Accessories Pad Savers... Good or bad?

I did use a pad saver but my teacher advised me to let the sax dry in the open air on a stand. Also my sax has a octave vent on the side that protrudes as a small tube into the body, do all saxophones have this and would a padsaver damage this as it is a tight fit.
 
daveq wrote:
Also my sax has a octave vent on the side that protrudes as a small tube into the body, do all saxophones have this and would a padsaver damage this as it is a tight fit.

My Yamaha student tenor has the same thing. On that it seems fairly substantial as it's managed to rip a cloth pull-through to shreds! (Yes, I was trying to be careful, but when the thing will move neither up nor down...!)

I now have a BG shammy pull-through which doesn't jam at all and seems to dry the insides well.
 
I believe sax authority Steve Goodson says if you don't use a pad-saver you need your head examining. Or maybe he says if you do use a pad-saver, I can't quite remember.

Anyway, my YAS-62 has one of those octave vent protuberances inside the body tube (I wonder if the turbulence set up by it has any effect on the sound?) but it hasn't torn my pull-through yet. I don't useb a pad-saver, just use the pull-through 3 or 4 times after playing.

Maybe a pad-saver is just another of those 'must-haves' that you don't really need...?
 
IMHO pad saver= bad
1 they always end up stinking
2 they dont actually touch 90% of the pads
3 they stop air circulation
4 they look stupid
5 did i mention they stink, if you play with a few sax players, say in a big band , you can always smell one who uses a pad saver..

use a pull through to mop up the stuff inside the horn then leave your case open over night after a gig..
 
I've heard from my sax teacher and seen on a "how to pack a sax for travel" page that the bung is to prevent damage to the "top end" (dunno the technical term!). Apparently, it's fairly common for a knock to stop the neck from fitting, and it's easier (and better) to prevent this kind of damage than to fix it.

Hearsay. YMMV.
 
I don't know about preventing damage from a knock serious enough to distort the "top end" so the neck doesn't fit - most bungs these days are made from plastic and would give way before stopping any damage there. However I think they do prevent damage to the top of the octave mechanism which pokes up, and might bend if allowed to rest on the case - the bug is what is supposed to rest on the case.

This doesn't actually happen in a lot of mould cases and gig bags, I always used to wrap some think towelling around the top end as well as a bung or padsaver in a loose fitting moulded (or molded) case.

I don't think padsavers do much to save pads, I tend to use them when travelling though, basically as an oversized bung.

It's like a lot of accessories, there's arguments both ways as to whether they do any good (Pad clamps I'm thinking of).
 
I'm happy to bow to your experience, Pete.

My source (other than my teacher) is here - http://www.cybersax.com/packsax.html (and on re-reading seems to bear out what you say as well!)

"The No. 1 cause of damage to saxes in shipment is failure to place the neck plug into the sax body neck opening.

The neck plug both protects the neck cavity & octave mechanism from damage, and assures the sax fits snugly into the case. When the sax is not snug within its case the body flows back & forth in pile-driver fashion as a result of shipment motions. The results are quite predictable: bent octave mechanisms, warped neck sockets. broken neck screws, bow dents, damaged cases, and in extremes, bends in the sax body itself. Since failure to install the neck plug is improper packing, none of this damage would be insurable.

Sax manufacturers supply neck plugs in the same finish as the sax. In case the original plug is lost, inexpensive replacement plugs made of plastic are sold in most music stores & instrument repair shops."



I'm in the habit of doing it now and, as it probably won't cause harm, I'll probably carry on.
 
I didn't think of that (pressure from the top, I wa thinking more from the side so a very good point.

If the damage would occur from motion down onto the top of the bung then yes it could prevent damage to the body as well as octave mechanism.
 
I thought the pad savers (HW anyway) had a desiccant effect, there by taking the moisture from the pad, the air or wherever. So they should work touching or not. Although they would need a recharge/blow dry every now and again. (probably more regularly than than is practical)

I keep a few small bags of silica gel in my case to try and help but again how much it works is anybodys guess, but it feels better trying than not.

Col.
 
I use a pull-through a few times then oscillate (most polite way I could describe the to-ing and fro-ing action I actually use) the pad saver a few times in the barrel to clean the bits the pull-through may have missed. I leave the pad-saver in the sax (a tenor) to protect the octave mechanism from damage. Get a good quaility pad-saver and use BG pull-throughs and I believe you can't go wrong.

Cheers

Moz
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,310
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom