Playing the saxophone Different Bb alternative fingerings

As Mizmar says.. In fact on the newish to me tenor I had to adjust the little 'bridge' thing that ultimately closes the bis key, fortunately this instrument has a lil' screw so easy peasy, a more vintage instrument and you're gluing bits of cork or felt !
 
Where does “long Bb” become the name for 1+1?

I consider “long Bb” as the note that comes from playing low Bb with the octave key (or voicing the low Bb to the next octave). So I guess that’s two more Bb fingerings.
 
That'd be 5 then ...as in addition we have both what I (and I thought most people) called the long Bb .. 1+1 and 1+2.. then we have the side Bb, and the bis key, then Dr G's bottom Bb with octave key malarkey
 
Where does “long Bb” become the name for 1+1?

I consider “long Bb” as the note that comes from playing low Bb with the octave key (or voicing the low Bb to the next octave). So I guess that’s two more Bb fingerings.
Must be European then. Long Bb is 1 / 1
 
I have never understood why 1+1 (“long”) is preferable to just using bis Bb. In the Mood and the passage referenced above are both just as easy using just LH 1 covering the bis key. Most of my saxophones sound a little stuffy using 1+1, and it’s not uncommon for that adjustment to be a little on the loose side, as most people in my area never use it.

Just facts. Clarinet has two Bb’s in the throat and 4 in the clarion.
And 2 more in the chalumeau. I can only think of 3 in the clarion, clarion A plus 1st side trill key, clarion A + the little fork key played with the RH ring finger, and 1+1. What’s the 4th?
 
I have never understood why 1+1 (“long”) is preferable to just using bis Bb. In the Mood and the passage referenced above are both just as easy using just LH 1 covering the bis key. Most of my saxophones sound a little stuffy using 1+1, and it’s not uncommon for that adjustment to be a little on the loose side, as most people in my area never use it.


And 2 more in the chalumeau. I can only think of 3 in the clarion, clarion A plus 1st side trill key, clarion A + the little fork key played with the RH ring finger, and 1+1. What’s the 4th?
1 + RH 2 (low B to D#; clarion F# to A#). Usually sharp. Agree about stuffiness on sax, same on clarinet to an extent. But useful if you want to creep in on a clarion Bb ppp. Less bright than usual side Bb.

I think 1/1 on sax is mostly used by players brought up on flute, especially, and clarinet. I don’t use it anymore on sax, but took me a long time to get used to the bis Bb.
 
According to my old fingering chart (it's from Gemany; griffentabellen) there are four ways to fingering Bb 1:

B/H + Bis key
B + A + side Bb key
B + E
B + F + F# alt/side

Same fingening for Bb2 + octave key.

The official way to teach to play Bb 1 and 2 is: B + A + side Bb key

I use B/H + Bis key more than B + A + side Bb key. I often play songs with lots of A# but not easy to get a nice flow using the Bis key.

When you are playing a new mouthpiece overtones exercesises are important. Check ligature and reed position as well.
 
I've literally never used the bis key, way too awkward, but obviously that's just me as most others seem to use it.
I guess both the long Bb's you would define as 'fork fingerings'
 
Starting out and still doubling on clarinet I never use Bis.

Some arpeggios are more efficient using long Bb. I find transitioning from side Bb to D2 awkward but it all depends where you're going next and how fast. I keep Rh3 regulated for trills and sometimes use Lh23 or even Lh 123. It gives a different feel and adds interest. imo.

In some keys Lh1 Rh12 seems give better intonation. It might just be me.

It's as well to be aware of all the whistles and stops on any equipment you're using.
 
Starting out and still doubling on clarinet I never use Bis.

Some arpeggios are more efficient using long Bb. I find transitioning from side Bb to D2 awkward but it all depends where you're going next and how fast. I keep Rh3 regulated for trills and sometimes use Lh23 or even Lh 123. It gives a different feel and adds interest. imo.

In some keys Lh1 Rh12 seems give better intonation. It might just be me.

It's as well to be aware of all the whistles and stops on any equipment you're using.
I agree that coming from the clarinet the Bis key on sax is difficult to get used to. But bare in mind - especially post #31 - that you don't toggle back and forth with it; the use is for keys that have constant Bb's or A#'s - eg you play with the LH index finger overlapping it throughout, unless you get a B natural.

I taught many a flute player that had come onto sax and they invariably won't change their 1 /1 Bb fingering, which is fine if your dexterity is good from A to Bb (as it is in decent flautists), but when you get a blip between A and Bb it isn't so clever.

You can usually make a good argument for any of the fingerings in certain scenarios. Mostly, classical music will give better reasons for usage of a certain fingering in a certain passage, because the way you have to play it is prescribed, and you can't decide whether a scoop into the note might be cool and cover something up, or not to play it pp or whatever...

Bottom line, if it's reliable for you, then nobody cares.
 
You can usually make a good argument for any of the fingerings in certain scenarios.
I just select which ever alternate fingering works best in a given situation, what comes natural, easiest, etc., been doing it for such a long time that I now have to look at a fingering chart to figure out the discussion. I select alternates based on what key I'm playing, whether the note is trilled or not, interval used, chromatics, etc.

Since I don't teach woodwind, and I am not grilled on nomenclatures regularly as a student would experience, my mind is not as sharp on proper terminology.
 
I just select which ever alternate fingering works best in a given situation, what comes natural, easiest, etc., been doing it for such a long time that I now have to look at a fingering chart to figure out the discussion. I select alternates based on what key I'm playing, whether the note is trilled or not, interval used, chromatics, etc.

Since I don't teach woodwind, and I am not grilled on nomenclatures regularly as a student would experience, my mind is not as sharp on proper terminology.
Yes, that’s what I meant. Some fingerings are not great and are rarely used, until they are really excellent in a certain passage of notes. Great to have alternatives, especially on the clarinet.
 
Interesting

Long Bb (1 + 2) is my go-to for lots of runs/intervals

But to add context, for me side Bb is the least used of the three, which I expect puts me on the sax-technique naughty step
Well, I'm pretty much a die-hard bis key user. The bis Bb is what I use about 95% of the time. With side Bb the other 5% or so. I do it automatically, without even having to think about it. Has this video been posted on here? Check it out:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C87hqa5AoB8
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,318
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom