Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

He got through the army band audition by faking playing while listening to the other trumpet players playing the first time though, the second time through he played the tune. He was later thrown out of the band by a newly appointed and more officious senior officer who thought (quite rightly) that the band members were a lot of druggy slackers. He was required to sight read a test piece, and couldn't do it.

According to Chet no doubt. Listen to the man who taught him that I linked to above.

He was known for employing novel chord voicings.

By whom? 3 note shells in the left hand and octaves, block chords and single notes in the right for the most part. What he was really known for was a rock steady 4 in a bar in the left hand and a rubato right hand. A novel approach, but not new voicings like Thelonious Monk, Bill Evans, McCoy Tyner or Herbie Hancock.

Not according to musicians he played with.

According to Gerry Mulligan. I think he played with Gerry once or twice.

...I don't think you necessarily have to be specially talented to play by ear...

No, neither do I but you're going to have to be bloody good to survive in a world of readers without being able to read yourself. Same for those who don't play by ear. Nobody's going to put up with them for long either, at least in the context of jazz.
 
Dibbs said:
...neither do I but you're going to have to be bloody good to survive in a world of readers without being able to read yourself.

Survive? We're not in bloody Texas!
 
I don't understand why you would not read music if you can.

Because I don't need to. I play music I know, I don't see any point in playing music I don't know.

Sax isn't the first instrument I've played. I took Grade 1 piano as a small child, since then I'm self-taught, on various instruments. When I picked up the sax I just played it, I have never learned the names of the notes on the sax.
 
What an odd statement,every piece of music is a piece we don't know until we play it or hear it.

Er, yes, so I don't generally play pieces I haven't heard before, unless they are simple and predictable enough for me to learn them "on the fly". So last week somebody called a tune, and I said "I don't think I know it", the leader said "it's a blues, with a bridge, you'll be ok", and I was able to wing it.
 
Er, yes, so I don't generally play pieces I haven't heard before, unless they are simple and predictable enough for me to learn them "on the fly". So last week somebody called a tune, and I said "I don't think I know it", the leader said "it's a blues, with a bridge, you'll be ok", and I was able to wing it.
Most blues tunes have a head or melody,unless it was a blues without a melody and you made it up,so how could you wing it if you haven't heard it?
 
There were other people playing, so I just followed them. I didn't get it all right, but my wrong notes were in the right key and at the right moment, so it was ok. I guessed what the bridge would be like, and guessed right. We got through the head like that, I could solo without difficulty, and when we played the head at the end I got it right, more or less. That's what the people I was playing with said anyway.
 
It's always a tactical error to say that in a discussion JBT.

Not if you're "old and opinionated" as clearly stated! 😎

But since it is "Not to be taken seriously", it doesn't matter, does it? 😉

So, if I understand the essence of the discussion here. It's good to be able to read music AND it's also good to be able to play by ear!

As I'm not good at either of them yet, so I'll keep working on both.

Thanks for the tips!

:thumbs:
 
So, if I understand the essence of the discussion here. It's good to be able to read music AND it's also good to be able to play by ear!

No, the point I am making, which few people here seem able to grasp, is that it is essential to be able to play by ear (to play jazz) and it is not essential to read music. The emphasis should therefore be on ear playing, but as exemplified by the poor sod who posted the initial query, it is in many cases pretty much ignored.

I think one reason is that teachers can't teach you to play by ear, so they teach you something else instead (reading music), and learners come to believe that that is what it's all about.
 
I don't believe that is possible. I can't see how you could do it. Of course you could tell them to do it, but how could you teach them to do it? The process takes place entirely within the student's mind. How could you intervene?

Play a piece of music to a student, then tell them to play it. They play the wrong notes. Then what?
How can you judge? You're not there, you're not checking with the students. You're making allegations based on assumptions.

This thread's getting a very nasty undertone and going nowhere. If it doesn't improve, it'll be closed.
 
Sorry , that isn't a problem with reading music, that's a musicianship problem - and that type of thing happens to readers and non-readers.

No, in this case at any rate it is excessive reliance on reading music that is at the root of the problem, the person in question acknowledges that. He's looking at the music, translating that into finger positions, and not thinking about the sound, either his own or the rest of the band.
 
No, the point I am making, which few people here seem able to grasp, is that it is essential to be able to play by ear (to play jazz) and it is not essential to read music. The emphasis should therefore be on ear playing, but as exemplified by the poor sod who posted the initial query, it is in many cases pretty much ignored.

I think one reason is that teachers can't teach you to play by ear, so they teach you something else instead (reading music), and learners come to believe that that is what it's all about.
Very true, if I find I have trouble playing a tune by ear, I resort to having a look at the music to learn that section
 
I compare it to only being able to know a story if someone tells or reads it to you, rather than being able to read stories yourself any time you wanted to. My question is why deprive yourself of the advantages of learning new tunes quickly by reading from Fake Books or lead sheets. Or having the opportunity to play duets or in quartets, or in combos with other musicians.

Playing by ear and developing your ear is also extremely important to becoming a well rounded musician, but you don't need to sacrifice "musical literacy" in order to develop those skills.
 
Although 95 + % of my playing is improvisation I agree with jbtsax. If you have the time to learn how to read music it's a very worthwhile skill and can open up vistas you can't currently see. It's the means of communication between musicians so that you can play together. If your goal is to always play by yourself and accept your limitations then that's your decision.

If you're intending to learn by playing without understanding the notes you're playing it's like learning to type on a keyboard that doesn't have the letters and numbers on the keys. You're starting off blind and blank just hoping to eventually make sense of it. Can be done...is it faster or smarter? Once you've got the basics down then there are other means (not usually taught) which can help you to become an effective improviser who plays what's in their head rather than set patterns. ....When you're ready....
 
My attitude has always been -
if I can whistle it then with a bit of work like finding out where all the whistle notes are whether it be on the saxophone or any other long blow tube instrument then with a bit of practice I can play it.

So it's been my goal in life to master the intricacies of this infernal curly tube for the last 50 years.

My quest has taken me to many corners of the world, met loads of people and had loads of fun along the way. Still can't make it whistle like I want to but Ey keep on keeping on 😉

You can of course take lessons, read books on theory and learn to play like all those other people who've taken lessons and read books on theory.

It depends what you want to do, where and how far you want to go, - and how brave you are.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,565
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom