, ear players, are you saying that you can pick up an alto and play Lily Was Here? If so, hats off. Or, are you saying you can figure it out and then play it, in which case whats the dif?