Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

I don't see why you should take exception. You may be an excellent teacher, I believe you probably are, but that doesn't mean that all music teachers are excellent.
Allow me to clarify my remark. Making broad assumptions about how beginners are taught when one has never set foot in a music classroom or taken music lessons is both ill informed and presumptuous in my opinion.
 
I've been trying to think of what it is that you do when learning to read, and playing by ear.
Learning to read - I think - is relating the dots on the page to the notes on your instrument, and getting the tempo, dynamics, etc.
But I can't quite figure out the mechanism of 'playing by ear'.
Do you remember the notes by name, or the finger positions, or the sound, or what?
 
But I can't quite figure out the mechanism of 'playing by ear'.
Do you remember the notes by name, or the finger positions, or the sound, or what?

For what I can remember, it is about movement shapes. The name of the notes, in my case, came after the fingers were right. That also works when reading: a dot relates to a sound/fingering. Names come later (an in my case in two languages too)
 
With a new piece I'm very mechanical. Count out the tempo and play the written notes. Repetition till I get it, and I often get it wrong, the dots are just an aid de memoire. Then it's a case of practice it. When I'm playing a piece I know well there's no thought of notes, dots or fingers. It's as if I'm listening to myself playing. I sometimes get distracted and forget I'm playing and the whole thing falls to bits.
 
But if you see the notes (the dots I think you are saying) then that would imply being able to read ?

Nope. I played bass for years before I found the need to learn to read, and that was because I wanted to learn to play Bach's Cello Suites but didn't have the Internet to listen to them being played so had no choice - I managed it, too 😀 - and then completely forgot how to read afterwards because I never had another reason to read anything.

I can't explain it but when playing I would 'see' the notes, often they were even coloured, too, but they weren't written on a stave, they just existed. Apparently it's called Synesthesia rather than me simply being a bit odd. 😉

Somehow I've accidentally learnt to read drum music over the last month, by helping the other half learn to play the drums, and I will eventually learn to read proper music (sorry percussionists but you know it's true 😉 ) once I've finished my language degree, but I'll know I can finally play the sax when I can 'see' the notes again.
 
There are now sax transcriptions of these. Good fun to play.

Imagine they'd work best with a Baritone..

vis, playing by ear..I suppose I'd say I sing the tune / words to myself and kind of 'go for' the notes..?
V. difficult to try and describe a thing you 'just do' in words really
 
Last edited:
Not sure I understand playing by ear here. I am pretty sure I do not do this, but I can pick out a melody or accompaniment on a guitar, or notes a saxophone, and I can improvise within my own limits. But thats just knowing a few scales and chords. I recently learned Lily Was Here. Like Colin I studied it up and now can play it without reference to music though I often put it on the music stand as a security blanket, which is daft. So, ear players, are you saying that you can pick up an alto and play Lily Was Here? If so, hats off. Or, are you saying you can figure it out and then play it, in which case whats the dif?
 
Then I dont know what playing by ear is. I really think I dont. Lets take a piano. Is playing be ear listening to a classical piece which is for grown ups, using both hands, and being able to play it with both hands straight off no study after one hearing?

I am not sceptical or dismissive of ear playing, I just think its beyond me and must be a very rare talent.
Cheers
Mike
 
For starters, just sit there with the saxophone and think / sing through a very simple tune, that you know very well, then try playing it...you prob won't get it right 1st time but if you keep doing that , you'll get better ..and go from there !..Try it
 
There is no real mystery or even difficulty to "playing by ear" in my experience. For me it is hearing a tune over and over until it is in my head, and then "figuring it out" on the saxophone without having to refer to a written page of music. The figuring it out doesn't need to be fast or spontaneous. Often it is done by bits and pieces a little bit at a time.

I grew up in a small town where the closest music store was 200 miles away, and of course there was no internet. If I wanted to play a tune, I couldn't just go out and buy the music. After I had learned most of the notes and keys on my saxophone when I heard a song like "Take Five" on the radio, I bought the record and learned to play the melody a few notes at a time by hearing it over and over again. Eventually, I could play right along with Paul Desmond picking up his tone and style as I went along. I did the same with Stan Getz's Desifinato, Plas Johnson's The Pink Panther, and Boots Randolph's Yakkety Sax. The more I did it, the easier it got.

After a while I began to think in terms of musical intervals which opened the door to playing tunes in different keys than the one I learned them in. My advice to anyone wanting to learn to play by ear is to start with Twinkle Twinkle Little Star and go on from there.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom