Great Players Who gets your vote for best rock n roll sax?

Johnny Knox is good. I don't know what happened after "Doin' Whar It Takes". Lenny Pickett played sax on two tracks. And to finished the recordings the call in Jimmy Carpenter to do the sax tracks. Carpenter was in UK for some months ago.
View: https://youtu.be/k8XMq1T1aig
Jimmy Carpenter is The Man!
Tours USA and Europe. Keep an eye on his ‘Web site for dates -
 
Not only but also, check out Eddie's Albums,
he also plays, rock, pop, R'n'B, Soul, Ballads, Standards and . . . and . . .

Clarence will be missed for always !!
I like Ed Manion music as well. Today I'm not buying so many CD's from USA or UK. The taxes and fees are too high.

Ed Manion been around for many years. He played/tour with Springsteen, Southside Johnny, Gary US Bonds, Mink Deville ...... .
 
Jake Clemons, Clarence nephew, use to be play sax with Bruce Springsteen. Jake is also a part of E Street Horns. A 5-piece horn section (bs,ts,2 trp,trb). Ed Manion is the other sax player in the section.

Jake playing "Jungleland" in Gothenburg 2012.
View: https://youtu.be/-qv3r7zcM-Y
Thanks, Thom! Jake played well in this video; it was a fitting and heartfelt tribute. I appreciate you sharing this.
Best,
Aaron
 
I remember buying Eddies first Album many years ago now and for some reason from the pic on the Album cover I always thought he was Australian. - So I must take this opportunity - I hereby apologise. 😱:rolleyes::doh:
FollowThrough.jpg
 
Always really enjoyed Lee Allen's solos on many of the Little Richard hit records :sax:

One of the first recordings by Richard that really got my attention was "Keep a Knockin'" featuring Grady Gaines on tenor who was his music director during The Upsetters years. Filled the dance floors and the parents did not care for it! But then I was a little wild during those years:clapping:

The drum intro would be used years later by another band. Remember who?

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHrAZhQEO90
 
Always really enjoyed Lee Allen's solos on many of the Little Richard hit records :sax:

One of the first recordings by Richard that really got my attention was "Keep a Knockin'" featuring Grady Gaines on tenor who was his music director during The Upsetters years. Filled the dance floors and the parents did not care for it! But then I was a little wild during those years:clapping:

The drum intro would be used years later by another band. Remember who?

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHrAZhQEO90
Both Alen and Gaines are good R&R sax players. Gaines is "heavier". Allen was playing with more ease as his tongue gave there reed electric current. Allen was one of a kind.
 
What’s the criteria for “best”?

- The player that most fits his solo to the music?
- …best sound/control/technique?
- …did he play for others and equally nail what the music demanded?

I like Sam Butera and Plas Johnson. I’m not particularly well-listened in this genre so there will be others that I like but haven’t mentioned/don’t know.

Maybe my criteria is a bit like this:

- can wail
- say a lot using one note
- can use different tones / manipulate sound
- ability to outline chord movements if appropriate
- complete control of horn
- has a “great” sound (completely my call 🤣)
- good solo construction

Crazy really.
 
What’s the criteria for “best”?

- The player that most fits his solo to the music?
- …best sound/control/technique?
- …did he play for others and equally nail what the music demanded?

I like Sam Butera and Plas Johnson. I’m not particularly well-listened in this genre so there will be others that I like but haven’t mentioned/don’t know.

Maybe my criteria is a bit like this:

- can wail
- say a lot using one note
- can use different tones / manipulate sound
- ability to outline chord movements if appropriate
- complete control of horn
- has a “great” sound (completely my call 🤣)
- good solo construction

Crazy really.
.... best Rock & Roll Sax?

What's Rock & Roll Sax? An umbrella name for saxes in blues, R&B, soul, funk, reggae, ska, rock , smooth jazz/ballad, schlagers, pop ..... , I almost forgot the style, Rock & Roll? Hard to say.

What do you want a Rock & Saxophone player to be? A session musicians, a live performer, an A&R man, with sax as main instrument, who made things happen ......?

Or is it just sax players that are forever engraved in our hearts? In this case I say John Fogerty, Bobby Keys and Clarence Clemons. They were in my boy's room and joined me when I moved out. 55 years later still in the house. Long friendship.
 
Last edited:
What’s the criteria for “best”?

- can wail
- say a lot using one note
- can use different tones / manipulate sound
- ability to outline chord movements if appropriate
- complete control of horn
- has a “great” sound (completely my call 🤣)
- good solo construction
I tend to think of these, and rock & roll playing in general as being about a sense of theatre and drama. Its performative in a way that most jazz isn't - a huge chunk of what became R&R originated with southern preachers declaiming their gospels. Its got a pretty straightforward agenda...
 
I tend to think of these, and rock & roll playing in general as being about a sense of theatre and drama. Its performative in a way that most jazz isn't - a huge chunk of what became R&R originated with southern preachers declaiming their gospels. Its got a pretty straightforward agenda...
That’s a good thought. Whenever I step up for a solo I still have to say to myself “don’t be a jazzer”.
 
I tend to think of these, and rock & roll playing in general as being about a sense of theatre and drama. Its performative in a way that most jazz isn't - a huge chunk of what became R&R originated with southern preachers declaiming their gospels. Its got a pretty straightforward agenda...
Of course it is. You often find good R&R singers in the south ..... gospel and gospel changes were important when R&B "delivered" R&R ..... and the R&R saxophonist gave an extra voice to R&R .... a dedicated and introvert R&R saxophonist can be a great showman. It was not so much repeated tricks and gags ....
 
Reading another thread I saw Van Morrison kicked down some pegs for his sax playing.

But as designated regular Rolling Stones sax side, the late Bobby Keys really hauled it. He played that famous sax on Brown Sugar.

Toured and recorded with Stones and other acts. Died in 2014. ( Was replaced by Karl Denson.)

I'm voting for Bobby Keys. Who gets your vote, any rock band, any era?
Bobby Keys gets my vote…great solo in Can’t you hear me knocking
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,239
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom