Mouthpieces Material does matter..

I think I probably do. We do tend to care what something sounds like recorded so sure that is caring about what the audience think? But maybe that's a different thing.

That I find that very true and is part of what makes all of this stuff so difficult. A good player may respond to small differences in sound. Say for example you have a mouthpiece you are very comfortable with. You like the sound it makes as you play it, you like the sound it makes when you listen back to a recording.

Suppose someone then alters it to be a bit brighter. You may either think "I like that brightness," or else you might think you don't like it, in which case you will adapt your embouchure (either consciously or unconsciously) to make it sound like you did before. (ie equalisation)
By altering the way you play I’m talking about musical choices. If you think your tone is more beautiful with a certain setup you might find that you play less notes and in particular, more long notes. More sound stuff.

By not caring what the audience thinks, I mean that I’m confident that for a long time the audience won’t have thought that my sound is bad, and to the best of my ability I respect the music and try and play what is appropriate to the music I’m playing. If they prefer Sanborn or Brecker (and they should!!), then I can’t do anything about that.

Likely too that they won’t hear the nuances that I or another experienced musician/listener hear.

So, I care little about their feelings on my sound, just as I care little about such comments as “you’re the best Sax player I’ve ever heard” - meant as a compliment but actually v annoying (ie shall I give you a list to broaden your horizons?).
 
I think that this different sound for changed setups has a sliding scale dependent upon what sort of sound you play with.

A sound rich in overtones is going to alter more compared to say, a West Coast sound with a lot of overtones purposefully suppressed.
 
I think that this different sound for changed setups has a sliding scale dependent upon what sort of sound you play with.

A sound rich in overtones is going to alter more compared to say, a West Coast sound with a lot of overtones purposefully suppressed.
That's interesting and definitely true of sound recording eq where you can do more radical changes to a sound with more overtones. ie it's easy to remove overtones but difficult to boost what isn't there.

But supposing you could instantly change mouthpiece characteristics perhaps with temporary installable baffles (as with my Joe Walton mouthpiece) or else adding a baffle with chewing gum or some other hi-tech material.

Theoretically you could make that West Coast few overtone sound have a lot more overtones quite easily but if a mouthpiece has a high baffle already you'd need to lower it to decrease its effect.

And getting back to the original topic if higher density material does affect the sound you couldn't instantly increase the density. You'd need to compare two identical mouthpieces with (as near as possible) identical material except for the density on one of them.
 
This is just a test - video is not in sync sometimes and so is my playing. Just out of curiosity - what's metal and what's hardrubber?

3 short sequences, played 4 times with 4 different MPCs.

Here's the order, recorded dry and all played with my Yanagisawa TWO20U and a Boston Saxshop Heritage neck:

Phil-Tone Intrepid 7*, Rigotti Wild 3 -Hardrubber
Morgan Excalibur Indiana 8*, Rigotti Wild 3 - Hardrubber
Gottsu Doublering 7*, Rigotti Jazz 3light - Metal
Ben Allen 20TD, refaced to 7*, Rigotti Wild 3 - Hardrubber

View: https://youtu.be/xAo-UgczXRA
I don’t think the point is discerning rubber vs metal, unless they’re the same ‘piece in different material. From the list, the two Rigotti’s are the only same make. Are they a similar concept?

To be more scientific you need to play a “control phrase/s”. It needs to be exactly the same thing every time. Otherwise if you push more or less air through, the same ‘piece will sound different
 
I don’t think the point is discerning rubber vs metal, unless they’re the same ‘piece in different material. From the list, the two Rigotti’s are the only same make. Are they a similar concept?
The only thing that matters for me is if there is a difference in output - as playing hardrubber vs metal FEELS totally different to me.
The answer for me is yes - but for somebody in the audience it's like playing Yamaha, Selmer or Conn.
It does not matter at all - most of the time. If it sounds good to them, it has to be Selmer.
 
The only thing that matters for me is if there is a difference in output - as playing hardrubber vs metal FEELS totally different to me.
Yes they feel v different for me too. Rubber is always more comfortable for me and has a “coming home” vibe due to me being a clarinet player originally.

With the output thing: if you’re saying that you’re being pushed into playing the ‘piece differently I get that, they do, but it doesn’t help the test.
 
@Pete Effamy
What I wanted to say is that if you give me the chance to hear a player in some styles, different dynamics etc., I think I can tell if he/she plays a metal or hardrubber MPC, no matter which "concept" the piece follows.
But I can be wrong, and please don't ask me how I think I could do that 🙂
 
@Pete Effamy
What I wanted to say is that if you give me the chance to hear a player in some styles, different dynamics etc., I think I can tell if he/she plays a metal or hardrubber MPC, no matter which "concept" the piece follows.
But I can be wrong, and please don't ask me how I think I could do that 🙂
I’d be surprised if you can - tak a player who puts a hard reed on a Dukoff D8 and gets a relatively fluffy sound or someone who puts a soft reed on a Meyer 5 and blows the keys off
 
That's very interesting. When you say "I know what I feel and hear" is that "hear" as the player in action, or do the differences come across in recordings as well ?

Rhys
It's entirely subjective from the playing point of view.
Concerning recordings, every mouthpiece and every reed sound fractionally different, and proximity to the microphone is a huge factor, so it's extremely difficult to judge.
 
But I wonder is there any current science which investigates the kind of detail mentioned here? ie how the sound changes across the dynamic spectrum, whether there are vibrations at just one small part of the mouthpiece. Everything I have seen people write is either based on what Adolphe Sax or Benade thought (not exactly modern sciences) or based on something they read but did not cite - mainly hearsay.

That is quite a point.
Academic science is a slow and expensive process, while production has more to do with engineering and has to balance customers' perception and production costs.

In recent years I have been testing different materials in saxophone making, that is a scientific nightmare, since many variables simply cannot be made equal.
The best that a maker can do is to do few specimens and ask few testers to try them. In an ideal research that would imply tens of specimens, hundreds of testers, and some statistic tools (measuring "articulation" or "projection" is also a can of worms)

We are still down to "how does it feel making music with this"?
If most testers preferred materials A and D, and D is easier to produce, D will be. Very little science involved.

Pillinger's doctorate (available online) is an exception in which great minds could approach scientifically an engineering issue, but the most interesting thing is still Pillinger's production after that research

Sometimes the market will punish a wrong marketing choice, like in Absolute's excellent acrylic mouthpieces, now out of production
 
So I downloaded this and read it (I must admit, I let my eyes glaze over from time to time…) The biggest surprise for me was this - the shape of the oral cavity has no effect on the tone or sound.

I was trained to visualize certain vowel shapes to accommodate different registers, to help focus of the tone, to help bring out overtones, etc. etc. etc. There are a gazillion videos and papers online talking about tongue position, forward coning, throat position, etc. Teachers talk about this stuff all the time.

But the conclusions in this paper clearly state that it’s only the pressure and position of the lower lip that matters. Making a “O” shape or an “E” shape (or whatever) in the mouth is only effective to the extent that doing so makes changes in the pressure and position of the lower lip.

I wish he had gone farther with this research, though I understand it was not the focus of this project. Maybe adjusting the artificial embouchure so that the direction of the air stream could be more closely controlled. Or putting a flexible tube around the mouthpiece so that a resonant cavity could be created that more closely mimics the mouth interior. Then testing for timbral change as he did with the mouthpiece dimensions.

This was absolutely fascinating reading, and it challenged my understaning of the way woodwind instruments operate in many ways. I’ll probably go over several of the sections in more detail over the coming months. Thanks @aldevis for posting this link, and huge thanks to Dr. Pillinger for this research.
 
Clear as mud! Sometimes I (slightly) preferred one, sometimes the other. Quite a few years ago I remember reading the diametrically opposed views of mouthpiece makers Phil Barone and Ralph Morgan on this subject. I remain confused.
 
I’m convinced of it, always have been. But the interesting thing for me is the amount of “frying” going on with the rubber as opposed to the clean, dry plastic. Usually heard more on metal ‘pieces (?)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom