Playing the saxophone Plateau, intermediate player

If you've got poor rhythm, go dancing.
My ex girlfriend, a beautiful black lady would say: But he's a white boy! He ain't got no rhythm 🙂

Seriously, like anything else, rhythm, or time can be learned and needs to be practiced. I keep a drum set around just for that purpose and practice nylon-string guitar finger picking. If your timing is off with those, it is akin to physical pain.
 
I'm dubious of saying I can play a saxophone. Compared to others I know, they're far better, I wish I had their ability. I also know players who wish they could get the sound I can.

Also agree with @Colin the Bear about the journey, even with my teacher we sometimes pause things and look at something else. We're back on improvisation at the moment, and I'm quite excited about it... I still look at some of the duets, but that can get repetitive as I'm trying to perfect sections I struggle with.
 
When I first read your post I baulked a bit at the "my technique is pretty solid" bit - after just 14 months of playing. Then I read on a bit and you talk about tonguing etc. This is part of basic technique, and a solid basic technique usually takes most people rather a few years.

So then I wondered (and this is where a good mentor/teacher/more experienced player) if you'd ever had a decent chat with anyone about what we're trying to achieve with our basic sound production/articulation etc. I'm not trying to be flippant, moreover that playing music is like many things: it's much easier if we know what we're trying to create/aim for.

Articulation for example: it's really valuable hearing someone play with a really nice legato tongue - you can hear the notes are articulated but there is no hint of the tongue action being heard - a "thh" sound or a hard T sound. Merely reading in a book about a relaxed tongue with a small amount of travel and where it contacts the reed... it's nothing without hearing it.
 
I'm dubious of saying I can play a saxophone. Compared to others I know, they're far better, I wish I had their ability. I also know players who wish they could get the sound I can.

Also agree with @Colin the Bear about the journey, even with my teacher we sometimes pause things and look at something else. We're back on improvisation at the moment, and I'm quite excited about it... I still look at some of the duets, but that can get repetitive as I'm trying to perfect sections I struggle with.
I've been told I have a good sound but I'm lied to alot .
 
Here is some stuff to help you out: 12 MEDIUM EASY JAZZ, BLUES & FUNK ETUDES - C EDITION: Bob Mintzer:

Just make sure you pick the correct key for your instrument (Eb for alto or Bb for tenor/sop). You get the sheet music along with a backing track and a play-along recorded by Bob. There is a ton of stuff out there, you just need to find something that matches your level of playing. Probably best to start with "easy" etudes before you get frustrated.

As for being lied to, record yourself and wait 2-3 days before you listen to it, if possible in the presence of your wife or significant other. Hips don't lie, lips often do.
 
Amen.

“Be the time…”. I love this. I played bass drum in high school and college marching bands, and guitar in a Top 40 band - I credit those experiences for reinforcing my sense of time. An interesting aside (interesting to me, at least) is that Jerry Bergonzi plays drums (kit), and plays very well. I’ve seen him break out a cow bell too.

Come to think of it, I have almost always had various hand percussion in my gig bag for Latin or rock gigs: cowbell, afuche, guiro, and shakers.
I try and think I'm doing better at knowing what the 1 is in some tunes, I'm getting better but have miles and miles to go. Yea you were into music at a young age , I'm sure the beat is easy for you to get.
 
Here is some stuff to help you out: 12 MEDIUM EASY JAZZ, BLUES & FUNK ETUDES - C EDITION: Bob Mintzer:

Just make sure you pick the correct key for your instrument (Eb for alto or Bb for tenor/sop). You get the sheet music along with a backing track and a play-along recorded by Bob. There is a ton of stuff out there, you just need to find something that matches your level of playing. Probably best to start with "easy" etudes before you get frustrated.

As for being lied to, record yourself and wait 2-3 days before you listen to it, if possible in the presence of your wife or significant other. Hips don't lie, lips often do.
How come a couple days after? And right about the hips and lips.
 
You need to click with your teacher for sure, but the things you’ve described about him makes me thing there is a problem with you as well. Seems like you want to be able to read, but don’t want to really put in the time it takes. That said, some teachers just know one way to present things, and cannot adapt, which is bad if a student has a learning issue. Good advice so far, especially about separating the the rhythms from the notes.

Reading music is like reading words - you see the symbol, in your mind you instantly know it’s a Bb, for a beat and a half. There should be no translation happening, like when you see the word “apple” you don’t have to go into your internal dictionary to figure out what it means - you know it instantly. If reading music isn’t like that for you, then you just need to do it more - until it is 🙂

Regarding ”keeping the beat” and “finding 1”, things that you say you have trouble with, can you keep count listening to a song? Choose a song you know well, maybe one you’d like to perform, and count (1,2,3,4) throughout the song. Can you do that? Can you keep the count (again, 1,2,3,4) for a minute with a metronome? Be the time, be the clock, keep the beat. Without that internal clock ticking along precisely, you have no chance to read music well. Or play it for that matter. Keep working with the metronome.

If the metronome is so dry sounding it drives you crazy, use a drum machine or drum loop. There’s a great app called Drum Genius that has 500 loops, many styles, it’s less than $10. Excellent beats, I use it sometimes when writing - I’m not alone, I learned about it from a composer on YouTube, and Jay Metcalf of Better Sax uses it too.
Yes I'm looking for another instructor, there aren't many around where I live . I am doing better, and am putting in the time, identifying notes up an down the scales has come easy to me, except in the altisomo? range. I go through the books trying to learn whatever I can in regards to playing, today was a great day of practice and I learned several things and was able to work them into my practice. I will definitely try what you said to find the 1, that should be a great tool for me. The knowledge here is amazing . Thank you!
 
I need to get something to record with better quality. Any suggestions ?

I'm no expert, there are some recent suggestions in this thread though,

 
How come a couple days after? And right about the hips and lips.
because you still feel some kind euphoria immediately after recording it but the longer you wait, the more objective your listening becomes. Especially if you try to do a couple of takes over and you realize the progress you make. And then you listen to something from a few days past and ....
 
If you grab your sax and play five songs what kind of music are you then playing? I send some sound files to a R&B, Blues, Soul, R&R..... player in TN. I played a slow tenor solo with a backing track. He wrote back and told me I was going to play more slow R&B ballads. I was, still is, stuck in up-tempo rock, blues and often playing in the higher register. I also posted some songs with me on the bari. Easy songs like Lucille, Stand By Me ...... I just played bari to make the music bigger.
 
Last edited:
How come a couple days after? And right about the hips and lips.
Listening straight after you record, you're influenced by what you were trying to do.
A couple of days later and you've forgotten what you were trying to do and can hear what you did.

Also listening back straight away is always disappointing. A recording through a speaker will always compare poorly to a horn in the room.
 
because you still feel some kind euphoria immediately after recording it but the longer you wait, the more objective your listening becomes. Especially if you try to do a couple of takes over and you realize the progress you make. And then you listen to something from a few days past and ....
That makes sense! I will try that. I'm still trying to develop a good embouchure for the tenor, after practice for a few hours straight I start to get fatigued, then my sound changes, I have noticed that just by ear , not even recording myself. It's a definite workout trying to keep a good embouchure, so much to work on, but the advice here helps so much, thank you!
 
Listening straight after you record, you're influenced by what you were trying to do.
A couple of days later and you've forgotten what you were trying to do and can hear what you did.

Also listening back straight away is always disappointing. A recording through a speaker will always compare poorly to a horn in the room.
Interesting, I guess maybe it's an acoustic thing and distortion, makes sense
 
When I first read your post I baulked a bit at the "my technique is pretty solid" bit - after just 14 months of playing. Then I read on a bit and you talk about tonguing etc. This is part of basic technique, and a solid basic technique usually takes most people rather a few years.

So then I wondered (and this is where a good mentor/teacher/more experienced player) if you'd ever had a decent chat with anyone about what we're trying to achieve with our basic sound production/articulation etc. I'm not trying to be flippant, moreover that playing music is like many things: it's much easier if we know what we're trying to create/aim for.

Articulation for example: it's really valuable hearing someone play with a really nice legato tongue - you can hear the notes are articulated but there is no hint of the tongue action being heard - a "thh" sound or a hard T sound. Merely reading in a book about a relaxed tongue with a small amount of travel and where it contacts the reed... it's nothing without hearing it.
I guess I didn't do myself any favors by not including tonging into my daily practice, it is a challenge to say the least, going back to the starting points of several of my books to learn that technique , it's like breaking a bad habit trying to tongue when I can slur the notes , but I want to play music the right way, so ive got to learn, I'm up for the challenge.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,525
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom