Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

Since I've already remarked on history as a construct, what the hell...

Shop keep: "Adlophe, your ophicleide copies aren't selling"
Adlophe: "why?"
Shop keep: "well, you know, buglers are very conservative. What are we going to do with the old stock?"
Adlophe: "I've had an idea: stick a base clarinet mouthpiece on them then well have something easer to play than trumpet and in all voices"
Shop keep: "nah, they won't sound the same. clarinetists are just as fussy."
Adlophe: "... Pass me my hammer..."
 
I smile, answer any specific concerns, and cross them off the list... for now.
Those techs who are interested and welcome an alternative will be the ones who form a network of approved repairers.
I wonder how a marketing expert would approach this (you do need to consider that).

USP to consumer - easy to fix the pads yourself for a leak-free horn
USP to techs- ??????
 
I wonder how a marketing expert would approach this (you do need to consider that).

USP to consumer - easy to fix the pads yourself for a leak-free horn
USP to techs- ??????
A marketer will not start a DIY market because they frequently change jobs every three years.

USP to tech :You can pad a sax in less time and ask the same price.
 
USP to consumer - easy to fix the pads yourself for a leak-free horn
USP to techs- ??????
consumer: much the same as synthetic reeds, surely. Harder to "feel" because the timeline is years instead of weeks. But someone who's suffered leaks from time to time might appreciate the "no hassle" idea.

Techs: as I suggested above, if there's support and possibly a good margin on parts, why not? Fettling is fettling.
 
Since I've already remarked on history as a construct, what the hell...

Shop keep: "Adlophe, your ophicleide copies aren't selling"
Adlophe: "why?"
Shop keep: "well, you know, buglers are very conservative. What are we going to do with the old stock?"
Adlophe: "I've had an idea: stick a base clarinet mouthpiece on them then well have something easer to play than trumpet and in all voices"
Shop keep: "nah, they won't sound the same. clarinetists are just as fussy."
Adlophe: "... Pass me my hammer..."
Historically Sax aimed at the bassoon players.
 
Then there is no point in the magnets if you take that point of view.
I don't think many would care. The offer / promise is "end annoying leaks". "no fear of pad failure when heading for a last minute gig" etc.

That assumes consumers won't be able to buy them and fix them themselves.
Why? But I'm sure (guess based on posts here) the minority of sax players even think of DIYing their horn.
 
In the marching band of that time the weakest link was the bass instrument.
As you like.
But, as I see it, the offer of replacing the whole wind section with one range of instrument, with the same fingering etc. And that was loud; was the business objective. In the era and countries where marching bands where a big fad...

Still, my point was that - like the pads in this thread - the sax itself was once a innovation based on the state of the art...
 
Last edited:
I wonder how a marketing expert would approach this (you do need to consider that).

USP to consumer - easy to fix the pads yourself for a leak-free horn
USP to techs- ??????
Bloomin’ hard to find vegan-friendly pads. Alastair Penman has set up this website:

Non-leather pad options are listed there.

To persuade a sax manufacturer to offer a model with these fitted as standard the unique selling point is that they’ll be the only manufacturer offering a cruelty free saxophone (they’ll need to lose the shellac and key pearls too). Some might argue that vegans can get the pads replaced themselves on any sax, but throwing away good leather means that the animal died for nothing, so that won’t happen.
 
Then you’re calling some top notch players absurd

Apologies, Pete. I failed to quote the post that I was responding to (please see below).

As to top notch players embracing objects that some consider gimmicks: I have spent decades as a scientist (physics and materials science), and have yet to see credible evidence or even credible theories as to why heavy-mass screws, Klangbogen, or tone stones change the tone or response of a saxophone. But if the objects enhance a player's perceived experience, I will not ridicule them. I sat shoulder to shoulder with a fine lead alto player that had several aftermarket enhancements on his Yanagisawa A-9937. He sounded fine regardless, although I wish his sound had the richness of a classic Meyer/Selmer setup. That, obviously, was not the sound he was going for.

A real world test, of the pads stability, after set level, would be staying in place thru the first 8 bars, with LeoP driving.
You might become the official pad supplier to the '28 Games in LA, for the new dance event,
Breaking with the Bari.
Individual and mixed team, with the women in high heels dancing backwards, when upright.
It could happen, says Tenuta. :banana:

That's gold medal absurdity.
 
Last edited:
Apologies, Pete. I failed to quote the post that I was responding to (please see below).

As to top notch players embracing objects that some consider gimmicks: I have spent decades as a scientist (physics and materials science), and have yet to see credible evidence or even credible theories as to why heavy-mass screws, Klangbogen, or tone stones change the tone or response of a saxophone. But if the objects enhance a player's perceived experience, I will not ridicule them. I sat shoulder to shoulder with a fine lead alto player that had several aftermarket enhancements on his Yanagisawa A-9937. He sounded fine regardless, although I wish his sound had the richness of a classic Meyer/Selmer setup. That, obviously, was not the sound he was going for.
I know that they're considered to be outliers, but there are a fair few that think they hear differences in ligatures, reeds, Klangbogens etc. Unless it's a definite 100% absolute no, then...

I'm sure that @petethomas has recently said that he'd changed camp as to hearing differences between ligatures. I'm in this camp, and always have been. I know a lot of fine ears that concur too. I do have a Klangbogen, but I must say that it's in my drawer - so there's obviously my own answer to that. But, whilst I can't remember who they are (apart from Jay "Better Sax" - who usually calls a spade a spade), I have been surprised to see some A1 guys using them.
 
I'm sure that @petethomas has recently said that he'd changed camp as to hearing differences between ligatures.
Where did I say that? If a ligature is working properly it sounds the same as any other ligature that is working properly. I’d go further and say any ligature has no sound at all. Unless you drop it or hit it with a hammer.

It’s a bit like saying the pearl touchpieces have a sound or that the springs have a sound (wait for it…,)
 
Where did I say that? If a ligature is working properly it sounds the same as any other ligature that is working properly. I’d go further and say any ligature has no sound at all. Unless you drop it or hit it with a hammer.

It’s a bit like saying the pearl touchpieces have a sound or that the springs have a sound (wait for it…,)
You said something like it
 
I know that they're considered to be outliers, but there are a fair few that think they hear differences in ligatures, reeds, Klangbogens etc. Unless it's a definite 100% absolute no, then...

I'm sure that @petethomas has recently said that he'd changed camp as to hearing differences between ligatures. I'm in this camp, and always have been. I know a lot of fine ears that concur too. I do have a Klangbogen, but I must say that it's in my drawer - so there's obviously my own answer to that. But, whilst I can't remember who they are (apart from Jay "Better Sax" - who usually calls a spade a spade), I have been surprised to see some A1 guys using them.

I hear differences in some ligatures - the ol' Rovner sucked the highs right out of a good reed. A great many people use them to temper a high baffle mouthpiece. Beyond that, any ill-fitting ligature will kill the response of a reed.

Differences between reeds? Oh, very yes. And for good reasons. That's actually a vibrating object that is subject to rules of physics.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom