Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

Where did I say that? If a ligature is working properly it sounds the same as any other ligature that is working properly. I’d go further and say any ligature has no sound at all. Unless you drop it or hit it with a hammer.

It’s a bit like saying the pearl touchpieces have a sound or that the springs have a sound (wait for it…,)
Can't resist that. The usual spring sound is: Why have those bleeding needles points!?

Now a little more nuance. Only in a developed embouchure the influence of the ligature can be annihilated by the embouchure. For a developing embouchure different ligatures can increase the soundscape.

At the Breda Jazz festival in 2010 I saw an exception in a developed German saxophonist who got his own sound by using his ligature upside down.
 
I talked about pads being stolen earlier. Felt like a real thing but people jumped on it, but it has just occurred to me where it will likely be very probable - schools.

One school I taught at had a remit (and money) to develop music in the school (from nothing). They bought maybe 20-30 saxes. Arbiters and Jupiters. SATB. It was a major success - all sorts of ensembles. I even ran two SATB sax quartets, playing challenging Saxtet arrangements.

Anyway. School instruments get beaten up. I reckon that would include pads going missing.
 
Can't resist that. The usual spring sound is: Why have those bleeding needles points!?

Now a little more nuance. Only in a developed embouchure the influence of the ligature can be annihilated by the embouchure. For a developing embouchure different ligatures can increase the soundscape.

At the Breda Jazz festival in 2010 I saw an exception in a developed German saxophonist who got his own sound by using his ligature upside down.
No one I referred to has a “developing” embouchure. Including me.
 
Interesting topic. I always encourage people to fulfill their ideas. Make your own, or modify already existing, stuff. That's what sax players have done for many years. Back then it was just a few musicians that took part of the innovations, tips & tricks ...... today we are just talking on an international saxophone forum.

I miss the 70's and 80's with leaking saxes, terrible ergonomic, noisy key work ...... and the enthusiasm. It was possible to play at a jam, in a small band/group .... without having killer saxes/accessories. More heart, less brain. We don't need to be clever all the time.

Saxophone playing has became a "material sport"? Like golf.
 
Last edited:
I remember now. It was your stance on whether the material of a mouthpiece made any difference to the sound.
Ah yes that makes more sense than ligatures making a difference. I think it does but not when there is any kind of baffle and depending on the material itself.
 
Ah yes that makes more sense than ligatures making a difference. I think it does but not when there is any kind of baffle and depending on the material itself.
Probably a new post…

So what can people hear:

Differences in sound (if any) between:

Clarinet -

Wood vs plastic (vs metal)

Sax -

Older horns vs newer horns vs Graftonite

General -

Mouthpiece material

Reed -

Filed vs unfiled

Different cut

Manufacturer

Ligature -

Types/materials

How much contact with reed
 
I took "Pete's" Jupiter (trad pads) to Paul Carrington anyway and he found a few bits and bobs to sort. Left it with him for a service.

If @Griff is amenable I'll still let him have this one and the one with my pads to check over as a kind of adjudicator before they both go to Pete Effamy and onward to others when he's had all the time he needs. Where are you based @Pete Effamy ?
 
I took "Pete's" Jupiter (trad pads) to Paul Carrington anyway and he found a few bits and bobs to sort. Left it with him for a service.

If @Griff is amenable I'll still let him have this one and the one with my pads to check over as a kind of adjudicator before they both go to Pete Effamy and onward to others when he's had all the time he needs. Where are you based @Pete Effamy ?
I'm in GU33 Petersfield area David.Otherwise known as MyField
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom