Regarding metal vs rubber, most of my tenor heroes, specially tone wise, played and still do on metal pieces.
Do Eddie Lockjaw Davis, Johnny Griffin, Benny Golson or Eric Alexander mean anything ?
Many of those I appreciate who play on rubber pieces are playing great. But I miss something in their tone and articulation. As if the highest partials were muffled.
Stan Getz, Zoot, Bob Mintzer or Joshua Redman ? Are they legitimate ?
Except Mr. Golson, I’ve seen and heard all of them live in small venues, unpostprocessed.
I’m sure physics, Nobel prize holders and top notch labs are better than my old pair of ears.
But this is the world I capture with them, I don’t have any better.