Playing the saxophone Is it me or my saxophone?

No.
I’m saying that if someone plays with a particularly mellow, or distinctly not bright sound, then any possible changes are less likely than a player who plays with a bright(er) sound
Yes, that’s what I thought you were saying. And I agree it’s quite possible.
 
I can definitely relate!
It sounds like you probably have very sensitive ears - maybe more so than your teachers. This happens, ie there are some people who seems to just have incredibly good sense of pitch. If you have perfect pitch thus can be a double edged sword as you will be hyper critical of tuning issues that don't actually matter to "ordinary" people. OTOH, you have been blessed with good ears which can be a real boon.
 
Last edited:
I had a couple of tenors in which sounded similar to me. In the hands of my friend they were considerably different. I think things like a mouthpiece or horn can offer a potential for difference , but it won't necessarily be realised. Some 'different' saxophones are so similar there isn't much of a real difference acoustically.
Players can subconsciously achieve 'their sound' by making minor adjustments to embouchure, air pressure, lip pressure etc. I try not to do that when trying different equipment - but maybe you can't 'turn it off'(?)
Recently played a Mauriat 66 which had a nice warm sound. Several similarities to my Trevor James - but it has a different bore and is brighter by comparison. There's no way I could get the TJ to sound as warm as the PM66. That sound owes a lot to the bore design. There's an acoustical difference, though the mechanics are very similar.
So there's two examples where the horn did or didn't make a difference - same player.
 
As I wrote earlier the saxophones can make big differences. Try a Keilwerth (wide bow) with slightly open up keys) and a factory set-up Martin Committee (low keys-heights).

The question "Is it me or the saxophone?" I would say it's 90% the player.
 
As I wrote earlier the saxophones can make big differences. Try a Keilwerth (wide bow) with slightly open up keys) and a factory set-up Martin Committee (low keys-heights).

The question "Is it me or the saxophone?" I would say it's 90% the player.
Well, just used the same approach to find a friend a new tenor that I used.
Line up 12 tenor saxes, use the same mouthpiece/reed and play the same thing each time.
- 2 pretty nice
- 1 ok
- 8 NO!
- 1 standout

Worked the same for me a few years back too. Doesn’t always work of course, but it’s always good to benchmark what you’re already playing on if you’re not 100% sure.

Have to be solid enough to play the same every time and not be all over the place - knowing that the input = x output
 
I ask because we read, here, many discussions about this MP suiting that sax etc.
If you do read that, I would advise against assuming it is correct. It may be very biased or just plain wrong. Possible we might think in much ore general terms, e.g. it might make sense to say very vintage saxophones work best with very vintage mouthpieces but I'd be intrigued to know where it says anything about "this MP suiting that sax".

I may well be wrong (I was was once before if I recall)
 
If you do read that, I would advise against assuming it is correct.
Sure. I normally add "I find..." To any claims as people vary in so many ways.

But it is discussed, from time to time...
Eg
My knowledge on this is mostly hearsay with a bit of trial end error, but we often hear about "mouthpiece mismatches", especially when using modern mouthpieces on vintage instruments (
 
If you're doing that, would you be using a "neutral" MP in some sense?
I ask because we read, here, many discussions about this MP suiting that sax etc. (Maybe mostly for older horns).
When life looking for a new (possibly better) horn, you don’t go chopping and changing the one constant that you know.
 
It sounds like you probably have very sensitive ears - maybe more so than your teachers. This happens, ie there are some people who seems to just have incredibly good sense of pitch. If you have perfect pitch thus can be a double edged sword as you will be hyper critical of tuning issues that don't actually matter to "ordinary" people. OTOH, you have been blessed with good ears which can be a real boon.
My music teacher said exactly this!
 
Mouthpices and saxes?

It's ...

.... how you play
.... what you play

Sure. I normally add "I find..." To any claims as people vary in so many ways.

But it is discussed, from time to time...
Eg
I always recommend to have a look at the original mouthpiece that came along with the sax when it was new before the searching starts. 90 % says a Martin sax is playing best with a mouthpiece with big chamber and no baffle. In my opinion a medium/small chamber with some kind of baffle is best, otherwise the Martin lose it's character. A rather small tenor sax with low key heights ...... . You can play with a big chamber mpc as well but I find other saxes better ..... .

Thera are guys, very competent players and big knowledge when it comes to saxes, who says the mouthpiece is a part of the saxophone.Other players says it's rubbish. You have to listen to your self ..... . My wife was the only one who listened to when I was honking on. my own. She has good ears and she is not playing sax.😉
 
Apparently, the answer is "no, use the one you're comfortable with".

Useful to know.
The opposite is true only if you’re happy to go on a complete crusade.

That could be a useful idea but only if you’re not experienced enough to know what type of mouthpiece works for what you need it to do.

Having said that, the amount of variables are daunting, so it also makes it a very bad idea.

I think that one or the other have to be a control part.
 
How did you and your teacher cope with you having the better ears?
Also blowing soft low staccato is a good exercise to lower pressure on the reed.
Thank you for the tip!
I don't know whether I truly have perfect pitch, it is just something that was mentioned. Thankfully we get on really well and we just accept this quirkiness of mine and focus on other things in the lesson, on the premise that my tone will improve with time and experience. I get very frustrated with it occasionally, and when I need to have a break, I go off and do my own thing with the music, then we regroup after a few weeks/months and carry on.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom