Playing the saxophone Plateau, intermediate player

Yes.
With adults you constantly have to work against their thoughts that they can't learn what a child can learn.
And sometimes - as I wrote - they know better than the teacher.
Maybe that's why I didn't click with the instructor, also I think he was used to teaching children and teenagers, and me being almost 60
 
Often my teacher will get me to sight read and play with him, sometimes duets and sometimes we play the same part, it might be well known tune, but it will usually be an arrangement I'm not familiar with. Last week it was from a soul book with backing tracks and we played Sittin' On The Dock Of The Bay (Otis Redding) and Stand By Me (Ben E King). There a good lesson trying to stick to what is written and resisting the urge to play based on memory of popular version!

There's good merritt in getting a good book that has audio tracks with and without the saxophone part. You can play along with the sax version and then switch to backing track only version once you've got a feel.
 
Often my teacher will get me to sight read and play with him, sometimes duets and sometimes we play the same part, it might be well known tune, but it will usually be an arrangement I'm not familiar with. Last week it was from a soul book with backing tracks and we played Sittin' On The Dock Of The Bay (Otis Redding) and Stand By Me (Ben E King). There a good lesson trying to stick to what is written and resisting the urge to play based on memory of popular version!

There's good merritt in getting a good book that has audio tracks with and without the saxophone part. You can play along with the sax version and then switch to backing track only version once you've got a

Sounds like you've got the right teacher, I've never played at the same time with someone else playing, but I look forward to it, I'm certain it will be a great experience for my learning. I do have several of the books you spoke of, trying to get the beat is challenging, not having much experience, learning the 1 has frustrated me, but I keep trying
 
Sounds like you've got the right teacher, I've never played at the same time with someone else playing, but I look forward to it, I'm certain it will be a great experience for my learning. I do have several of the books you spoke of, trying to get the beat is challenging, not having much experience, learning the 1 has frustrated me, but I keep trying

Separate the variables here: reading the rhythm vs fingering/playing the notes. Can you speak or clap the rhythms while listening to the backing tracks and reading the music? This is a complexity that is lost on people that eschew reading music.

Reading rhythm is different that associating pitches with notes. Go back to basics. Clapping or tapping is useful. I suspect that @mizmar has become familiar, if not fluent, in the syllables used in hand drumming.

For intermediate/advancing players in the jazz idiom, I suggest Fred Lipsius’ “Reading Key Jazz Rhythms”.
 
Last edited:
I had the same problem which I posted here. I’m also self taught but over a longer period than you. You might find the thread if you do a search. Here’s what I found to be most helpful: 1. Find a group of amateurs that you can play with, it’s great for rhythm ( and eventually impros or solos) and you will make more friends. 2. Find a teacher who is willing to just listen to your playing and correct your mistakes because at the stage you’re at you know enough theory but your practice is probably letting you down. Find a musician who teaches rather than a music teacher. 3. Imitate. From recordings of your favourite tunes and from live gigs. 4. Experiment. We are often stuck with our own ‘sound’ and find it hard to move from there. Get out of your comfort zone even if it sounds like the last quacks of a duck shoot. You’ll be amazed by how much you’ll discover. Good luck.
 
Go back to basics. Clapping or tapping is useful. I suspect that @mizmar has become familiar, if not fluent, in the syllables used in hand drumming.
100% clapping, etc. & certainly not fluid.
The tak dums of hand drumming are fine; but I've mentioned the value I got out of a thorough takadimi course and work.

But I suspect the fact is, for late starters with poor rhythm, like me, more than any specific exercise is you might have to "work on rhythm for a good long time" ...building bits of brain is slow.
 
Sounds like you've got the right teacher, I've never played at the same time with someone else playing, but I look forward to it, I'm certain it will be a great experience for my learning. I do have several of the books you spoke of, trying to get the beat is challenging, not having much experience, learning the 1 has frustrated me, but I keep trying


I'm very fortunate with my teacher. He's ex-forces and plays clarinet in the RAF Reserve Band. Plus other bands on saxophone. He does have a full time job (not in music) but teaches saxophone and clarinet to grade 8 and is ABRSM (Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music) certified.
 
Separate the variables here: reading the rhythm vs fingering/playing the notes. Can you speak or clap the rhythms while listening to the backing tracks and reading the music? This is a complexity that is lost on people that eschew reading music.

Reading rhythm is different that associating pitches with notes. Go back to basics. Clapping or tapping is useful. I suspect that @mizmar has become familiar, if not fluent, in the syllables used in hand drumming.

For intermediate/advancing players in the jazz idiom, I suggest Fred Lipsius’ “Reading

Definitely having issues with rhythm, I hear once it clicks , it's easy but getting to that point I am having difficulty with. Just found a book "idiots guide to music theory " going to get that and see it it will help me progress. I will check out the book you mentioned as well, can't have enough books!
 
I'm very fortunate with my teacher. He's ex-forces and plays clarinet in the RAF Reserve Band. Plus other bands on saxophone. He does have a full time job (not in music) but teaches saxophone and clarinet to grade 8 and is ABRSM (Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music) certified.
The ex-forces ones can be some of the best teachers, my first teacher which was 45 years ago was ex army band, played woodwinds but he was at his best on the piano taught me for my first 10 years of my journey, studied classical and the start of jazz/improvisation, moved to a dedicated jazz teacher after that, finding the right teacher is so important in one's musical journey.
 
The ex-forces ones can be some of the best teachers, my first teacher which was 45 years ago was ex army band, played woodwinds but he was at his best on the piano taught me for my first 10 years of my journey, studied classical and the start of jazz/improvisation, moved to a dedicated jazz teacher after that, finding the right teacher is so important in one's musical journey.
Wow , you we're lucky to have that type of teacher, I am searching now , I guess the way I learned was not from the beginning, I taught myself the instrument and how to read notes and play them but it's so hard for me to learn the proper way to play a piece of music without that , hopefully I will be able to, it's discouraging to say the least.
 
I had the same problem which I posted here. I’m also self taught but over a longer period than you. You might find the thread if you do a search. Here’s what I found to be most helpful: 1. Find a group of amateurs that you can play with, it’s great for rhythm ( and eventually impros or solos) and you will make more friends. 2. Find a teacher who is willing to just listen to your playing and correct your mistakes because at the stage you’re at you know enough theory but your practice is probably letting you down. Find a musician who teaches rather than a music teacher. 3. Imitate. From recordings of your favourite tunes and from live gigs. 4. Experiment. We are often stuck with our own ‘sound’ and find it hard to move from there. Get out of your comfort zone even if it sounds like the last quacks of a duck shoot. You’ll be amazed by how much you’ll discover. Good luck.
Thank you, great advice! this will be very helpful , the knowledge of players here and the advice is why I joined, I have gotten some really good feedback, it is most helpful to get advice from someone who taught them self like me , I do get discouraged, alot but I keep going, I do recognize hurdles that I have struggled with but was able to surpass , what an awesome feeling!
 
Remember also that this journey has no destination. The journeying itself is the point of the journey.

There's more to know than can be known in a lifetime. The more you learn, the more there is to learn. The more you learn makes it apparent how little you know.

Don't rush. Enjoy where you are. We are all where we are. Enjoy the view. Enjoy the company. Be sidetracked.
Pause. Resume. Share what you have. Be generous and grateful. Be brave and humble.

Most of all...




be in tune.
 
You need to click with your teacher for sure, but the things you’ve described about him makes me thing there is a problem with you as well. Seems like you want to be able to read, but don’t want to really put in the time it takes. That said, some teachers just know one way to present things, and cannot adapt, which is bad if a student has a learning issue. Good advice so far, especially about separating the the rhythms from the notes.

Reading music is like reading words - you see the symbol, in your mind you instantly know it’s a Bb, for a beat and a half. There should be no translation happening, like when you see the word “apple” you don’t have to go into your internal dictionary to figure out what it means - you know it instantly. If reading music isn’t like that for you, then you just need to do it more - until it is 🙂

Regarding ”keeping the beat” and “finding 1”, things that you say you have trouble with, can you keep count listening to a song? Choose a song you know well, maybe one you’d like to perform, and count (1,2,3,4) throughout the song. Can you do that? Can you keep the count (again, 1,2,3,4) for a minute with a metronome? Be the time, be the clock, keep the beat. Without that internal clock ticking along precisely, you have no chance to read music well. Or play it for that matter. Keep working with the metronome.

If the metronome is so dry sounding it drives you crazy, use a drum machine or drum loop. There’s a great app called Drum Genius that has 500 loops, many styles, it’s less than $10. Excellent beats, I use it sometimes when writing - I’m not alone, I learned about it from a composer on YouTube, and Jay Metcalf of Better Sax uses it too.
 
Remember also that this journey has no destination. The journeying itself is the point of the journey.

There's more to know than can be known in a lifetime. The more you learn, the more there is to learn. The more you learn makes it apparent how little you know.

Don't rush. Enjoy where you are. We are all where we are. Enjoy the view. Enjoy the company. Be sidetracked.
Pause. Resume. Share what you have. Be generous and grateful. Be brave and humble.

Most of all...




be in tune.
Very well put ! Great advice and much appreciated, I think of being a kid and wanting to learn it all at once , it takes time, and patience, I am learning that as I go,. The more I talk to experienced players such as you, the better understanding and more knowledge I gain, and you're right , there's more to be learned in a lifetime for one person, to know that is to be humble
 
Remember also that this journey has no destination. The journeying itself is the point of the journey.

There's more to know than can be known in a lifetime. The more you learn, the more there is to learn. The more you learn makes it apparent how little you know.

Don't rush. Enjoy where you are. We are all where we are. Enjoy the view. Enjoy the company. Be sidetracked.
Pause. Resume. Share what you have. Be generous and grateful. Be brave and humble.

Most of all...




be in tune.

Remember also that this journey has no destination. The journeying itself is the point of the journey.

There's more to know than can be known in a lifetime. The more you learn, the more there is to learn. The more you learn makes it apparent how little you know.

Don't rush. Enjoy where you are. We are all where we are. Enjoy the view. Enjoy the company. Be sidetracked.
Pause. Resume. Share what you have. Be generous and grateful. Be brave and humble.

Most of all...




be in tune.
I want to change the title of this thread as I know now I am NOT advanced in my play, I do feel good about my accomplishments but there is so much to learn to get to be an advanced player, I have gotten really good feedback and advice, and I do appreciate it all
 
Reading music is like reading words - you see the symbol, in your mind you instantly know it’s a Bb, for a beat and a half. There should be no translation happening, like when you see the word “apple” you don’t have to go into your internal dictionary to figure out what it means - you know it instantly. If reading music isn’t like that for you, then you just need to do it more - until it is 🙂
Amen.
Regarding ”keeping the beat” and “finding 1”, things that you say you have trouble with, can you keep count listening to a song? Choose a song you know well, maybe one you’d like to perform, and count (1,2,3,4) throughout the song. Can you do that? Can you keep the count (again, 1,2,3,4) for a minute with a metronome? Be the time, be the clock, keep the beat. Without that internal clock ticking along precisely, you have no chance to read music well. Or play it for that matter. Keep working with the metronome.
“Be the time…”. I love this. I played bass drum in high school and college marching bands, and guitar in a Top 40 band - I credit those experiences for reinforcing my sense of time. An interesting aside (interesting to me, at least) is that Jerry Bergonzi plays drums (kit), and plays very well. I’ve seen him break out a cow bell too.

Come to think of it, I have almost always had various hand percussion in my gig bag for Latin or rock gigs: cowbell, afuche, guiro, and shakers.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,526
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom