Playing the saxophone Different Bb alternative fingerings

Here is where I find the 1+1 alternate useful, because it allows one to do this interval quickly. This is the lead part for Bb instruments for the swing classic, In the Mood, after the 8 bar intro:
View attachment 29996
Annotated part for Bb instruments from Hal Leonard's Jazz Play Along Volume 28, Big Band Era, Page 28, the melody.

My choices found from:
View attachment 29997

This is where I find the 1+1 Bb combo fingering very useful. Played up to tempo, it makes easy work of these intervals. In the 5th measure of the melody, there are two choices I can use, the first fingering using the right-hand A# "trill" key with A fingering or the "forked" 1+1 denoted "RH1".

My preferences is still to use the 1+1. Why? Because at tempo, to play this up to tempo, there is just a slight variation of fingering. I find it easier for me to use this, as basically it is a very minor alteration, the substitution of G for F in the 5th measure. It took practise but afterwards, I was able to easily finger this passage with very little effort.

This is where use of B+bis would be very difficult to maneuver quickly with these 8th notes up to tempo. It takes practise and effort to retrain the mind to be able to do this. However IMHO, once one catches on will be able to take their playing skill level up another notch.
Bis in the fifth measure for me.
 
Bis in the fifth measure for me.
Definitely. The problem with use side Bb over either of those phrases is the difficulty in dropping back down from Bb to D or to Eb. It's much easier going from bis Bb down to either of those notes than going from side Bb. Especially at an up-tempo speed.
 
Since people are thinking about this kind of thing ... What would your preference for this triplet run be? - 120 BPM, F - so Bb...

1000000183.webp


I settled on Bis for the top Bb and side Bb for the middle...
 
What you are describing is a bit unconventional, where the index finger is simultaneously covering the pearls to B and Bis. This was hard to picture until you just explained it.

Because the tempo is fast, I prefer to keep my fingers in their traditional locations and just use an alternate 1+1. It is one of the few instances where this combination makes easy "footwork" of it.
No, it's not in the least unconventional - covering both B and bis with index finger is standard technique.
 
What you are describing is a bit unconventional, where the index finger is simultaneously covering the pearls to B and Bis. This was hard to picture until you just explained it.
The index finger overlapping of the bis key for an β€œautomatic” Bb is standard sax technique. For series of notes where B natural is not present, perhaps not at all, it’s a really easy fingering that changes the β€œopen scale”, if you like, to the key of F major. 1st finger defaults to Bb - or A#. I rarely use anything else.

If playing F# major scale (or B major etc - A# to B) I would use the side key fingering as I’m not a fan of sliding off cleanly, but these days my playing consists mostly of Rock gigs and that sequence of notes is not that common. 1,2,3,5,6,1 or 1,b3,4,b5,5,b7,1 type of combos are more usual.

Bis is the flute equivalent of thumb Bb. The clarinet doesn’t have an equivalent on any note, unless you have a model with an articulated C# / G# (I think - been out of the clarinet world for decades).
 
All bis

I’d probably do all bis too. If I actually bothered to think about it I might consider side for the second one.

I would use Bis for both.

bis throughout.

I initially did all-bis but found the last bit stilted. So tried side Bb which was just as possible...

Both take a lot of practice (for me) to get even - i guess that's the thing for any fiddly bit; pick a fingering, start slowly and evenly and speed up slowly. The really hard part (for me) is practicing with a slow metronome, not the choice of Bb!
 
I initially did all-bis but found the last bit stilted. So tried side Bb which was just as possible...

Both take a lot of practice (for me) to get even - i guess that's the thing for any fiddly bit; pick a fingering, start slowly and evenly and speed up slowly. The really hard part (for me) is practicing with a slow metronome, not the choice of Bb!
Once you've got a good, well-practised finger-technique, you'll have your own preference anyway. The side Bb is not a daft option by any means though does involve two parts of coordination when coming from C a step above Bb - the down movement of two fingers into the A fingering, and the opening of the side Bb. This can be out of sequence. The overlap Bb bis is one movement, although a crossover movement (from 2nd finger C to index finger Bb bis).

A textbook might say to avoid it. But we need to be able to do it smoothly anyway, and compared to the normal flute fingering of Bb - 1/1, and also the proper flute F# (123 / --3) when coming from or to E etc (awkward!) - there are fingerings that we need to be proficient in anyway for an all-round technique.

Being 100% is king whichever way you choose.
 
I think it's hard to chromatic play B-A#,A,G#,G, F#. In a blues in E concert we use to play a combo of F# blues- and F# mixolydian scale; F#,G#,A, A#,B,C,C#,E.
 
This whole thing piqued my interest and had a look on 'tinternet it seems Bb fingerings is a highly contentious topic on Sax on't Web !
Somewhere on my shufti round I read somewhere that Monsieur Sax originally envisaged the side Bb as the standard, and indeed on his early instruments apparently it didn't even have the little 'bridge' enabling long fork fingered Bb
 
Keys were added over time, just like the clarinet and other instruments.

I don’t know why fingerings need to be contentious at all if the player makes them work and is happy.
 
Maybe I got all wrong? I wrote down the mixed F# blues and mixolydian scale on a Rock Sax workshop:
F#, G#, A, A#,B, C, C#,E (bold from the F# blues scale). And of course all the other tones that are not in blues or mixolydian scales. A trill F# to G sounds great as well. WE also learned some tricks who to get a good flow on the sax. Avoid the flip fingers ...... .
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,317
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom