Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

With pad costs spiralling they'd likely be cheaper, at least to start with until they get a foot hold in the market.

I have always been advised not a good strategy - your initial price sets an expectation so raising it later (beyond normal inflation) is going to put people off. Maybe a way round that is an initial discounting (e.g. introductory off) but even then that works better with a subscription model than item prices.
 
I don't think they were very secure.
My first desktop computer had a fax program on it that I had no use for so it wasn't activated until one day the machine told me someone had tried to send a fax. Out of curiosity I activated the software and an hour later they tried again.
The Canadian immigration department sent me a copy of the passport and personal details of a woman entering the country that they had some doubts about.
That made a change from my phone number being mixed up with BICC.
Did you pass her or was she dodgy?
 
I have always been advised not a good strategy - your initial price sets an expectation so raising it later (beyond normal inflation) is going to put people off. Maybe a way round that is an initial discounting (e.g. introductory off) but even then that works better with a subscription model than item prices.
I could be more expensive, like Super pads, so as to show mine are the Rolls Royce of pads. Who's for a £1,000 re-pad?
 
I could be more expensive, like Super pads, so as to show mine are the Rolls Royce of pads. Who's for a £1,000 re-pad?
Well, for a retrofit, you've already committed to
They need ONE total dismantle of the sax
So, it's already expensive. I guess the assumption is that a sax needs a complete disassembly anyway... oil, bits straightened etc. and complete repad anyway. So a tech is going to have to be confident to offer the mag-pads as a premium alternative.
So,. again, what gives the tech confidence?
And, as for discount... Probably one would want to give the tech an appealing margin more than a discount to the end customer.
The end customer, on the other hand, needs to have seen a top musician or influencer using them.
 
One other important need, apart from sounding like a saxophone, is feeling like one.

Why it should have to feel like a traditionally padded horn is odd. Why can't it feel better?

Well... because what IS better? Nobody knows! But familiarity is all I can aspire to at present, making it sound and feel like the "old" system pads.

Maybe there is no better feel anyhow.
 
I don't think they were very secure.
My first desktop computer had a fax program on it that I had no use for so it wasn't activated until one day the machine told me someone had tried to send a fax. Out of curiosity I activated the software and an hour later they tried again.
The Canadian immigration department sent me a copy of the passport and personal details of a woman entering the country that they had some doubts about.
That made a change from my phone number being mixed up with BICC.
No connection to computers. The fax had their own lines/telephone numbers.
 
No connection to computers. The fax had their own lines/telephone numbers.
Back in the day, you may remember computers using dial up internet and were plugged in to the phone line via a 56k fax/modem. Fax on computers was a feature most people had but had no use for and were probably unaware they even had.

Now days you can still fax from a computer/smartphone via a web service on the internet.

I work for the NHS -faxes were banned a few years ago as you can send anything anywhere -you can verify that you've sent it, but if the receiving fax machine is in a public place anyone can take an incoming fax, also you can pick up more than one fax at a time or mix up pages. We've also banned printing without physically walking up to s printer and inputting your PIN number to get it to print.
 
One other important need, apart from sounding like a saxophone, is feeling like one.

Why it should have to feel like a traditionally padded horn is odd. Why can't it feel better?

Well... because what IS better? Nobody knows! But familiarity is all I can aspire to at present, making it sound and feel like the "old" system pads.

Maybe there is no better feel anyhow.

There is not much consensus on feel. My own observation is that when the pad hits all points on the tone hole at the same time you have the best feed back in which position the pad closes. Any stickiness or sponginess reduces the sharpness of this signal.
 
I’ve been reading this thread (with interest) for quite a while. I’m curious about a couple of issues that spring to mind.

First, how do these pads wear? Will they compress over time, as leather and felt pads do? What about losing resiliency, i.e. hardening and becoming inflexible.

Second, does the easy moveability of the pads present any issues for regulation, particulary on the stack keys or bell keys? It seems to me that getting a proper seal on the pads is what is done first, with timing regulation done after that is achieved. (Ideally anyway, sometimes this a back and forth activity…). But if the pad can easily move in and out of proper placement, how does one ensure good regulation? And will it last?
 
The neoprene should be long lasting.
It has a low compression set so springs back to its original state if left for 24-48hrs. Being waterproof and airtight the material won't become contaminated by saliva. The pads are removable so they can be washed, in a dishwasher if you prefer.

The pads are held firmly in place by strong neodymium magnets. They do not flop about in between key strokes like Schmidt or MM Neo pads (I've tried both).
When first inserted your finger pressure will set the pads level and that's where they stay in normal use. If the horn is mishandled, perhaps in transit, some pads may be knocked out of level. Simply by closing the sprung open pads you'll reset them all to level once again.

When regulating, the pads will all be set level as above and will stay level during regulation.

There was a "gorilla grip" issue a while back where a pad could be squeezed hard and not quite return to level. This was down to too much friction between magnet and pad screw head and was engineered out with a lower friction magnet coating. This still holds the pad in its levelled setting whilst playing.

Strong magnets keep their magnetic strength and initial regulation will last unlike traditional pads where saliva ingress can swell, harden, and distort leather and felt over time. My neoprene pads are 1.5mm thick including the stainless steel backing disc. The neoprene is unaffected by saliva.
 
Are the magnets strong enough to mess up the regulation of mechanical wrist watches or even pacemakers? You might need to include a warning with each set.
 
Are the magnets strong enough to mess up the regulation of mechanical wrist watches or even pacemakers? You might need to include a warning with each set.
I suppose that accumulated total of magnets could be quite significant and I don't see a way round that.
 
Great project and I hope you get it sorted out and make it for Alto flute. :clapping:

I guess neoprene durometer is a factor as well.
Back in the late '70s we made 6 string guitar pickups with long and fat Alnico magnets. So strong, that Jerry and the Pacemakers, decided not to
try them. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Are the magnets strong enough to mess up the regulation of mechanical wrist watches or even pacemakers? You might need to include a warning with each set.
Yes, I looked into this in detail to the point of calculating the field of pull for the specific magnets used. I will include a warning but actually it's the pacemaker manufacturers who stress to users to watch out for what others may regard as everyday items. Microwaves, loudspeakers, etc.
Laid across the chest some magnets would perhaps be within the 50mm "danger zone" but the advice from pacemaker makers and medics is to simply move away if a problem is detected. It's really not that big an issue.
 
Last edited:
I’ve been reading this thread (with interest) for quite a while. I’m curious about a couple of issues that spring to mind.

First, how do these pads wear? Will they compress over time, as leather and felt pads do? What about losing resiliency, i.e. hardening and becoming inflexible.

Second, does the easy moveability of the pads present any issues for regulation, particulary on the stack keys or bell keys? It seems to me that getting a proper seal on the pads is what is done first, with timing regulation done after that is achieved. (Ideally anyway, sometimes this a back and forth activity…). But if the pad can easily move in and out of proper placement, how does one ensure good regulation? And will it last?

Excellent question Skeller.

Compression is something of the leather/felt pads. When using silicone or neoprene without air bubbles compression can be neglected.

Leather, neoprene and silicone can all harden in time. This can result in leaks when the pad doesn't fit exactly to the tone hole rim. My solution is the use of molding in place with a last layer of around 0.2 mm. With a shrinkage of 5% this gives a theoretical error of 0.01 mm. I can't measure that or see it. Having a tight fit makes you less dependent of elasticity to close the last small leaks. Ensuring a perfect flat tone hole rim is another solution, but that is hard.

Problems with regulation are in most cases caused by grip strength. Leather pads have the bad habit to give a short timed reward for gorilla grip.

By having a tight fit you can feel a clear snap when the pad is closed and you can learn to minimize grip.
Thin strips of silicone give a real snappy feeling, also more mechanical noise. At the moment I use 0.2 -0.3 mm silicone layers as my preferred balance between feeling and mechanical noise. This is also dependent on the dimensions of the tone hole and the type of silicone.

Hard leather pads are also used to give this snappy feeling but they have more leakage problems than soft leather pads, so your ears say to your inner gorilla: more grip.
There are fans of hard leather pads, but I am not one of them.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom