Here is where I find the 1+1 alternate useful, because it allows one to do this interval quickly. This is the lead part for Bb instruments for the swing classic,
In the Mood, after the 8 bar intro:
View attachment 29996
Annotated part for Bb instruments from Hal Leonard's Jazz Play Along Volume 28, Big Band Era, Page 28, the melody.
My choices found from:
Alternative fingerings on the saxophone (e.g. Bb, F#, C) and when to use them, either for ease of fingering or for sound
tamingthesaxophone.com
View attachment 29997
This is where I find the 1+1 Bb combo fingering very useful. Played up to tempo, it makes easy work of these intervals. In the 5th measure of the melody, there are two choices I can use, the first fingering using the right-hand A# "trill" key with A fingering or the "forked" 1+1 denoted "RH1".
My preferences is still to use the 1+1. Why? Because at tempo, to play this up to tempo, there is just a slight variation of fingering. I find it easier for me to use this, as basically it is a very minor alteration, the substitution of G for F in the 5th measure. It took practise but afterwards, I was able to easily finger this passage with very little effort.
This is where use of B+bis would be very difficult to maneuver quickly with these 8th notes up to tempo. It takes practise and effort to retrain the mind to be able to do this. However IMHO, once one catches on will be able to take their playing skill level up another notch.