Playing the saxophone Plateau, intermediate player

Sounds like something like a master class is needed. Some teachers are great with raw beginners and getting a body started. Advancing players with fixed ideas, needs and wants can be beyond their experience.

Go find your local bands and see if you can sit in. You can often learn differently listening to and playing with accomplished players.

Also jam nights are good for meeting like minds.
Oh no , definitely not ready for that, my instructor told me I was ready to play out , with a band or maybe a local orchestra, but I don't believe I am , just yet
 
Great.
For reading music - there's better people than I, here, to recomend texts or other support material... if they don't respond here, nothing wrong with a search or post asking.

For scales... there's something. Playing the basic "major / minor" by memory should be unquestioned. But it doesn't end there; arpegios, other patterns, other scales (C7, deminished, pentatonics, blues etc.) with a vaiety of patterns ... all part of what I refered to as technique that underpins begginer->intermediat playing... and that feeds into reading music; knowing the notes, keys, signs etc. is one level, spotting patterns on the page and having those ready in the fingers is ninja level!

There are other things: playing by ear, decorations, tonging techqies etc.

so, yeah, lots to work on to be a solid intermediate!
 
Last edited:
Great.
For reading music - there's better people than I, here, to recomend texts or other support material... if they don't respond here, nothing wrong with a search or post asking.

For scales... there's something. Playing the basic "major / minor" by memory should be unquestioned. But it doesn't end there; arpegios, other patterns, other scales (C7, deminished, pentatonics, blues etc.) with a vaiety of patterns ... all part of what I refered to as technique that underpins begginer->intermediat playing... and that feeds into reading music; knowing the notes, keys, signs etc. is one level, spotting patterns on the page and having those ready in the fingers is ninja level!

There are other things: playing by ear, decorations, tonging techqies etc.

so, yeah, lots to work on to be a solid intermediate!
I've been working on tonging techniques, my play primarily has been slur so far, I haven't attempted the higher notes as the books I believe only go to high F , don't know why the fingering charts don't go higher. I definitely have many things to work on
 
I've been working on tonging techniques, my play primarily has been slur so far, I haven't attempted the higher notes as the books I believe only go to high F , don't know why the fingering charts don't go higher. I definitely have many things to work on
I appreciate the feedback and advice, I will try and get a more solid focus on learning these things that everyone has mentioned so far. I don’t want to portray myself as being something I'm not, I'm just saying what I've been told about my play, as far as how I view my play I still consider myself a beginner
 
You've mentioned the metronome and not getting on with it and not being comfortable playing with a band. A lot of people who are used to playing on their own, struggle with timing. I have this problem.Playing with other people will help you improve on both timing and confidence. Maybe you can find a rehearsal band, so long as you're not the worst player -second worst is fine 😉
 
There is a jazz school here for adults that have combo classes, and they've posted some material that attempts to give students an idea of what they should be able to do at different levels.



I don't think people should be too prescriptive with this kind of thing but I think it's helpful.
 
You've mentioned the metronome and not getting on with it and not being comfortable playing with a band. A lot of people who are used to playing on their own, struggle with timing. I have this problem.Playing with other people will help you improve on both timing and confidence. Maybe you can find a rehearsal band, so long as you're not the worst player -second worst is fine 😉
Somebody has to be the worst 😀 yes I was not friends with the MN, I know it's an important tool tho , still a work in progress
 
There is a jazz school here for adults that have combo classes, and they've posted some material that attempts to give students an idea of what they should be able to do at different levels.



I don't think people should be too prescriptive with this kind of thing but I think it's helpful.
That sounds like something I need , thank you! I will check it out
 
60 years in and I still don't read much. Only when I have to. I've never owned or used a metronome but have no bother playing to drum machine.

It's very pleasing to be the arbiter when the bass, drums and banjo are having a discussion about tempo. 😉
 
Regarding reading, IMO there is only one way to learn it, and that is by doing it. Opportunities are hard to find these days, but maybe something like a local brass band / community band kind of thing. You live in Maryland, check community colleges. I don’t know what kind of music you are trying to play, but there is probably a big band or “concert band” that you can take part in.

Regarding scales, do 10-20. inutes a day, every day, on one key for a week. In 3 months you’ll have them down. Full range.
 
, he did get me to start using the metronome, I had attempted to use it before but I just wasn't getting it
Maybe you have your own thoughts of what to practice, and it's not the teacher's fault?
In my experience that's sometimes a problem with adults and especially players self-taught by books and youtube.
My teacher (currently Greg Fishman) calls that the "rabbithole of misinformation".
When you have a teacher and he tells you something and you talk about 5 youtube videos where a guy (often having the experience of about 3 lessons more than you) tells you the opposite.

14 months?
Students of mine would (if they are hard-working like you) not only play songs, they would play etudes (with a dose of classical etudes to improve sound control), maybe jazz etudes and technical exercises (much of that by ear).

So I don't fully understand the problem of not finding books.

Greetings, Guenne
 
I second the teacher idea. I 'could' play when I started with mine, learning at school.

Sure you could tell what tune I was playing, but my teacher has tightened up my timing, and rhythm... Still some way to go.

For my sight reading, I play with local amateur orchestra, and we play a broad spectrum of music, it also helps with timing too.

With my teacher we're working through a book of duets, which really highlights my poor timing and rhythm, we're also touching on improvisation.

Sometimes I'm bombarded with stuff, then weeks, or months later we touch on it again and something twiggs.

The transition from 'beginner' to 'intermediate' was like opening Pandora's box (especially with improvisation), even my teacher said "now you know what all buttons do, now you start learn how to play it"
 
@Sax Addict

What is your goal with playing the saxophone? To read and play? To be able to join a band/orchestra? ....... .

I'm 68 and I'm struggling to play in the same way as I did for a couple of years ago. I decided to play more baritone than tenor. And to give up reading music as well. So farewell to spend time on playing from sheet music. Ok, I play some easy stuff so I can always pretend to read ..... . But no more extra rehearsals to get the horn section tight .... . I discovered that bari is more the "adult sax voice". I still like and listen to lots of tenor heroes .... I realized that time is tighter these days. So should I spend time on useful exercises or just play and have fun? Don't be afraid to ask yourself questions.

To teach a 16 years old girl/boy or to teach 60 years old woman/man is IMO a big difference. More to consider when it comes to adult teaching.
 
To teach a 16 years old girl/boy or to teach 60 years old woman/man is IMO a big difference. More to consider when it comes to adult teaching.
Yes.
With adults you constantly have to work against their thoughts that they can't learn what a child can learn.
And sometimes - as I wrote - they know better than the teacher.
 
Sure you could tell what tune I was playing, but my teacher has tightened up my timing, and rhythm
This is one of the plus points for having a teacher, playing what's on the the music sheet instead of playing how our head thinks it should go.
If you are playing in a big band then what's on the music sheet matters, not so much in other formats.
 
Last edited:
@Sax Addict

What is your goal with playing the saxophone? To read and play? To be able to join a band/orchestra? ....... .

I'm 68 and I'm struggling to play in the same way as I did for a couple of years ago. I decided to play more baritone than tenor. And to give up reading music as well. So farewell to spend time on playing from sheet music. Ok, I play some easy stuff so I can always pretend to read ..... . But no more extra rehearsals to get the horn section tight .... . I discovered that bari is more the "adult sax voice". I still like and listen to lots of tenor heroes .... I realized that time is tighter these days. So should I spend time on useful exercises or just play and have fun? Don't be afraid to ask yourself questions.

To teach a 16 years old girl/boy or to teach 60 years old woman/man is IMO a big difference. More to consider when it comes to adult teaching.
My goal is to play with a band, not anything serious, maybe just local pubs , I've gotten great advice so far and am trying to put that towards my everyday practice, definitely need to learn sheet music better, not a problem reading notes, that came pretty easily, I need to learn how to play exactly as it says,
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,526
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom