Saxophones Recommendations for first Baritone

But I'm still always dubious when someone says "it's identical therefore is a stencil made in the same factory" when in fact it could be made in a different factory, just to the same design. And a design can be sold, licensed, reverse engineered or stolen. And once you put that possibility into the mix you can have different raw materials, different skill and different QC.
I 100% agree with this. The ease with which a design as simple as a sax can be reverse engineered, together with the extreme difficulty of enforcing a patent over an instrument designed in the 1800s means that even saxes which look to be superficially the same could well have been made in different locations, by a different people using different materials, to different quality control standards.
 
But I'm still always dubious when someone says "it's identical therefore is a stencil made in the same factory"

Thanks Pete!

I suppose none of this matters if the instrument plays well and is constructed well enough to stand up to the rigors of playing and performance.

Clearly there are only a finite number of workshops in Taiwan where these parts are made and/or assembled.

P. Mauriat is charging a premium for their brand and the "P. Mauriat" stamp on the bell. From the available info that I can find, they have their own assembly facility but produce no parts on their own. It would seem reasonable that distributors such as Thomann would provide the provenance of what they sell, given that they provide the added value of setup etc.

I have never understood the secrecy around where these Asian horns are manufactured and assembled.
 
I have never understood the secrecy around where these Asian horns are manufactured and assembled.
Brands protecting their investment.

There have been instances of some companies advertising their products as "the same as...made in the same factory .... but half the price" And they can get away with it if the product does indeed look identical.

But as I said above - identical looking doesn't mean same materials, skill of either mechanised or hand work and QC even if they aren't just using the same template in a different factory.
 
Bottom line: are there enough people playing the LowJazz bari to verify that it is a well constructed great-sounding instrument at less than 1/2 the price of a Mauriat 302?
Slight side note to this:
It would be relevant to know what their experience is with other bari's.
Looking at myself for instance, I have a (low A) Stephanhouser bari that I bought secondhand (through this forum). I am very pleased with it, but I have nothing to compare it with. I never played another bari before this one.
Same thing with my tenor, I have been playing my YTS32 for about 20 years. I did have the occasional blow on another tenor (2 or 3 others). That means that I don't realy have anything to compare those saxes with.
I am pleased with them, but perhaps I am just ignorant of how much better some other brands/types are.
 
Bottom line: are there enough people playing the LowJazz bari to verify that it is a well constructed great-sounding instrument at less than 1/2 the price of a Mauriat 302?
If think you ask; are there enough people, with enough experience .... . I've played my friend LowJazz and I think it's a good bari. I've never played a Mauriat 302. But I'm not the right man to so why the X bari is better tha the Y bari. There are guys that can ... .

I have never understood the secrecy around where these Asian horns are manufactured and assembled.
It was the same with european brands (former manufacturer?). I saw a french XXXXXX bari to low Bb the other day. I didn't look at the body- bell brace, palm key touches, the design of the lh and rh cluster .... I just looked at the bow and the angle of the low key C key and the angle/design was the same as a bari sax that was made behind the iron curtain. I've seen this on many other brands as well.
But there isn't much difference for manufacturing apart from removing a key and linkage and stamping out a shorter bell.
Is it easy? I don't know? To add the straight section (with low B tonehole a the Conn 11M low A) was not a success according to bari specialists. I've played a Conn 11M (Crowall-Collier Macmillan) and a Conn 13M (United Musical Instruments) and I think they were both good. But the13M played better because it was brand new. The low A Weltklang (also an added bell section construction) I played in a punkrock band was good. But what do I know? To make lot's of noise is enough for me. The more, the better. The low A MkVI alto didn't became the success that Selmer expected. I would probably like that horn as well.
 
Last edited:
o add the straight section (with low B tonehole a the Conn 11M low A) was not a success according to bari specialists.
I don’t think the straight section was such an issue, it was more the key linkage because the low A requires the low Bb to also be fingered.
 
Howarth’s have a line of Chiltern bari’s that look identical to the Thomann BariPro line, the Howarth technicians have apparently said in the past they’re from the same production lines as System 54, Mauriat etc… unsure if that’s true - I wonder if anyone’s tried a Howarth bari?
 
they’re from the same production lines as System 54, Mauriat etc
I'm fairly sure I know the origin of the System 54 instruments and it has nothing to do with P.Mauriat. There is a lot of hearsay, speculation and maybe wishful thinking out there.

I would be quite confident that Howarth's own line would be good though.
 
I'm fairly sure I know the origin of the System 54 instruments and it has nothing to do with P.Mauriat. There is a lot of hearsay, speculation and maybe wishful thinking out there.

I would be quite confident that Howarth's own line would be good though.

I'd imagine that there's a couple of factories (as said earlier) with the exact same spec and differing levels of success. Unsure whether to order in a Thomann to try (which are cheaper than the Howarth ones) or just go to Howarths.

I'm really not a fan of the Howarths store though, the lack of soundproofing is a barrier to really trying an instrument as Im constantly worrying about the customers upstairs!
 
A saxophone brand had a video on thier web site to show how thier baris were made on Taiwan. It was a small workshop that were just making baris. Just two persons on the line; father and son. I guess the production was good. QC would be better with less persons in the shop. They made good saxes and a symphatic business model as well.
 
but I think the P.Mauriat low Bb Bari may be an adaptation of a low A Bari (as opposed to the Conn 11M being a low A adaptation of a Bb) .
Ooooh!

That's an interesting idea implying that reverse/reverse engineering from Low-Bb to Low-A and then back again means a modern Low-Bb bari could've lost it's acoustic balls in the transitions to and from its original form

Makes sense that this could happen
I am pleased with them, but perhaps I am just ignorant of how much better some other brands/types are
I smell GAS
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom