Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

That’s not the point. Personally, I’ve always obsessed about sound down to the nth. ANY change is a dealbreaker.
Maybe that makes you the best person to test this. If you don't hear any change in the sound, they don't affect the sound.
I would expect no change to the sound from what I have understood about the concept of those pads.
I am off course now expert in acoustics (though I have some knowledge about this), nor am I an expert saxophone player....
 
I don’t understand how a test can particularly achieve anything:

The stock horn plays and doesn’t leak
The horn with “unleakable” pads plays and doesn’t leak.

It needs daily playing of both in the same conditions to see when the trad. Horn breaks and whether the new pads are still going strong. A bit like Fairy Liquid (still washing dishes etc).

Otherwise, what is the test for - just feel and sound?
 
Maybe that makes you the best person to test this. If you don't hear any change in the sound, they don't affect the sound.
I would expect no change to the sound from what I have understood about the concept of those pads.
I am off course now expert in acoustics (though I have some knowledge about this), nor am I an expert saxophone player....
Difference in sound absorption? Softer/harder surface? Sound reflection rate?
 
I don’t disagree with this chain of thought, but they can’t be easily popped on (in place of the regular key cups/pads) and popped off again, so unless you have a horn I like with trad. Pads and another with your pads it’s not an experiment.
Why does it need to be a horn you like?
I'm sure most well regarded models would sound very nice in your hands.
The Jupiter 767-769 is a well made OK sounding alto (even with me playing it!).
I have one with my pads, one with traditional pads.
 
I don’t understand how a test can particularly achieve anything:

The stock horn plays and doesn’t leak
The horn with “unleakable” pads plays and doesn’t leak.

It needs daily playing of both in the same conditions to see when the trad. Horn breaks and whether the new pads are still going strong. A bit like Fairy Liquid (still washing dishes etc).

Otherwise, what is the test for - just feel and sound?
How about having both for a week, a month? I'd be grateful for your input along with the other passaround pros.
 
Why does it need to be a horn you like?
I'm sure most well regarded models would sound very nice in your hands.
The Jupiter 767-769 is a well made OK sounding alto (even with me playing it!).
I have one with my pads, one with traditional pads.
How about having both for a week, a month? I'd be grateful for your input along with the other passaround pros.
Ok
 
Because it messes with my head!

Is it me?
Is it the horn?
Reed?
Where’s that other mouthpiece?
Pads?
Me again?
But surely they'd both sound As "different" as each other? But I do understand you may not like to hear yourself playing below your usual standard, even for the good of all saxophonists. (laying it on a bit there!)
What horn/s would "do"?
 
A real world test, of the pads stability, after set level, would be staying in place thru the first 8 bars, with LeoP driving.
You might become the official pad supplier to the '28 Games in LA, for the new dance event,
Breaking with the Bari.
Individual and mixed team, with the women in high heels dancing backwards, when upright.
It could happen, says Tenuta. :banana:
Are you AI?
 
What horn/s would "do"?
None “will do”, that’s the whole point of wanting every nuance to be just so.

But if you have the same horn as control and self-levellers (sounds like a breakaway band) then I’d be happy to give you balanced, honest feedback between those two.
 
I think a good question to ask the techs is why pads need replacing in the first place.

Does your pad address all of these reasons and are you able to prove this to an experienced tech.
 
I smile, answer any specific concerns, and cross them off the list... for now.
Those techs who are interested and welcome an alternative will be the ones who form a network of approved repairers.
There may not be that many, at least to start with.
But unless they refuse to fit/work on them (refuse to fit maybe) I don't see why anyone who is merely "not fully signed up" would be crossed off - that suggests that a tech wouldn't be bothered to do the best job on that horn, like any other. A bit like a pro player deliberately playing a piece to a lesser standard because they don't like it.
 
I think a good question to ask the techs is why pads need replacing in the first place.

Does your pad address all of these reasons and are you able to prove this to an experienced tech.
I've had loads of feedback, real issues (pad feel; poor adhesive; loose nuts; pad drop out in transit; pacemakers; etc) and many theoretical issues.
The MkIII prototypes will address all of these but when built they too may have shortcomings.
At present I can't prove anything until more field testing is done by techs, pros, and amateur players.
I'm sorry it's taking so long but I'll not boast they work perfectly until they do.
Even then the long term performance won't be known until... the long term.
In a way I'd be perfectly happy if an insurmountable issue crept in and I could play the sax instead of fiddling with it.
But then overcoming obstacles is quite fun and satisfying.
 
Last edited:
But unless they refuse to fit/work on them (refuse to fit maybe) I don't see why anyone who is merely "not fully signed up" would be crossed off - that suggests that a tech wouldn't be bothered to do the best job on that horn, like any other. A bit like a pro player deliberately playing a piece to a lesser standard because they don't like it.
No they'd send the customer away saying "I don't work on those, sorry."
Once my pads are "the best" every tech will want to use them.
Or have I misunderstood your thought?
Of course once perfected I'd go back to any "anti" tech and say "here, try this" but many will still find reason not to want touch such witchcraft.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom