Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

Techs and retailers are going to be scared of innovation and innovation
Here's my guess:
Punter: here's my horn with weird pads:
Tech: <Google's DavidUK pads>
... A/ finds nothing but Cafe sax threads. "nah mate, no idea. Want some music medic pads?"
or
... B/ finds a site with explainer videos, spares to order or carried by professional supplier, a handy PDF for repair and maintenance, tools list and how to claim repair hours and parts on 'guarantee' "oh, yeah, ok, hand it over, ready in 2 weeks"
 
Last edited:
Retailer/Tech... "...but these pads have a lifetime guarantee against wear..."
Would that swing it?
It is a unique selling point for the players, but less for techs and stores. No return sales, less maintenance, why should I sell that?

..and you have to test them for a long time before you can sell that as a reliable salesman.

Can be used in extreme climates is probably a better pitch. But reduces the size of the market.
 
It is a unique selling point for the players, but less for techs and stores. No return sales, less maintenance, why should I sell that?

..and you have to test them for a long time before you can sell that as a reliable salesman.

Can be used in extreme climates is probably a better pitch. But reduces the size of the market.
Not the way global warming is going.
Then can be used under water might be even better.
 
Here's my guess:
Punter: here's my horn with weird pads:
Tech: <Google's DavidUK pads>
... A/ finds nothing but Cafe sax threads. "nah mate, no idea. Want some music medic pads?"
or
... B/ finds a site with explainer videos, spares to order or carried by professional supplier, a handy PDF for repair and maintenance, tools list and how to claim repair hours and parts on 'guarantee' "oh, yeah, ok, hand it over, ready in 2 weeks"
MM don't have any viable pads to compete with mine. Neo just doesn't work as I've explained already.

If and when my pads are ready for market AND I can be bothered to manufacture and sell them I hope to have a brand name, registered trademark, website, online ordering, tech network (oh yes, some techs ARE keen on my alternative), "how to" videos, etc., etc.

I say "hope" but I already have a registered trademark and domains secured as this costs very little.

I might even go the Superpads route and keep manufacture small, offering a re-pad service to those who like the idea as some seem to.

But unlike Schmidt, MM, Toptone, Padless, et al I won't go to market in any way shape or form unless they're faultless. That takes time.
Also, persuading anyone to go against the traditional leather grain (sic) is always going to be tricky. That's why an alternative has to work, perfectly. That's why they have to have many desirable features such as being Vegan; waterproof, airtight, self-levelling, height adjustable, instantly removable/replaceable; with a traditional "feel"; retro-fittable; no alteration to key cups or mechanisms; guaranteed for life.

That I've published my long trail of R&D rather than keep it hidden away is to both get a grasp on enthusiasm for my pads and so that the design can't be pinched and patented by someone else. I did go Patent Pending but after a year decided there's little point continuing with that as the Chinese will pinch the design if it does work out and it would be impossible to sue them. But if a reputable manufacturer tried for Patent without permission it would be easier to prove they copied my design by reference to my published content. Once you go public you can't get a Patent anyhow.

But overall my drive comes from simply finding a better solution to leather covered felt and card glued and manipulated by wizards to make them work. My alternative, when working 100%, will give me 99% satisfaction. Going the extra 1% and seeing my pads "up in lights" will most likely be more hassle than it's worth.
 
But overall my drive comes from simply finding a better solution to leather covered felt and card glued and manipulated by wizards to make them work.
I, and I think we all, know and appreciate that.
I was making the point, as you understood, that there's more to products than good engineering. I'm sure many techs would tackle almost anything, however unusual, if the required support was available from the manufacture... And details like that are part of producing a product.
 
When a pad can last 30+ years, still sealing and doing the job, do we need new pads? What drives development? I understand that some of us are curious to see if it's possible to develop new pads. And that's good. If I ever will be able to choose between "old skin pads" or "new XXXXXXX pads" I would go for skin pads. It's like electric cars vs fossil cars, Elvis vs Tommy, hamburgers vs cheeseburgers ....... .
 
30+ years require some serious maintenance. A pad that needs less pampering can be more popular when it can no be distinguished from the original in a blind test.
That's goes lots of things I own/use. To maintain things and buildings is important and something new for many persons. "Tomorrow starts a very long and ambitious maintenance program of the bridge and it will last for over 100 years", said a guy after the inauguration of the Öresunds bridge. My 86 years old Martin with pads installed in 1995 is doing well. The G4M I played I didn't get any serious maintain.
 
Last edited:
When a pad can last 30+ years, still sealing and doing the job, do we need new pads? What drives development? I understand that some of us are curious to see if it's possible to develop new pads. And that's good. If I ever will be able to choose between "old skin pads" or "new XXXXXXX pads" I would go for skin pads. It's like electric cars vs fossil cars, Elvis vs Tommy, hamburgers vs cheeseburgers ....... .
...fax machines vs. email...
 
I guess that it comes down to these considerations:

1. that any "out of whack" is almost eliminated (as you say, before going to market)
2. the cost is presumably similar to normal pads/cups
3. there would be no "bad factory setup" or shop "tuneup" needed at the point of selling
4. they would need to be fitted to a sax that people were interested in buying (for the reasons we list as saxes being desirable to buy)
5. if they could be knocked out of whack in transit between gigs, then they can be reset - thus enabling your own reset before any gig

So why am I not excited?
Put them on a Yani or Yam and I'd still not be excited - it's not my sax. So then we're into retrofitting...
 
I guess that it comes down to these considerations:

1. that any "out of whack" is almost eliminated (as you say, before going to market)
2. the cost is presumably similar to normal pads/cups
3. there would be no "bad factory setup" or shop "tuneup" needed at the point of selling
4. they would need to be fitted to a sax that people were interested in buying (for the reasons we list as saxes being desirable to buy)
5. if they could be knocked out of whack in transit between gigs, then they can be reset - thus enabling your own reset before any gig

So why am I not excited?
Put them on a Yani or Yam and I'd still not be excited - it's not my sax. So then we're into retrofitting...
Well my original intention was that they'd be retrofittable and indeed they are.

With pad costs spiralling they'd likely be cheaper, at least to start with until they get a foot hold in the market.
They need ONE total dismantle of the sax to glue the magnets into the key cups. This would be a tech or official installer job OR could be a DIY fit by a competent owner who can also do adjustment and regulation.

I can do this up to a point but would always want a tech to check my work as I'm not an expert. Hence my prototypes go to a well regarded tech who has been a great help so far albeit not sold on the idea.

After the initial magnet install, pad replacement needs no dismantling for the majority of pads. There are a few which get trapped by key guards. posts, etc. but these aren't in the main stacks which is a blessing. To replace all pads would take around an hour including initial individual pad height adjustment, as under.

Users could replace their own pads after the initial installation so long as the incoming pad has any height adjustment shims (washers) transferred from the outgoing pad screw. In practice users would likely want their tech to do this work. It's far quicker than a traditional re-pad. No glue necessary.

In transit by courier a few of the larger pads have become dislodged. These are simply pushed back until they click into place in the magnet. In everyday transit by the owner this is unlikely to occur. A new retaining magnet has been custom made to stop larger pads, because of their mass, from dropping out in transit. These are to have their first fit after bench testing in the "final" alto and tenor prototypes awaiting the outsourced pre-cut pads coming to me shortly. These will go to the tech for a final set-up before doing the rounds amongst players here, pro and amateur, as previously.

My "small business" alternative to retail and repairer routes would involve taking your sax Pete, fitting my pads, and off you go. If you don't like them you can refit traditional pads by removing the magnets. I use a pair of mole grips to break the magnet out and then remove any adhering debris in the cup. The cups are unharmed!

As for OEM fit, that would be good... please phone Yani and set up a meeting for me!
OEM could go further, such as doing away with key cups entirely for lightness which excites me but for which I don't have the engineering skills or equipment to try. I think the retro fit pads would have to get some rave reviews before a large manufacturer would be at all interested. Yes I know... hire a stand at NAMM. Any pro players here fancy a trip to California to demonstrate my pads and prototypes to the world?

But... let's not run before we can walk eh?...
 
I miss the fax machine. Secure and no "chat control".
I don't think they were very secure.
My first desktop computer had a fax program on it that I had no use for so it wasn't activated until one day the machine told me someone had tried to send a fax. Out of curiosity I activated the software and an hour later they tried again.
The Canadian immigration department sent me a copy of the passport and personal details of a woman entering the country that they had some doubts about.
That made a change from my phone number being mixed up with BICC.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom