• New!

    Try our new Social Feeds, look out for the navigation icon: . You can now set default social feed view in your account preferences.

Beginner recording Recording Progress

Status
Not open for further replies. This may be temporary.
I just recorded this, and thought I'd post here instead of starting a new thread. I did a mid-side recording which ended up seeming a bit lop-sided but the stereo effect is nice. It's a bit hard to always be centered in front of the mics but I think I want to record this way anyway. I also used a Fairchild 670 emulation for compression on the track. Comments welcome, thanks for listening.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkH0lPyvCVY
 
I mastered this in Logic. I think this mix came out a lot better. Also I'm using a mid-side recording technique and got the mic setup / playing position sorted so it's centered. I want to do the geek out thing and talk about gear and techniques but instead I'll leave it to your ears to listen to and enjoy (or not.)

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_9CMtD-tg8
 
Don't hear enough depth/resonance to your sound.
Even when just playing acoustically, that's an important element, especially on Tenor.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9YNDZlpnl4o
Based on your feedback and my feeling about this, the two things I'll do next time is record with no or less HPF on either mic, then master in Pro Tools with the Fairchild 670 emulator. That means when I make the backing track I don't apply master bus compression. I like the flexibility of Logic though but it doesn't come with this specific plug-in which I like. The good thing is that I can always try Logic again and play around with the settings later but the Fairchild 670 is the tried and true classic sound of old jazz recordings.
 
It's late, I'm tired, but I still felt like playing. For this recording, I had to switch around my pre-amps to get more gain with my ribbon mic. Then when mixing, I found a "less-is-more" approach worked best. I only used a limiter on this, no reverb or compression. Feedback welcome, thanks for listening.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-jvE-u4p5U
 
Hi @AlonW,

Again I think that this your best recording yet!
- as in your previous few recordings, you've 'stuck to the melody'
- though your 'lazy timing' isn't perhaps always perfect, you're improving with each recording!
-post-processing 'raw sax audio is still (for me) a 'dark art' but you did well! Your preferred 'breathy sound' still came through, But the 'sharp edges' (higher frequencies) were nicely rounded off. Making this recording far less of a 'raw recording' and much more of a 'thoughtfully processed' recording.

So my congrats on both points. Especially on your processing of your 'raw recording'! For me it was much more enjoyable to listen to than your previous 'raw recordings.
 
Last edited:
Hi @AlonW,
... -post-processing 'raw sax audio is still (for me) a 'dark art' but you did well! Your preferred 'breathy sound' still cam through, But the 'sharp edges' (higher frequencies) were nicely rounded off. Making this recording far less of a 'raw recording' and much more of a 'thoughtfully processed' recording.

So my congrats on both points. Especially on your processing of your 'raw recording'! For me it was much more enjoyable to listen to than your previous 'raw recordings.
Whether processing or post-processing 'live sax, it takes IMHO some time and experimentation to get 'the sound' as you want it to be. if you're not completely satisfied with your recorded 'sound', there's always plenty of time to 'tweak; and experiment with other settings.

As has often been noted - becoming a more competent 'sax mixer', while perhaps inspiring you to record more, doesn't add anything to your sax playing abilities or development. So improving your sax playing abilities is always priority 1.
 
Hi @AlonW,

Again I think that this your best recording yet!
- as in your previous few recordings, you've 'stuck to the melody
- though your 'lazy timing' isn't perhaps always perfect, you're improving with each reco -post-processing 'raw sax audio is still (for me) a 'dark art' but you did well! Your preferred 'breathy sound' still cam through, But the 'sharp edges' (higher frequencies) were nicely rounded off. Making this recording far less of a 'raw recording' and much more of a 'thoughtfully processed' recording.

So my congrats on both points. Especially on your processing of your 'raw recording'! For me it was much more enjoyable to listen to than your previous 'raw recordings.
Mike, I appreciate the feedback! I also thought this came out pretty good at first too (in terms of the mix) but later felt it was a little subdued sounding overall, however my following few experiments came out much worse. So in the end this is probably the best starting point I have for continuing to refine my mixes. The technical problem I was having was too low of a recording volume with my ribbon mic, so I picked up a cloud lifter CL-1 today, which will add gain and has a lower, possibly more optimal input impedance than the pre-amp. But in terms of basic mixing techniques I'm going to stick with this as an example. Once I have the process down it will free up more energy to work on the actual music playing. 🙂
 
Hi @AlonW, you post so many recordings that I'm not going to comment again on your technique. Just on the recording quality between this track and "I like Myself". This track again sounded 'raw' in comparison to your post-processing of "I like Myself". FWIW, I think it's worthwhile experimenting with the sax tone that you either process during the recording or in post-procssing.

TBH this (to my ears 'raw' recording) is a step backwards from your sound quality on "I like Myself".

Mike
 
Hi @AlonW, you post so many recordings that I'm not going to comment again on your technique. Just on the recording quality between this track and "I like Myself". This track again sounded 'raw' in comparison to your post-processing of "I like Myself". FWIW, I think it's worthwhile experimenting with the sax tone that you either process during the recording or in post-procssing.

TBH this (to my ears 'raw' recording) is a step backwards from your sound quality on "I like Myself".

Mike
Because I had reed troubles for so long I spent less time mixing this. I believe I have worked out my sound in my latest video “I’m Late”!
 
Status
Not open for further replies. This may be temporary.

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Trending

Latest Song of the Month

Forum statistics

Topics
32,236
Messages
575,068
Members
8,066
Latest member
Boomer
Back
Top Bottom