richardr
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,697
I think the first thing that Jeanette needs to do is to climb out of the "I can't do it" hole. Would I be right in guessing that when she tries to play sax "by ear" it's as if her mind were being forced to do something it doesn't want to and seems to be trying to tell her, "stop it"? So, make the process as easy as possible. On a sax, particularly a soprano, the player has to form the note. Skip that part by starting with the keyboard where you press a key and a note comes out. If it's not the note you want, press another key then another until you find what you want.
Once you've got the tune on keyboard, you can play the same notes on sax and you'll have the tune there. Forget transposition at this stage and accept that whatever you play on soprano sax will come out a full tone lower than the same thing on keyboard.
Another thing: try to start with tunes where the notes are close together in pitch because that way it's easier to find the right ones. For a beginner at playing by ear "Happy Birthday" is quite difficult because at one point you have to jump a full octave and recognising that just by hearing it is beyond "beginner" level. "Frere Jaque" and "Three Blind Mice" are much easier to start with. That may seem literally infantile, but I suggest that it's a good way for someone who's in the "I can't do it" hole to start the climb out.
Once you've got the tune on keyboard, you can play the same notes on sax and you'll have the tune there. Forget transposition at this stage and accept that whatever you play on soprano sax will come out a full tone lower than the same thing on keyboard.
Another thing: try to start with tunes where the notes are close together in pitch because that way it's easier to find the right ones. For a beginner at playing by ear "Happy Birthday" is quite difficult because at one point you have to jump a full octave and recognising that just by hearing it is beyond "beginner" level. "Frere Jaque" and "Three Blind Mice" are much easier to start with. That may seem literally infantile, but I suggest that it's a good way for someone who's in the "I can't do it" hole to start the climb out.
