Somebody said that somebody else was telling him his reed was too soft and the only way to know for sure would be to try. Everything else is just conjecture.How did we get onto other people playing your reeds ? 🤷🏻♂️
They were just talking about a bit of banter between mates.Somebody said that somebody else was telling him his reed was too soft and the only way to know for sure would be to try. Everything else is just conjecture.
I practice for 2 hours a day, more when I can 😎 so I definitely don't feel lack of practice is an issue for me, unless you are suggesting I try "shedding" 😄It’s great that OP is looking for and trying out advice given here by our very knowledgeable members, I’ve been following this thread since inception, and my impression is that she is not learning by practice but by others’ experiences.
I partially agree, but for me the listening experience is quite different to the playing experience. Just like eating at a restaurant is different to cooking a meal for yourself.B5 is a decent mpc but won’t give the sound that a beginner expects in his audio memory, since we’ve all been there, and want to hear our favourite players’ sound come out of our sax before we can even sound like a decent player.
It is still early days where the new reed is concerned. It is slightly harder to blow, but I prefer the sound!And now going up in reed strength means she’ll have less control over her sound notwithstanding that she might very well damage her embouchure if it’s too hard for her.
Makes perfect sense to me. It is reassuring to know that I am on the right path 😜Not sure if I’m making sense to y’all. I’m speaking from personal experience having spent years learning by myself with books and online videos and falling in every pit and bad habit that the beginner falls into. In the end what worked for me was a good midpriced mpc going slowly from a 1.5 to a 2.5 to attain my best sound and lots and lots of practice,
Lol! I don't always do it all in one session. Sometimes one before work (I work from home) and in between clients, and an evening one.@Lydia
2 hours daily. Wow! You got stamina. Long notes to get the tone right. Mental note of where and how that perfect sounding note is, because being able to reproduce it at every following sessions means you’re on the right track. Also I hope in those 2 hours there’s theory and rhythm.
It is reassuring to know that it isn't just a "me" thing!I meant we try to reproduce the sound we like but are not able to until much much later, very frustrating.
Thank you. I can relate to the sore mouth and jaw. To be honest I have been mainly playing the No2 and now that I am more aware of my bad habits, the sound has improved.On a hard reed, look after that embouchure. At some point you’ll feel like you have lockjaw. Your lower lip will suffer if curled on teeth and you’ll try to compensate the discomfort by doing other things that may well damage your embouchure. Your sound will suffer and if you persist it will just get worse, both the discomfort and the sound. Take a few weeks’ break if that happens. And start again on softs.
This is brilliant advice. Thank you so muchI took much longer to play well because I was trying too hard to play as it’s taught rather than play how it feels naturally which comes with basic technique and LOTS of practice. Just re: embouchure, all mouths, lips, tongues, breaths are not equal. Some say mouth full in, others on the tip…..etc. Very distracting.
Good luck on your sax journey.

Check your mouthpiece setup. Higher-end saxes can have better tone.
Yes, horns do make a difference, I picked up.a King Cleveland tenor for $300.- , I didn't really want it but it was an old guy needing some funds for his dogs surgery (my soft spot) and it turned out a hell of a player. Then I did a complete overhaul of a YTS23 and I just can't get along with the keywork/ergos. It sounds great but my hands are too small. That's my main issue.For many sax players it's difficult to find out the good saxes and right stuff. So many guys on the net who are promoting "their" saxes and accessories.
I have also played ultra cheap and high quality student saxes. The G4M tenor and YTS 25 I played couldn't compete with New King tenor I bought for half the price of a new G4M tenor. I also got two Berg Larsen ss bullet mouthpieces that came along with the New King. So cheap that I could afford to give one of the Larsen to a young aspiring RockSax player. She was good with the Yamaha mouthpiece she had but with a Larsen she is even better.
Internet is fantastic .... but most decisions I have made I took on my own or with help from friends. To know and meet, in real life, persons who can help you is important.
That's kind of what I do. I get Gonzalez reeds which may be a bit harder than other brands. A lot of the time they play out the box for me or after a little blowing in. Generally reeds will soften with some playing, though I've heard from some players saying Alexanders, for example can feel harder after they've been blown in (!?)What do people think of the advice to get reeds slightly harder than you like (for example if you like a 2 get a 2.5) because some in a box will be soft and some that are harder you can adjust down (but not up)?
