Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

I suggest that there's a huge difference between learning to improvise and teaching the same. You learn to improvise by playing it and finding what sounds right to you and what the audience likes.
But you're much more likely to find something that sounds right (in the practice room, I mean) if you're constantly aware of where you are in the chord progression (asuming there is one) and you know on a deep level what, for example, a flat 9 sounds like in that harnonic context and where it is on your instrument. And to get that knowledge, you spend many, many hours prcaticing patterns, licks etc on those harmonies. That's where the theory comes in, as I see it. On the gig, hopefully, you just play the stuff you've already mastered.
 
if you're constantly aware of where you are in the chord progression
Theory is one way towards this but I suspect that most of the guys I listen to don't know any theory and that they simply recognise a chord how it sounds and know what will fit. As Colin the Bear says, years of practice.
 
I don't think this is unattainable. It comes with playing by "ear" - I find that I can play simple melodies in easy keys straight off without prior practice. It comes to me naturally.

I think you're half way there. If you can learn a melody by heart and know where your fingers are going you can start adding simple twiddles here and there, maybe wobbling up and down by a tone or semitone on long notes. Or you might add notes like putting a quick A before a G - E interval, or turning intervals like C - G into runs like CDEFG. You might even miss a few notes out of a sequence by hanging on to the first note a bit longer then diving straight into the last. As you get the hang of it you'll probably get more adventurous and move further away from the straight melody. A bit like trying to work out a harmony as you mentioned. You'll find which notes fit with which keys by trial and error, and probably recognise those notes from scales, which will give you an idea of the chord sequence.
 
I think you're half way there.
Thanks for your encouragement. I'll listen to you rather than my daughter who told me last year, "Dad, keep on playing that sax if you enjoy it, but don't imagine you'll ever be any good". She's a semi-professional musician. I must admit that one of the things that drives me is a desire to confound her!
 
Thanks for your encouragement. I'll listen to you rather than my daughter who told me last year, "Dad, keep on playing that sax if you enjoy it, but don't imagine you'll ever be any good". She's a semi-professional musician. I must admit that one of the things that drives me is a desire to confound her!
Ouch!
 
Thanks for your encouragement. I'll listen to you rather than my daughter who told me last year, "Dad, keep on playing that sax if you enjoy it, but don't imagine you'll ever be any good". She's a semi-professional musician. I must admit that one of the things that drives me is a desire to confound her!

Go for it. Us Dads need to stick together!
 
Playing to be good I feel is self defeating. I don't play to be good or for anyone but me to enjoy it. I try to make it interesting so I don't bore myself. I'm very pleased and grateful if people like it. I try to flavour the mix pleasantly when playing with a group but remain true to myself.

Recording yourself can help to keep it real. I can sometimes hear what I should have played while listening to the playback of what I did play. Sometimes I surprise myself and it takes ages to play it again.

I feel it's very important to record yourself and listen to the recordings with an open, critical ear. Playing out of tune annoys me. I often listen to recordings of myself, only to be annoyed.
 
No I haven't, because I can't be bothered to record myself. I have Audacity but fiddling around with my computer when I've a tenor sax slung round my neck is all too much trouble.
Not sure how anyone can disagree with this personal opinion of how you feel! You can't be bothered and that is a matter entirely for you! I find recording a bit of a faff so have left it! I may go back to it but if I don't the world will keep on spinning!
 
Like anything, the more you do the easier it gets. Took me quite a while to get used to where all the buttons are on audacity and which ones to press. It's a little more complicated than an old fashioned cassette recorder, but not much. Stick a mic in the mic socket and hit the red button. Put the sax on the stand first though.
 
I feel it's very important to record yourself and listen to the recordings with an open, critical ear.
This is one of a number of good reasons that I've been given to record myself and I have done so from time to time, only to find that I can't play properly (ie worse than usual) because having to work my computer is too much of a distraction .
 
Recording also lets you know how well you know a piece. The red light is very distracting. Perhaps it's not worse than usual. That's the revelation. I never cease to be amazed how recordings turn out. If you find the computer distracting, you'll find an audience and other band members more so.
 
Not sure how anyone can disagree with this personal opinion of how you feel! You can't be bothered and that is a matter entirely for you! I find recording a bit of a faff so have left it! I may go back to it but if I don't the world will keep on spinning!

Because it isn't so hard to do, plus it is a great way for you to improve your playing. Beginners that don't record tbh don't know what they really sound like, or how far out of time they are, or how out of tune they are, or not as the case may be..
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom