Playing the saxophone Plateau, intermediate player

I guess I didn't do myself any favors by not including tonging into my daily practice, it is a challenge to say the least, going back to the starting points of several of my books to learn that technique , it's like breaking a bad habit trying to tongue when I can slur the notes , but I want to play music the right way, so ive got to learn, I'm up for the challenge.
In my opinion, a great legato tongue makes one of the biggest differences to a player’s development.
Don’t copy the tongue action, but the sound of “Laa” when singing is amazingly smooth - yet still articulated.
 
In my opinion, a great legato tongue makes one of the biggest differences to a player’s development.
Don’t copy the tongue action, but the sound of “Laa” when singing
is amazingly smooth - yet

Thank you, I will try that, trying to work it into the music when I'm playing, if it calls for it. Going back over my music books trying to learn things that I should have, having fun doing it tho.
 
There is no wrong or right way. Just different ways of doing things.
Starting out we learn how to do things, then we learn how not to do them.
Beginners strive not to squeak. When they've mastered that, they find it's called altissimo and have to learn to do it again, on demand.
It's gonna be a long time before I even attempt altissimo , I know my neighbors will be happy about that. For me it's learning and going back and learning, cause I didn't go about it the right way
 
Thank you, I will try that, trying to work it into the music when I'm playing, if it calls for it. Going back over my music books trying to learn things that I should have, having fun doing it tho.

I consider legato as how to tongue every note that is not otherwise annotated. How else do you start a series of notes that are all the same pitch?
 
In my opinion, a great legato tongue makes one of the biggest differences to a player’s development.
Don’t copy the tongue action, but the sound of “Laa” when singing is amazingly smooth - yet still articulated.
I've really gotten alot of advice and I'm thrilled about trying every single thing, especially learning how to tongue notes and navigate through a piece of music properly, it's tough going learning by myself especially with a tbi
 
I consider legato as how to tongue every note that is not otherwise annotated. How else do you start a series of notes that are all the same pitch?

I'm going to guess and say tongue the first one then slur from there

That doesn’t work for notes that are the same pitch. If you choose not to tongue four quarter notes, you just played a whole note.

P.S. I have personal experience with friends and family whom have experienced various brain injuries. Respect and compassion to you. I urge you all the more to seek out direction and support for learning the fundamentals of music.
 
That doesn’t work for notes that are the same pitch. If you choose not to tongue four quarter notes, you just played a whole note.

P.S. I have personal experience with friends and family whom have experienced various brain injuries. Respect and compassion to you. I urge you all the more to seek out direction and support for learning the fundamentals of music
That makes so much sense and I kind of wondered about that when I'd play 4 quarter notes that it just sounded like 1 note. I'm learning so much here just in conversation, I'm really glad I became a member of the Cafe Saxophone! And thank you for your understanding of tbi's, the funny thing about them especially in my case I have a closed head injury that people can't see , people don't understand in that case.
I think what I need is a " music teacher " ,I can find an instructor after I am taught to read music properly
 
I think what I need is a " music teacher " ,I can find an instructor after I am taught to read music properly
so, here's a thought.
I'm self taught on sax for whatever reason. But on (reed) flute, after a year or so getting into it, I got a teacher. Then, although I could read the music and play some tunes (some from the teachers YouTube, loss leader channel) I agreed to start from lesson zero; each note, each "scale", each little exercise and tune committed to memory. We sailed along quite briskly, so my prior work paid off. I'm glad I did because it set a solid baseline.
To be blunt. From your posts here, it seems to me, you are not solidly through the beginner stage. I'd suggest you think, resources allowing, of getting a teacher and asking no more than to work through the basics. It probably won't take long.
 
so, here's a thought.
I'm self taught on sax for whatever reason. But on (reed) flute, after a year or so getting into it, I got a teacher. Then, although I could read the music and play some tunes (some from the teachers YouTube, loss leader channel) I agreed to start from lesson zero; each note, each "scale", each little exercise and tune committed to memory. We sailed along quite briskly, so my prior work paid off. I'm glad I did because it set a solid baseline.
To be blunt. From your posts here, it seems to me, you are not solidly through the beginner stage. I'd suggest you think, resources allowing, of getting a teacher and asking no more than to work through the basics. It probably won't take long.
It is rewarding being self taught, however being taught from step 1 is much more of an advantage, I think. I may have developed some bad habits that will be tough to overcome, like tonging and reading and playing music the way it is intended to be played, I have put alot of the advice that I have gotten from this forum to work already and am feeling a new energy from it as well, but it's a marathon, I have to rid myself from the sprinter mentality
 
As rewarding as claiming to be self taught may be, good players benefit from community. I have learned so much over the years just showing up early or staying late after gigs and talking to bandmates.

As a wind player, if you never develop the fundamentals, it is especially hard to take it to the next level. I cannot imagine trying to be self taught to read music either - imagine a child being handed books with no pictures and no clues about sounds associated with letters.
 
The issue isn't whether being self taught is, in general, good or bad; it is, I believe, for adults who vary widely, a personal thing... And each individual should decide the next step for themselves; possibly in conversation or consultation; with respect to personal experience, temperament, objectives etc.
The issue, seems to me, is whether Sax Addict is approaching the teacher well - for themselves, with their personal history etc. Hence my suggestion.
 
Last edited:
t is rewarding being self taught, however being taught from step 1 is much more of an advantage, I think. I may have developed some bad habits that will be tough to overcome
Well, I don't know. I'm proud that I taught myself to play Rock & Roll Sax. I'm not a good player and I'll never be qualified enough to get paid. But on the other side, that was never my goal. My sax life is different to my friends sax life. I'm still honored when the former leader of our old punk band ask if we can play again for an evening. I played bari in a punk band back in the late 70's. Or to play sax with a guy that have SRV closed to his heart, or a pubrock band, or a bluesband .... . I never missed the Big Band I tried to be a partof. And they were probably glad the day I didn't show up on the rehearsals. But I missed the guys in the band. Now it haven't a complete solo journey. For 30-35 years ago I started to ask Rock & Roll Sax - Blues- players for some help and they gladly helped. To be a nerd helps up. I have spent many hours in the car to be able to be able to go to a club gig in Odense, Gothenburg, Stockholm, Amsterdam ... to say "Hi" and listen.
 
Based on some of the things that you've said in this thread @Sax Addict

I have found a series of books very helpful. They are aimed at adults so not nursery rimes and they have backing tracks played by a real band rather than some terrible midi tracks that a lot of books have.

They start from the beginning but cover a lot of the things you've mentioned progressing to some genuinely intermediate level pieces. Only available for Alto saxophone though: The Saxophone Method by John O'Neill

 
As rewarding as claiming to be self taught may be, good players benefit from community. I have learned so much over the years just showing up early or staying late after gigs and talking to bandmates.

As a wind player, if you never develop the fundamentals, it is especially hard to take it to the next level. I cannot imagine trying to be self taught to read music either - imagine a child being handed books with no pictures and no clues about sounds associated with letters.
I totally agree, I am learning how important that is , I never realized how important it is until I started reading advice and suggestions from other players, having learned in a so called bubble , it has already affected my practice/learning
 
So here's another thing, last night I had another lesson, and we continued with Chords, Chord tones, an improvising over them - I do struggle with it, and it takes some time for the penny to drop. I stand in awe as he belts out phrases making it look easy.

After doing a bit, we tried something else, and I couldn't get head around it, so we went even slower, and then he's accompanying me on piano, hovering over the chords waiting for me to change, and something almost magical happened. I was (in a very simple form) making music, and I got excited about this new found knowledge, it was fun... I can away full of excitement - although we had visitors when I got home so have to wait until tonight to try again.

I showed him the open solo I'd been nominated for - "Ahhh just play triad pairs over that." followed by some amazing sounding demonstrations - and now something more to add to my practice routines.

I'm 99% confident that if I didn't have a teacher I'd have got bored, or not progressed as far as I have, and doing the above keeps pushing me, it keeps me accountable.
 
Based on some of the things that you've said in this thread @Sax Addict

I have found a series of books very helpful. They are aimed at adults so not nursery rimes and they have backing tracks played by a real band rather than some terrible midi tracks that a lot of books have.

They start from the beginning but cover a lot of the things you've mentioned progressing to some genuinely intermediate level pieces. Only available for Alto saxophone though: The Saxophone Method by John O'Neill

Thank you , I will check them out ! Question for you, how come when I play a piece for "alto" on my tenor it doesn't sound great? Probably a stupid question but I am a beginner.
 
Well, I don't know. I'm proud that I taught myself to play Rock & Roll Sax. I'm not a good player and I'll never be qualified enough to get paid. But on the other side, that was never my goal. My sax life is different to my friends sax life. I'm still honored when the former leader of our old punk band ask if we can play again for an evening. I played bari in a punk band back in the late 70's. Or to play sax with a guy that have SRV closed to his heart, or a pubrock band, or a bluesband .... . I never missed the Big Band I tried to be a partof. And they were probably glad the day I didn't show up on the rehearsals. But I missed the guys in the band. Now it haven't a complete solo journey. For 30-35 years ago I started to ask Rock & Roll Sax - Blues- players for some help and they gladly helped. To be a nerd helps up. I have spent many hours in the car to be able to be able to go to a club gig in Odense, Gothenburg, Stockholm, Amsterdam ... to say "Hi" and listen.
Awesome story! I kind of think that may be the case for me , but I'm OK with that, but I am still going to try and accomplish the goal I have set for myself . You sound humble and are probably a better player than you think you are . This community has helped me already with my learning and I've only been a member for a very short time. Several members here have said how important this community is to learning and developing skills, they are absolutely right and am very appreciative of everyone's feedback.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom