Mouthpieces Material does matter..

I dont know but to me, as a player there are differences between how metal pieces sound compared to hard rubber, dont you think?

No I haven't been able to detect a difference. I believe it's possible that material can make a slight difference at the very tip of mouthpiece that have thin material and no baffle but no overall genetic difference I can say about metal vs HR vs Resin/plastic

@Pete Thomas - didn't you and Morgan Fry do some experiments with a PPT tenor mouthpiece design made by CNC in different materials ?

No I did some comparisons, but Morgan wasn't involved in experiments, apart from making the mouthpieces.
So yes I did some comparisons between the HR and brass PPT using the same phrase each time.

See here for my own comparisons and a more useful tweet as it is single blind. (Not double blind as it could be argued I could tell which one I was playing even though I couldn't) but blind in that the listener doesn't know.


What were the conclusions ?

You can listen and decide for yourself.

All that said, there was a very lengthy thread on the other forum about this topic,
There have been a few on Sax On The Web , but one of them was about my experiment.
 
Give me 10 of the same mpc, in either metal or HR and there will be differences, nothing to do with material.
Ofcourse but I talk about characteristics. This topic is hard to discuss for me as English is not my primary language and describing tone with words is hard.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I dont know but to me, as a player there are differences between how metal pieces sound compared to hard rubber, dont you think?

Not really, but I definitely hear differences between mouthpieces of different (external) beak geometries. I prefer a bigger / steeper beak that makes the player open up their mouth and metal pieces frequently are designed with a narrower profile.

Rhys
 
The problem you will have is, it has never ever been proven that material matters, you might feel there is but another player won't get it, we all play our way and the player is the biggest difference to sound and feel, which is why when someone buys the setup of their hero they quickly realise that they sound nothing like the player they are trying to emulate.
Buy whatever suits and run with it.
 
The problem you will have is, it has never ever been proven that material matters, you might feel there is but another player won't get it, we all play our way and the player is the biggest difference to sound and feel, which is why when someone buys the setup of their hero they quickly realise that they sound nothing like the player they are trying to emulate.
Buy whatever suits and run with it.
I agree that the player has the largest impact on the sound, the "signature" sound is individual and there are as many signature sounds out there as there are saxophone players. Thats what makes the saxophone such a flexible and expressive instrument. Many years ago i bought a new Otto Link STM 7* NY tenor sax model cause I tought that John Coltrane played on that...oh was I wrong..the different models of Otto Links he played did not have much in common with the current run of STM's and also, Mr.C played smaller tip openings. I sticked with the piece for 10years, too long (it was a dud) but I learned how to get the most out of it and develop my airstream which had not been the case if I played high baffle pices.
 
Can you make just two different recordings, one with ebonite and one with metal?
No, the test is already recorded and I'm not able to play at the moment.

it is much better to have several it is a test that can eliminate some of the inevitable variables.
 
For many years ago I was playing Dukoff D7 silverite metal. I also got a Dukoff D7 Vibra-com ebolite composition (plastic) along with a sax I bought in USA. Both mouthpieces were identical; chamber, tip and bore. I could hear and feel (of course) a difference. The silverite mpc had a more piercing sound/tone.
 
See here for my own comparisons and a more useful tweet as it is single blind. (Not double blind as it could be argued I could tell which one I was playing even though I couldn't) but blind in that the listener doesn't know.


You can listen and decide for yourself.

Very interesting test. Listening carefully on good equipment I can barely hear any differences between all the clips - certainly nothing that might not just be the inconsistencies of articulation or air support on different takes using the identical set up.

The only things I wrote down were:
  • Mouthpiece 6: Edgier - possibly slightly more aggressive playing ?
  • Mystery Mouthpiece: Fluffier
Rhys
 
Regarding metal vs rubber, most of my tenor heroes, specially tone wise, played and still do on metal pieces.
Do Eddie Lockjaw Davis, Johnny Griffin, Benny Golson or Eric Alexander mean anything ?
Many of those I appreciate who play on rubber pieces are playing great. But I miss something in their tone and articulation. As if the highest partials were muffled.
Stan Getz, Zoot, Bob Mintzer or Joshua Redman ? Are they legitimate ?
Except Mr. Golson, I’ve seen and heard all of them live in small venues, unpostprocessed.
I’m sure physics, Nobel prize holders and top notch labs are better than my old pair of ears.
But this is the world I capture with them, I don’t have any better.

Speaking of scales or arpeggios instead of « jazz licks » to tell mouthpieces apart, are we sure ? Isn’t a big part of the sound signature we capture given by how the setup reacts to changes more than how it sounds on steady notes ? Specially the upper partials ?
 
Last edited:
Regarding metal vs rubber, most of my tenor heroes, specially tone wise, played and still do on metal pieces.
Do Eddie Lockjaw Davis, Johnny Griffin, Benny Golson or Eric Alexander mean anything ?
Many of those I appreciate who play on rubber pieces are playing great. But I miss something in their tone and articulation. As if the highest partials were muffled.
Stan Getz, Zoot, Bob Mintzer or Joshua Redman ? Are they legitimate ?
Except Mr. Golson, I’ve seen and heard all of them live in small venues, unpostprocessed.
I’m sure physics, Nobel prize holders and top notch labs are better than my old pair of ears.
But this is the world I capture with them, I don’t have any better.

I love those tenor players with their big sounds and personal styles.

Back in the 30s, 40s and 50s when most of the tenor giants started to play, there was little choice in terms of "professional" equipment. That had advantages as well as disadvantages, in that they didn't have to obsess about gear (well not the saxophone sort) and could just work on their own personal sound and style.

They were no doubt influenced by their tenor saxophone forebears and their peers, so the fact that Hawkins and Webster played on metal Links would have made it a likely choice for the players who idolised them.

And were the ebonite pieces of the time exactly the same design in terms of baffle, chamber etc ?

Rhys
 
Given that the size difference between mouthpieces of the same make can be a couple of thousandths of an inch and a gentle, light dressing, by hand over a sheet of 3000 grit paper can fine tune piece, from good to excellent, or visa versa, I think the weather has more effect on sound than material.

By how much do internal and external dimensions change from a hot to a cold day in different materials?

A serious blind test would need a larger sample size. If it was possible to pick six of one material from a mixed dozen then I might be influenced to change my mind.

Given any two mouthpieces one will appeal more than the other, and given time both can be made to sound indistinguishable. imo.
 
The fact that this is still a topic of discussion which has not been resolved would suggest that if there are are differences in tone solely due to the material of which the mouthpiece is constructed such differences are not sufficient to be significant. Yes, I can hear some subtle differences in some of the comparisons, but no person plays anything exactly the same twice, as Heraclitus noted many years ago.
 
Regarding metal vs rubber, most of my tenor heroes, specially tone wise, played and still do on metal pieces.
Do Eddie Lockjaw Davis, Johnny Griffin, Benny Golson or Eric Alexander mean anything ?
Many of those I appreciate who play on rubber pieces are playing great. But I miss something in their tone and articulation. As if the highest partials were muffled.

Otto Link HR vs metal have different baffle contours. They were never intended to be the same piece in different materials.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom