Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

The end customer, on the other hand, needs to have seen a top musician or influencer using them.
This could be the biggest sticking point. Many (most?) of the top musicians will have had their sax for decades and won't wan't to change it.

There's another point. I think that it will change the sound. That's the biggest problem by far.
 
There's another point. I think that it will change the sound. That's the biggest problem by far.
Ok. Let's run with that. Changing the sound could be a selling point.
Here's a possible scenario: stiffer, lighter, not at all tacky pads might change the attack of the notes. Someone experiments with it and innovates their sound... That technique and sound gets picked up...

A large chunk of the history of music is people developing new sounds and styles out of technical innovations.
 
Ok. Let's run with that. Changing the sound could be a selling point.
Here's a possible scenario: stiffer, lighter, not at all tacky pads might change the attack of the notes. Someone experiments with it and innovates their sound... That technique and sound gets picked up...

A large chunk of the history of music is people developing new sounds and styles out of technical innovations.
It would only be a selling point as part of a horn as a whole.
 
Just another thought - presumably they are quite easy to pop off. And steal? 🤷🏻‍♂️
Yes, the black market for random sized neoprene saxophone pads is ever increasing.

To counter this, I generally keep my horns in a locked building.

But on stage at a gig I can well see a felon sneaking up with tweezers brandished, pinching the pads, and leaving the Super 20 Silversonic tenor sitting naked on its stand with the drunken player totally oblivious to the nearby goings on. 😉
 
Yes, the black market for random sized neoprene saxophone pads is ever increasing.

To counter this, I generally keep my horns in a locked building.

But on stage at a gig I can well see a felon sneaking up with tweezers brandished, pinching the pads, and leaving the Super 20 Silversonic tenor sitting naked on its stand with the drunken player totally oblivious to the nearby goings on. 😉
You’ve not been around many horn players with a prank in mind then..
 
It would only be a selling point as part of a horn as a whole.
I disagree. As an aside the one saxophone manufacturer who has expressed interest is also keen to build a prototype using my pads, but also with their engineering in no cups or minimal "skeleton" ones, carbon fibre rods, custom made adjustable pad arms. That would change weight, feel, ergonomics, and maybe the sound (but I doubt it).

They also suggested a myriad of aftermarket resonators so a player can change, or believe they're changing, the sound. This is where traditional pads cannot compete, well not cheaply, easily, or quickly.
It's so easy to remove a pad unscrew the retaining nut and replace the standard domed or flat reflector (I'm using MMs) with a different shaped one. This suggestion was aligned with the many guitarists who love to fiddle with aftermarket parts in order to produce a different sound, or so they may think.

Admittedly this is more of a sales gimmick than a proven science but who's to say Pete that your sound is the best it can be with your current set up?
What experimentation have you done using different mouthpieces? I guess loads. I'd bet you've tried dozens of them over the years and dozens of reeds with those dozens of mouthpieces?
So... add in different reflectors, Noyak, brass dome, seamless dome, solid brass, sterling silver, flat, plastic, Mickey Mouse (MMMMs - work it out!) shaped... and a whole new world of sound comes into your world. Now... how about trying a different neoprene blend too? A bit softer? A little harder? Thicker? Blue with pink dots...?

We're all conditioned to accept that the 150 year old pad design must be the pinnacle of technology. The best.
Really? How can that be when in just about every other area of our life technological advances have produced better solutions to just about everything?

Some of you may remember the days before cling film. Are you still using silver foil to wrap food, or tupperware perhaps (some may have a fetish here). Many moved from reel to reel tape to cassette to CD to memory stick to Alexa.
Do you still have a Ferrograph machine Pete?

I know some folks just have to have old "pure" technology, like vinyl records for instance, and that's fine.
But it is just possible there's a better solution than Adoplhe's spotting a cow all those years ago and thinking "That's it! That's the very material for my pads!!"
Otherwise we'd still be riding horses. Hang on... some of us do!
:thumb:
 
What experimentation have you done using different mouthpieces? I guess loads. I'd bet you've tried dozens of them over the years and dozens of reeds with those dozens of mouthpieces?
I think quite a few players do that, but very few experiment with pads in their search for the ultimate sound.
Are you still using silver foil to wrap food, or tupperware
I use silver foil or other reusable materials rather than single use plastic - consider the environment.
 
@Pete Effamy - how about I add you to the closed passaround group here to try out the next alto (Jupiter 767-769) or tenor (Beaugnier) prototype. Or you could wait a little for Yamaha alto and tenor prototypes coming after those?

It's great having sceptical testers as a balance to those who like the idea of change. Many revisions have been made thus far thanks to techs' and players' feedback. That's why it's taken so long. It might take forever with your input! 😉 I can't promise I can come up with the perfect pad but we certainly don't have those at present.

I also have an identical Jupiter 767-769 alto with traditional pads in what I'd call excellent playing condition. Would you be up for playing the two Jupiters blind, standard pads vs. mine, and saying which is which?
We could get a panel of pros together, see who gets it right. Maybe video the experiment?

You could end up as my first pro endorser! :rofl:

Or you all guess correctly and my pads are dead in the water. I'd get my life back at least... and my coat!
 
Admittedly this is more of a sales gimmick than a proven science but who's to say Pete that your sound is the best it can be with your current set up?
What experimentation have you done using different mouthpieces? I guess loads. I'd bet you've tried dozens of them over the years and dozens of reeds with those dozens of mouthpieces?
So... add in different reflectors, Noyak, brass dome, seamless dome, solid brass, sterling silver, flat, plastic, Mickey Mouse (MMMMs - work it out!) shaped... and a whole new world of sound comes into your world. Now... how about trying a different neoprene blend too? A bit softer? A little harder? Thicker? Blue with pink dots...?
I don’t disagree with this chain of thought, but they can’t be easily popped on (in place of the regular key cups/pads) and popped off again, so unless you have a horn I like with trad. Pads and another with your pads it’s not an experiment.
 
how about I add you to the closed passaround group here to try out the next alto (Jupiter 767-769) or tenor (Beaugnier) prototype. Or you could wait a little for Yamaha alto and tenor prototypes coming after those?
I wouldn’t enjoy any of those horns with normal pads, and if yours really won’t make any difference to the sound then I wouldn’t be enjoying them on the sax either.
 
A real world test, of the pads stability, after set level, would be staying in place thru the first 8 bars, with LeoP driving.
You might become the official pad supplier to the '28 Games in LA, for the new dance event,
Breaking with the Bari.
Individual and mixed team, with the women in high heels dancing backwards, when upright.
It could happen, says Tenuta. :banana:
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom