Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

Or, are you saying you can figure it out and then play it, in which case whats the dif?


There is no real difference - you learn to play something and then play it. I can hear certain phrases or riffs and be able to play them almost instantly, on the bass anyway 😉, but this isn't anything special, it's simply experience and recognising what the person has played. I know some musicians can do this with quite complex pieces, but I'm not one of them. 😉
 
After a while I began to think in terms of musical intervals

Please note the "after a while".
The instinctive aspect of playing by ear is easier than expected.
I often play something to my students and ask them to find the notes without looking at my fingers.

My (academic) theory teacher at some point recommended, while on a bus, to sing things in my mind, analyze intervals and durations, go home and transcribe them.
 
Please note the "after a while".
The instinctive aspect of playing by ear is easier than expected.
I often play something to my students and ask them to find the notes without looking at my fingers.

My (academic) theory teacher at some point recommended, while on a bus, to sing things in my mind, analyze intervals and durations, go home and transcribe them.
I have a good friend who is a professional tubist (the Jazz for Cows guy). He has tubas in all different keys Bb, Eb, F, C etc. and he just picks them up and plays them. I asked him once how he can do that. He said that he just thinks in terms of intervals something brass players have to learn to do right from the start.
 
I have a good friend who is a professional tubist (the Jazz for Cows guy). He has tubas in all different keys Bb, Eb, F, C etc. and he just picks them up and plays them. I asked him once how he can do that. He said that he just thinks in terms of intervals something brass players have to learn to do right from the start.
I read these sorts of posts and go into a blind panic, I so wish I had started 20 years ago 🙂

Jx
 
I think "playing by ear" is a simplification of the word improvisation.. When you play by ear, do you rely solely on your ear? No, you use your brain in thousand different ways.

I think a better term for it might be 'playing from your subconsciousness". While listening to tunes, even just the one time, your building your repetoire in your subconscious mind.
You just gotta learn to trust that your subconscious mind, are remembering the things that your conscious mind might forget.
 
I think "playing by ear" is a simplification of the word improvisation.. When you play by ear, do you rely solely on your ear? No, you use your brain in thousand different ways.

I think a better term for it might be 'playing from your subconsciousness". While listening to tunes, even just the one time, your building your repertoire in your subconscious mind.
You just gotta learn to trust that your subconscious mind, are remembering the things that your conscious mind might forget.
I would agree that there are similarities, but to me the main difference is that "playing by ear" generally refers to playing a tune composed by someone else without printed music, and improvisation refers to playing a tune you are creating as you go along. Hearing music in your mind and then playing it aloud is common to both.
 
I think "playing by ear" is a simplification of the word improvisation.. When you play by ear, do you rely solely on your ear? No, you use your brain in thousand different ways.

I think a better term for it might be 'playing from your subconsciousness". While listening to tunes, even just the one time, your building your repetoire in your subconscious mind.
You just gotta learn to trust that your subconscious mind, are remembering the things that your conscious mind might forget.

This point deserves some deepening.
In linguistic, two guys (Ogden and Richards) developed a model that could be a starting point in analizing musical behaviours.
I would distinguish "playing by ear" from "improvisation".
Playing by ear we are supposed to know what is going to happen, in improvisation this is not always necessary.
The point is describing the path of "playing by year" in beginners or in experienced players.

This thread is getting even more interesting, now.
 
improvisation refers to playing a tune you are creating as you go along.
So, charlie parker wasn't improvising on tunes he allready knew? Not trying to be cocky! I'm just trying to create a logical picture.

Playing by ear we are supposed to know what is going to happen, in improvisation this is not always necessary.
Well what if you are playing a tune you never heard before, by ear?
 
Well what if you are playing a tune you never heard before, by ear?
If you mean a tune that someone sings to me and I have to play it on the saxophone, I wouldn't call it improvisation.
If I am playing something that nobody heard before, not even myself, I'd call it improvisation.
 
Well, I'm not talking about reprising. I'm talking about taking stuff from your subconsciousness and putting it together over chord proggressions you havent heard before.
 
Well, I'm not talking about reprising. I'm talking about taking stuff from your subconsciousness and putting it together over chord proggressions you havent heard before.
That is a higher level: extemporary composition, or improvisation on an unknown progression.
I like to do it putting on backing tracks I never heard before, but I often hit my head.

Tough, really tough.
 
I think it's the most fun form of improvisation, especially, if i know the artist who composed the new tune i am playing really well, because then i usually stand a chance of making something out of it, because i know his style.

There's no better feeling than when you; find a brand new tune, that you can hear is right for your style/tone, pressing pause, remove mouthpiece cap, press play and play something that actually fits!... Oh the joy..

Edit: I think this is something everyone who is trying to get better at improvising should do.

Didn't someone on this forum once refer to improvisation as; "Composition on the fly" ?
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom