Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

I think the first thing that Jeanette needs to do is to climb out of the "I can't do it" hole. Would I be right in guessing that when she tries to play sax "by ear" it's as if her mind were being forced to do something it doesn't want to and seems to be trying to tell her, "stop it"? So, make the process as easy as possible. On a sax, particularly a soprano, the player has to form the note. Skip that part by starting with the keyboard where you press a key and a note comes out. If it's not the note you want, press another key then another until you find what you want.
Once you've got the tune on keyboard, you can play the same notes on sax and you'll have the tune there. Forget transposition at this stage and accept that whatever you play on soprano sax will come out a full tone lower than the same thing on keyboard.
Another thing: try to start with tunes where the notes are close together in pitch because that way it's easier to find the right ones. For a beginner at playing by ear "Happy Birthday" is quite difficult because at one point you have to jump a full octave and recognising that just by hearing it is beyond "beginner" level. "Frere Jaque" and "Three Blind Mice" are much easier to start with. That may seem literally infantile, but I suggest that it's a good way for someone who's in the "I can't do it" hole to start the climb out.
 
Let's not forget the universal woodwind trainer, the recorder. It produces an even tone easily and quickly connects ears to fingers. It uses a simple boehm system so everything transfers, I wouldn't recommend saxophone as a first instrument.
 
Whilst I'm in a picky mood (sorry Colin):
It uses a simple boehm system so everything transfers,
A Boehm system is a system of keywork. Recorders don't have any keywork. And if you ever play a recorder in something like C# major you'll find the fingering similarities between that and a sax are practically non-existent.

Still good for learning woodwind basics though. 🙂
 
I still don't believe I'm any good at this sax playing lark.......
That goes for several of us including me. I'm ahead of you on playing by ear, you're way ahead of me on sight reading and playing in general as your sounclips tell me.
I come from a family with a massive music gene and used to think I was gifted. I know now that the family gene has bypassed me and my innate ability is very ordinary. So, I have to work hard at playing sax but I know I'm improving. One of my aims is to play well enough for others to enjoy listening to me. From your soundclips I'd say you've already got there!
 
Let's not forget the universal woodwind trainer, the recorder. It produces an even tone easily and quickly connects ears to fingers. It uses a simple boehm system so everything transfers, I wouldn't recommend saxophone as a first instrument.
I recently had to give some recorder lessons, and I found out that in this lovely island, children are taught what in Italy we call "baroque" fingering, with that unpleasant fork F xxx|xoxx. While what we call "German" fingering (more similar to Boehm) is not considered.
I can only guess you haven't taught it to many children.🙂
With those little uncontrollable fingers that never stay on a tonehole for more than a fraction of a second?
With that overblowing habit that scares most mammals in the area?
With that unpleasant habit of using it as an aspergillum to sprinkle saliva on fellow students?
 
I recently had to give some recorder lessons, and I found out that in this lovely island, children are taught what in Italy we call "baroque" fingering, with that unpleasant fork F xxx|xoxx.
I suspect you'll find that's cos it's in tune with the style of recorders used here - although the concept of "in tune" with the little buggers is a bit of a lost cause.
 
that scares most mammals in the area
I've just had a bit of encouragement from my cat. She's always objected to my playing, which is understandable. Now she's objecting to Billie Holiday and the Prez: maybe I'm not that bad and it's simply, that cat ain't got no culture.
 
I recently had to give some recorder lessons, and I found out that in this lovely island, children are taught what in Italy we call "baroque" fingering, with that unpleasant fork F xxx|xoxx. While what we call "German" fingering (more similar to Boehm) is not considered.

With those little uncontrollable fingers that never stay on a tonehole for more than a fraction of a second?
With that overblowing habit that scares most mammals in the area?
With that unpleasant habit of using it as an aspergillum to sprinkle saliva on fellow students?
German system recorders are made slightly different to use that fingering. You can tell from the tone holes, but I can't remember how.
 
The challenge I have with playing by ear (amongst others) is that I realise that to do it will take a fair amount of time and effort. Given that I don't have issues reading notation (and because of the instruments I play, I read all 4 of the standard clefs - F4, C3, C4 and G2) I'm a bit short of incentive to do it... It's something I will have a go at sometime, but it may need to wait for retirement!
 
The challenge I have with playing by ear (amongst others) is that I realise that to do it will take a fair amount of time and effort. Given that I don't have issues reading notation (and because of the instruments I play, I read all 4 of the standard clefs - F4, C3, C4 and G2) I'm a bit short of incentive to do it... It's something I will have a go at sometime, but it may need to wait for retirement!
I admire your skill in playing from sheet music which is what you need for the orchestral music you play. You have no need to play be ear so why should you bother? But, please understand that for the kind of music I want to play, it's far more important to be able to play by ear so for me improving my dot-reading skill is very much on the back burner.
 
Is there any connection between playing by ear and improvisation? I haven't learned to improvise so I have no firm opinion but I would have thought that "ear" is essential to improvisation, otherwise how can one recognise the chords as they change and know what goes with them? I repeat, I can't improvise so I don't know how it's done and I'm asking a question rather than making an assertion.
 
Is there any connection between playing by ear and improvisation? I haven't learned to improvise so I have no firm opinion but I would have thought that "ear" is essential to improvisation, otherwise how can one recognise the chords as they change and know what goes with them? I repeat, I can't improvise so I don't know how it's done and I'm asking a question rather than making an assertion.

This is a really interesting question! I discovered at my recent improvisation workshops that I don't improvise the way some other people do, or at least I don't think I do it the way they say they do it. The way the course tutor says he does it is all about recognising chords and knowing what goes with them. So before he plays a new piece he says he analyses it.

I think my improvisation is built more on the melody. I embroider the melody, which can lead to the development of new bits of melody that match the changes.

I'm interested that you think you can't improvise because you haven't learned. What would happen if you just did it?? Take a song you know reasonably well, one with a clear melody, sing the melody, and then start to add little twiddles, arpeggios, sing notes that would harmonise with the original melody, sing little snatches of melody that fit the chords (because they are related to the original melody), when something works, repeat it with variations.

Can you do that? What happens? Can you do it on the sax?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom