Playing the saxophone Is it me or my saxophone?

I dont know the graftonite numbering as I find the graftonite and metalite way too harsh (does that bear any relevance to your iced latte description?) for my liking.
But if using @thomsax numbering knowledge......
This is an important observation in your quest for the warm Latte.
A B3 & a softer reed vs a C7 and harder reed is almost definitely giving you more control as well as the fact that the B chamber is allowing the air through in a broader, slower steam at that point which will contribute to a less piercing sound.
Not sure if I have described the air stream very well with broader and slower but if you think of pinching closed a balloon full of air and you let some pressure out through a tiny hole by releasing your thumb and finger thats been holding it closed, the leak will be a more high pitched piercing noise.
If you let the air out with a larger leak between your finger and thumb then the whole sound becomes deeper and less piercing at the same time.

What your B3 and softer reed are doing is giving you control & volume of air.
This makes perfect sense. I thought the no2 synthetic reed was soft enough, but I do have some 1.5 canes left over which I will start using today.
 
Don't be afraid to try different ligatures. Ok they should hold the reed so you can play well. I play a Rovner Dark 2R on my Metalite baritone mpc. I have the pins and screw down instead of on the top. I think it's playing a little bit better with the pins down. This sorts of things are harmless and cost you no money to try. Your teacher knows probably more about this.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4925.webp
    IMG_4925.webp
    19.6 KB · : 95
Last edited:
Is your music teacher an accomplished sax player?
List what you do, in your daily practice, from the moment you put your mouth on the mouthpiece.

I've had students that took half hour lessons for 2-3 years, and sounded pitiful at best.
They could read the music.
They learned from school teachers that were not reed players, just middle/high school music teachers, that played many instruments, not so well.
Gave those teachers a few lessons to help improve the school's music program.
Plus how to make the charts playable, and sound great, with the mix of students at different levels.

Long ago all sax students started with a HR 3 lay and a 1.5 cane reed.
The teachers made the changes based on their progress.

My ligature is made from a meteorite.
It lets me play "way out" but always keep it in.
Just kidding. :sax:
 
Last edited:
This makes perfect sense. I thought the no2 synthetic reed was soft enough, but I do have some 1.5 canes left over which I will start using today.
Ah good.
So you can be comfortable that the B is more in line with the sound concept you are after and the 3 (closer) along with a softish reed is helping you control things better than on the C7.

Along with so much advice and opinions here offered so far
If you take the balloon analogy away from the mouthpiece design for a moment and now think about it for your body.....
Can you visualise the air completely filling your lungs (as the balloon) and the release through your throat into the mouthpiece with a firm but not biting embouchure as the volume of air trying to escape your finger and thumb you can apply a similar approach before the air even gets to the B3. Which is your part in helping to produce the sound you are after (is it my saxophone or me?) this is the me part you can control.
Sound "arrrrgggghhhhh' and feel your throat expand as opposed to sounding 'eeeeeeeeee' where it will close in slightly.

Stay conscious of that and it will go a long way.
 
This^ it helps to know what sound you're aiming for. If you do look into changing mouthpieces, if you can give a player you like the sound of it should be possible suggest a suitable piece.

Correct, but at the same time if you're not happy with your sound, you're not as enthusiastic about playing practicing.

Where abouts are you located?
The funny thing is though, most of my favourite sax players are primarily tenor players (jJohn Coltrane, Lester Young, Pharoah Sanders, Sonny Rollins).
 
Is your music teacher an accomplished sax player?
List what you do, in your daily practice, from the moment you put your mouth on the mouthpiece.

I've had students that took half hour lessons for 2-3 years, and sounded pitiful at best.
They learned from school teachers that were not reed players, just middle/high school music teachers, that played many instruments, not so well.
Gave those teachers a few lessons to help improve the school's music program.
Plus how to make the charts playable, and sound great, with the mix of students at different levels.

Long ago all sax students started with a HR 3 lay and a 1.5 cane reed.
The teachers made the changes based on their progress.
Absolutely! And a talented and experienced multi-instrumentalist. She is a good teacher, and I can't fault her.

Since the spring, my practice starts with the Klose exercises, just 1&2 for now, alternating with TTS Tone without Tears, again the first few exercises for about 15-20 minutes. Then I dive into whatever music I am trying to learn. I'm currently playing mostly UK grade 3 and 4 (Trinity) material. Whilst I am taking the Theory exams through ABRSM, I have not decided whether I need or want to take the saxophone exams. I practice with and without accompaniment for about another hour and a half. Basically the bulk of my practice session is playing.
 
Ah good.
So you can be comfortable that the B is more in line with the sound concept you are after and the 3 (closer) along with a softish reed is helping you control things better than on the C7.

Along with so much advice and opinions here offered so far
If you take the balloon analogy away from the mouthpiece design for a moment and now think about it for your body.....
Can you visualise the air completely filling your lungs (as the balloon) and the release through your throat into the mouthpiece with a firm but not biting embouchure as the volume of air trying to escape your finger and thumb you can apply a similar approach before the air even gets to the B3. Which is your part in helping to produce the sound you are after (is it my saxophone or me?) this is the me part you can control.
Sound "arrrrgggghhhhh' and feel your throat expand as opposed to sounding 'eeeeeeeeee' where it will close in slightly.

Stay conscious of that and it will go a long way.
This is golden. Thank you!
 
I thought the B3 came in different chamber/baffle shapes?

Certainly the mouthpiece can make a huge difference if it is designed to have bright baffle and/or chamber so I’d look into this.

I also agree that it is unlikely to be an issue with the horn itself.
"The B3 Graftonite Alto Saxophone mouthpiece features the medium B chamber for the most brilliance and projection, a .070" tip opening, and an 18mm facing length ..."

Ok, you are right, it's a sandblaster 🙂
 
"The B3 Graftonite Alto Saxophone mouthpiece features the medium B chamber for the most brilliance and projection, a .070" tip opening, and an 18mm facing length ..."

Ok, you are right, it's a sandblaster 🙂
Well I don't know much about Rico mouthpieces, but are you saying there is a difference between a B3 and a B3 Graftonite?
 
Well I don't know much about Rico mouthpieces, but are you saying there is a difference between a B3 and a B3 Graftonite?
No, if you just google Rico B3 it gets you straight to the Graftonite offering. I got a graftonite and a metalite once because they were cheap and had great reviews on Amazon (the best bang for the money) and played both for about 5 min which was enough for the raven to speak.
 
my practice starts with the Klose exercises, just 1&2 for now, alternating with TTS Tone without Tears, again the first few exercises for about 15-20 minutes.

What are the Tone without Tears exercises? I was a little surprised to see you don't start with some kind of warmup or long tones. Klose #1 straightaway and I can imagine things getting a bit tense 😉.

I feel like getting tone feedback from teachers is not always straightforward. My teacher seems to prefer positive reinforcement and and usually says I sound good (I don't think so of course, but I sort of see his point). The most objective thing he's said is that I "don't have a problem playing loudly". One time I had a sub fill in for my teacher and she said my tone was 'bright" (probably a euphemism for harsh 🙂 ) and she recommended "hairpin longtones", so set your metronome around 50 bpm and crescendo from as softly as you can play to as loudly for two bars, diminuendo for two, starting at middle B, down to low Bb, and then start at middle C and up to high F chromatically.

Every third day or so I alternate a different exercise from an Alexa Tarantino video, ha-ta-ta's and whisper tones, best explained here,

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZH8Hprw9K8
 
As far as I can tell the OP has not made clear whether she's playing a Graftonite B3 (not a very good MP) or a Rico Royal B3 (by all accounts a well made mouthpiece of standard design).

For a beginner on alto I'd recommend Brilhart Ebolin, Selmer Soloist or S-80, Yamaha 5C, Meyer 5, Vandoren Optimum or V5; that kind of thing, probably .065-.075".

Cane reeds, either in the #2 range for the Rico-type or maybe #1.5 for the Vandoren blue-box type.

Lots of personal instruction on air stream and embouchure. I can't tell but fear that the instructor here is not focusing as much as desirable on these things.
 
As far as I can tell the OP has not made clear whether she's playing a Graftonite B3 (not a very good MP
That's what I was wondering. @Lydia did not mention Graftonite which is why I was/am confused by people mentioning Graftonite.

Brilhart Ebolin, Selmer Soloist or S-80, Yamaha 5C, Meyer 5, Vandoren Optimum or V5; that kind of thing, probably .065-.075".
I agree with all of those plus a Fobes Debut and (of course) a PPT, although I think it may be better for someone who is a relative beginner not to spend too much. (That said there may be a PPT alto pass around soon AFAIK)
 
a Graftonite B3 (not a very good MP) or a Rico Royal B3
That's what I was wondering. @Lydia did not mention Graftonite which is why I was/am confused by people mentioning Graftonite.
I'm not sure if my 'graftonite' tenor is marked as Rico Royal? I will dig it out and check...

Edit - Yes it does! Rico Royal B5.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,456
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom