It's time for me to post an update on my experience with ZhengHao pads. I've now done 3 repads with them. 2 sopranos and 1 tenor. In between, to make things more interesting and have perspective, I did a couple of repads using Music Medic sourced pads. Both altos. One with Chocolate Roo pads, the other with Standard Tan. So here are my notes and feelings.
The first soprano went well, but left the premises so quickly that I can't really say how they are holding on. Having said that, I did spend a couple of weeks play testing until I was happy with the outcome and they appeared to do their job.
Next was a Chocolate Roo Pads set I ordered for a YAS-23. As far as I remember, it went very well. Most pads fit perfectly, I even had to use some sweet pinky ribbons to make sure I could extract them from their key cups after dry fitting! Bottom line is I'm delighted with the outcome. I'd say these are great pads. But the horn wasn't in bad shape either. Pads were a bit old and dry.
Next, I did a tenor, using a Pad Set ordered from ZhengHao, for a YTS-23. The fit wasn't as good as with the MM Chocolate Roos, but were good enough to perform the job without trouble. I have been playing this horn for two months as my main tenor and it's fine.
Next I did another Soprano. An old Hawkes & son XX Century. The issues I had were not related to the pads, although they were probably a touch on the thick side, but it went well in the end and I'm playing it from time to time.
Finally, I did a Martin Indiana alto, using Standard Tan from MM. Sadly, I discovered that there had been a mistake in the shipment, it was a Pad Set and one of the large pads was missing. MM reacted beautifully and sent it right away. So, there again, I must say the MM service is excellent. Now, to be honest, it's difficult to compare the feel of pads with horns as different as a YAS-23 and a Martin Indiana. I clearly prefer the YAS-23 with it's Chocolate Roo pads, but I'm not sure the pads are the reason.
Conclusion:
ZhengHao's pads are OK. They do the job, but are not as well made as MM's pads. They can be irregular with off centered resonators/rivets. Something I have not seen with MM pads.
What makes me consider ZhengHao's pads is obviously their very attractive price, although you need to be patient to receive them... It'll take a few weeks.
I just checked their website as I have another project I'd like to get started and I found they now offer Kangaroo pads. They are 3 times more expensive than the regular ones, but that's still way cheaper than MM. How good are they. I can't tell. But I might give them a try. At 33$ a set for alto, it's tempting.
Price aside, my preference goes to the Chocolate Roo pads, then the Standard Tan from MM.
Keep in mind that I'm not a professional repairer, so it's only worth my 2 cents!