Playing the saxophone Different Bb alternative fingerings

I feel like I've missed the boat somewhere, since I use just B+bis 99% of the time.
Here is where I find the 1+1 alternate useful, because it allows one to do this interval quickly. This is the lead part for Bb instruments for the swing classic, In the Mood, after the 8 bar intro:
2025-08-16 In the Mood Bb Melody Annoted.webp

Annotated part for Bb instruments from Hal Leonard's Jazz Play Along Volume 28, Big Band Era, Page 28, the melody.

My choices found from:
2025-08-16 TTS Alt Bb-s2.webp


This is where I find the 1+1 Bb combo fingering very useful. Played up to tempo, it makes easy work of these intervals. In the 5th measure of the melody, there are two choices I can use, the first fingering using the right-hand A# "trill" key with A fingering or the "forked" 1+1 denoted "RH1".

My preferences is still to use the 1+1. Why? Because at tempo, to play this up to tempo, there is just a slight variation of fingering. I find it easier for me to use this, as basically it is a very minor alteration, the substitution of G for F in the 5th measure. It took practise but afterwards, I was able to easily finger this passage with very little effort.

This is where use of B+bis would be very difficult to maneuver quickly with these 8th notes up to tempo. It takes practise and effort to retrain the mind to be able to do this. However IMHO, once one catches on will be able to take their playing skill level up another notch.
 
This is where use of B+bis would be very difficult to maneuver quickly with these 8th notes up to tempo. It takes practise and effort to retrain the mind to be able to do this. However IMHO, once one catches on will be able to take their playing skill level up another notch.
Indeed, so why break your heart over it when you can use another easy option !
 
Here is where I find the 1+1 alternate useful, because it allows one to do this interval quickly. This is the lead part for Bb instruments for the swing classic, In the Mood, after the 8 bar intro:
View attachment 29996
Annotated part for Bb instruments from Hal Leonard's Jazz Play Along Volume 28, Big Band Era, Page 28, the melody.

My choices found from:
View attachment 29997

This is where I find the 1+1 Bb combo fingering very useful. Played up to tempo, it makes easy work of these intervals. In the 5th measure of the melody, there are two choices I can use, the first fingering using the right-hand A# "trill" key with A fingering or the "forked" 1+1 denoted "RH1".

My preferences is still to use the 1+1. Why? Because at tempo, to play this up to tempo, there is just a slight variation of fingering. I find it easier for me to use this, as basically it is a very minor alteration, the substitution of G for F in the 5th measure. It took practise but afterwards, I was able to easily finger this passage with very little effort.

This is where use of B+bis would be very difficult to maneuver quickly with these 8th notes up to tempo. It takes practise and effort to retrain the mind to be able to do this. However IMHO, once one catches on will be able to take their playing skill level up another notch.
The bis Bb is every bit as easy to use in this example. There are no B naturals. Just keep your finger on the bis key.
 
The bis Bb is every bit as easy to use in this example. There are no B naturals. Just keep your finger on the bis key.
That sounds so "unclarinet" like. πŸ˜‰

Seriously, maybe your sax is key linked differently than mine. Keeping my finger on the bis key and remaining fingers on the others leaves the A pad open. (Reference my Vito 7133T - Jupiter tenor.)

The tempo is somewhere between 164 quarter note beats per second to 176, depending one which recording one is listening to. Thus for me at that speed, I find the 1+1 fingering indispensable.
 
Doesn't work so well in the keys of B major and F# major.
Yes, exactly. Options are there as exactly that. In most circumstances the side Bb or bis key will be the smoother and most sensible option, but occasionally the other fingerings are the smoother and more sensible option. Sliding on and off the bis key continuously is not a nice movement.
 
That sounds so "unclarinet" like. πŸ˜‰

Seriously, maybe your sax is key linked differently than mine. Keeping my finger on the bis key and remaining fingers on the others leaves the A pad open. (Reference my Vito 7133T - Jupiter tenor.)

The tempo is somewhere between 164 quarter note beats per second to 176, depending one which recording one is listening to. Thus for me at that speed, I find the 1+1 fingering indispensable.
The A pad closes when you put down your second finger. I’m not sure what you’re referring to here. But as long as each of us likes the way we do it, everything is good.
 
You play the B and the Bis with your first finger. In your example you don’t have to slide. There are no B naturals. B natural to B flat is the situation where bis is difficult. Not the case here.
What you are describing is a bit unconventional, where the index finger is simultaneously covering the pearls to B and Bis. This was hard to picture until you just explained it.

Because the tempo is fast, I prefer to keep my fingers in their traditional locations and just use an alternate 1+1. It is one of the few instances where this combination makes easy "footwork" of it.
 
The bis Bb is every bit as easy to use in this example. There are no B naturals. Just keep your finger on the bis key.
Agreed. I just now gave this a good workout, using both the 1+1 (1+4) fingering for Bb and the Bb bis key. Both fingerings worked just fine for that "In the Mood" passage, and I could do it equally as fast using bis Bb as on the 1+1. On my Mark VI tenor, the bis Bb came out much stronger/fuller sounding. So, I'd use bis Bb for this. But it can be done either way.

I found side Bb very awkward on that passage and impossible at an up-tempo speed.

What you are describing is a bit unconventional, where the index finger is simultaneously covering the pearls to B and Bis.
What he describes is not unconventional. It's how you play bis Bb. You push both the B & bis key by a simple rotation of the index finger:

When playing B natural, the index finger is not covering the bis pearl, but it is very lightly, just slightly, touching the upper edge of the bis key. In order to engage the bis key to play Bb, moving from B, you simply have to tilt or rotate the index finger downward, closing the bis key. It's a subtle, quick, and easy movement, at least on both my VI & Buescher tenors.

Again, I'll suggest watching that Greg Fishman video (has anyone looked at it?). He explains and demonstrates the use of bis Bb very well.
 
What he describes is not unconventional. It's how you play bis Bb. You push both the B & bis key by a simple rotation of the index finger
I think a couple variables are in affect to the ease or un-ease in doing this. This IMHO is provided one's keywork is laid out in a manner to make this relatively easy.

There are also variations in how one's fingers are shaped, curved, length, strength, etc. Also, some variation may be related to one having started on another instrument like clarinet who still doubles, which may affect preferences.

I think it better that a saxist knows what options are available, and to choose the one best suited for them.

For me, I have "BIS-less Bliss". (My apologies to the Bis advocates.) πŸ˜‰ :banana:
 
I think it better that a saxist knows what options are available, and to choose the one best suited for them.
On this particular point we are in total agreement (I always look for at some agreement in these discussions).

Not to beat a dead horse, but because I normally am not thinking about fingerings when I'm playing--I just play them--today I fooled around with these Bb fingerings and paid some attention to how, when, and where they worked for me. And that's what I've been going on here. For me, it turns out bis Bb works great at least 95% of the time.

I'll give one observation regarding the side Bb fingering vs the bis Bb. In playing bis Bb, you are using one finger (left index finger); one point of contact (even though you're bridging 2 keys). In playing side Bb, you are using 3 fingers: LH 1 & 2 on B and A, and RH index finger (on its side) on the side key; 3 points of contact. That may or may not be an issue depending on the musical phrase you are playing. That is to say, the notes preceding or coming after the Bb. Obviously, if you are moving from A to Bb, you simply have to press the side Bb key. But using bis, you just lift the A key, having already rotated onto the bis. So that one's a wash but it still will matter what other notes are in the phrase (where are you going next?). And fairly often the single finger fingering (for lack of a better way of saying it) will be more efficient than pressing multiple keys.

Finally, going back to choosing the options that are best suited to you, the fact is, the more you play & practice certain fingerings, and fingering combinations, the more natural they will feel. It all gets internalized, and you certainly aren't going to be thinking about which option to choose in the heat of playing a solo. You end up going with what you've practiced and worked out.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,317
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom