Playing the saxophone Is it me or my saxophone?

My music teacher says my sound is fine and will develop over time.
While this is true, especially when you are specifically doing tone control exercise, at this stage it's always a good to work with a good teacher.
She says I'm not out of tune.
This make me question whether she is a good teacher - something is wrong when the student hears issues that the teacher doesn't. If you are consistently sharp then there are two things to try:

  • Relax your embouchure
or (if your embouchures is already relaxed enough)
  • Pull the mouthpiece further off the cork slightly.
 
If you are consistently sharp then there are two things to try:
Can we clarify, Lydia, that your use of the word “sharp” refers to pitch, and not meaning “harsh “ ?

If it does mean sharp then do what Pete says. It’s highly likely that you’ll be playing with too much pressure (jaw bite) on the reed, and also the possibility as has been suggested about too much mouthpiece in your mouth.

Look sideways at the mouthpiece and note where the gap (tip opening) starts. If your lower lip is (pretty much) on this point it will probably sound harsh. If you tend to blow fairly hard then this will exacerbate it. How much back from this point?

Dunno - maybe 10mm? @Pete Thomas ? Never measured what I do.

I do agree with your teacher though about tone taking time. For many, a reasonably good tone would be measured in years. That’s a problem with adult learners - they can have a more discerning ear, especially when it comes to tone and a fixation is not necessarily a healthy thing. Keep it in mind always, yes, but remind yourself that it progresses very slowly, unlike achieving a particular technical goal with an etude, for example.
 
And like @skeller047 I have reservations about a synthetic reed, especially at only one year in.

I play a synthetic on tenor, and have come to really like it. I can’t say the same about alto though.
 
I don't think Graftonite mpc are bad. In my opinion better than Yamaha.

Graftonite alto. A3-A5-A7 / B3-B5-B7 / C3-C5-C7.

"A" chamber is the largest, "B" chamber is medium, "C" chamber is the smallest. "A" is "darker" and "C" is "brighter".

Tip opening: 3 = .070", 5 = .080", 7 = .0.90". Smaller tip less volume / bigger tip opening more volume.

Facing length: 3 = 18mm, 5 = 20mm, 7 = 21,5mm. Shorter facing loose resistance/bright tone / longer facing less resistance/darker tone.

No baffle on Graftonite. If you want a step baffle you should play a Metalite.

The first thing I would do is to check ligature and reed. Make sure the reed ok. You can also do some slightly changes with the ligature. Move it forward or backward. We are talking about minor adjustments.

If you take less mouthpiece you will have more control With more mouthpiece you open your mouth more and will play with less control but more "airy/bigger".
 
We'll Pete is best equipped to say if he feels to order is things is important.
Seems to me, a year is not long to expect to be in control of your tone! And, in regard of the question in the thread title... Probably not the horn.
Thank you. That is reassuring to know. If it is me, that is the problem, I can take steps to rectify it. Perhaps I am a too impatient. I thought my sound would have progressed by now.
 
I don't think Graftonite mpc are bad. In my opinion better than Yamaha.

Graftonite alto. A3-A5-A7 / B3-B5-B7 / C3-C5-C7.

"A" chamber is the largest, "B" chamber is medium, "C" chamber is the smallest. "A" is "darker" and "C" is "brighter".

Tip opening: 3 = .070", 5 = .080", 7 = .0.90". Smaller tip less volume / bigger tip opening more volume.

Facing length: 3 = 18mm, 5 = 20mm, 7 = 21,5mm. Shorter facing loose resistance/bright tone / longer facing less resistance/darker tone.

No baffle on Graftonite. If you want a step baffle you should play a Metalite.

The first thing I would do is to check ligature and reed. Make sure the reed ok. You can also do some slightly changes with the ligature. Move it forward or backward. We are talking about minor adjustments.

If you take less mouthpiece you will have more control With more mouthpiece you open your mouth more and will play with less control but more "airy/bigger".
The ligature I have is made by a company called Rover, I think it is PVC or leather. I have one solid one and one with a cut out. I think they were called Rovner Dark and Rovner Bright. TBH I can't tell the difference between the two in how they sound. Daily I tend to use the B3/Legere no 2 combo although have been gravitating back to the B5. I deliberately stuck with Rico to experiment with cheaper MP until I found one I liked.
I have been playing alto for a year. I've had regular lessons during that time, up until around March this year. I practice around 1 or 2 hours most days minimum.

I'm struggling with the way my sax sounds. I play a Trevor James "The Horn" alto. With a Rico B3 mouthpiece and Legere no2 reed. (Also have Rico B5 and B7 MP).
Imagine the difference between a warm sweet latte and an iced latte. I want to sound like a warm latte, but am still getting iced latte, a bit cold and jarring.
(Even when confirmed in tune by the TE Tuner and music teacher).
I feel the sound is too sharp and cold.
What should I do? I am working through Tone Without Tears, and do the Klose exercises as well.
When people say "student sax', upgrade sax, professional sac. Is there really a difference in sound?
Correction. It's actually a C7 not a B7 that I have. But my sound is even worse now on the C7 (with a softer reed) since I switched to the B3, so I don't play it anymore.
 
TBH I can't tell the difference between the two in how they sound.
Ligatures don't cause any significant difference in sound, provided they are holding the reed firmly and the mouthpiece table itself is not damaged or distorted. Other people think they do but I've never found that myself.

But that is a whole other discussion.
 
Ligatures don't cause any significant difference in sound, provided they are holding the reed firmly and the mouthpiece table itself is not damaged or distorted. Other people think they do but I've never found that myself.

But that is a whole other discussion.
Yes, if they do it’s tiny and won’t bridge the gap between nice and awful
 
Can we clarify, Lydia, that your use of the word “sharp” refers to pitch, and not meaning “harsh “ ?

If it does mean sharp then do what Pete says. It’s highly likely that you’ll be playing with too much pressure (jaw bite) on the reed, and also the possibility as has been suggested about too much mouthpiece in your mouth.

Look sideways at the mouthpiece and note where the gap (tip opening) starts. If your lower lip is (pretty much) on this point it will probably sound harsh. If you tend to blow fairly hard then this will exacerbate it. How much back from this point?

Dunno - maybe 10mm? @Pete Thomas ? Never measured what I do.

I do agree with your teacher though about tone taking time. For many, a reasonably good tone would be measured in years. That’s a problem with adult learners - they can have a more discerning ear, especially when it comes to tone and a fixation is not necessarily a healthy thing. Keep it in mind always, yes, but remind yourself that it progresses very slowly, unlike achieving a particular technical goal with an etude, for example.
I am definitely putting too much jaw pressure - this was pointed out to me by my music teacher. And the more agitated I get about my sound, the more clenchy I become. Most days my jaw aches after long practice sessions, which I thought was due to the length of time, but putting this together with what people have said I can see it is a "me" problem.
I am using the word sharp to mean harsh, piercing, although not always out of tune, but not a sound I am OK with.
I am going to try a few new things today based on this conversation.
 
Alto using synthetic reed on a C3 graftonite. 🙉 Cripes! No wonder you don't like your sound.

Changing your horn will have little effect on your sound, so no need yet.

Mouthpiece is very personal. While the graftonite is an easy blow and a reasonable place to start, it's not a very flexible piece in my opinion.

While a synthetic reed is consistent, it's the inconsistency of cane that teaches your embouchure how to react and search for the sweet spot that each reed has.

I'm assuming that when you describe your sound as sharp but in tune, it might better be described as bright and harsh.

Some players strive for that sound. It's useful in certain ensembles.

However if it offends your ears it might be worth experimenting with reeds. There is a bewildering array of brands and cuts out there.

When it comes down to the very basis of sound production it starts with the reed. That's the place the sound begins it's journey. Everything after that is just shaping what you started with.

The mouthpiece is the interface between your embouchure and the reed. At this point in your journey and your level of practice, your chops are developed enough to be looking for a more expressive and flexible piece to suit your physiognomy and your idea of sound.

One way is to go to a store that stocks a good range and spend a day trying different pieces in different sizes with different reeds.

Another way is to buy used and sell on if they don't suit.

For a mellow sound, the accepted description is dark, the opposite of bright, I'd try a Selmer Soloist or S80, with a french cut reed, perhaps a D'addario Reserve.

Don't get misled by the idea that more money means better. Your setup needs to fit your chops and suit your needs. There's a lot of nonsense spouted in sales pitches for very expensive, mediocre, poorly finished kit.

When you decide on your next piece, spend some time searching for your sound and exploring the limits and range of your capabilities together.
 
While this is true, especially when you are specifically doing tone control exercise, at this stage it's always a good to work with a good teacher.

This make me question whether she is a good teacher - something is wrong when the student hears issues that the teacher doesn't. If you are consistently sharp then there are two things to try:

  • Relax your embouchure
or (if your embouchures is already relaxed enough)
  • Pull the mouthpiece further off the cork slightly.
I did pause the lessons so I could address this by myself. I assume her intentions were to reassure me, but I am a person that just prefers the cold hard truth. I would be surprised if she did not hear what I hear, particularly when playing side by side, our saxes sound completely different! And yes, she is the more experienced player, but I'm pretty sure this is my embouchure and have always felt just continuing and hoping time will resolve it might not be the solution, because I could just correct it now rather than continue to murder music!
 
Correction. It's actually a C7 not a B7 that I have. But my sound is even worse now on the C7 (with a softer reed) since I switched to the B3, so I don't play it anymore.
I dont know the graftonite numbering as I find the graftonite and metalite way too harsh (does that bear any relevance to your iced latte description?) for my liking.
But if using @thomsax numbering knowledge......
This is an important observation in your quest for the warm Latte.
A B3 & a softer reed vs a C7 and harder reed is almost definitely giving you more control as well as the fact that the B chamber is allowing the air through in a broader, slower steam at that point which will contribute to a less piercing sound.
Not sure if I have described the air stream very well with broader and slower but if you think of pinching closed a balloon full of air and you let some pressure out through a tiny hole by releasing your thumb and finger thats been holding it closed, the leak will be a more high pitched piercing noise.
If you let the air out with a larger leak between your finger and thumb then the whole sound becomes deeper and less piercing at the same time.

What your B3 and softer reed are doing is giving you control & volume of air.
 
Alto using synthetic reed on a C3 graftonite. 🙉 Cripes! No wonder you don't like your sound.

Changing your horn will have little effect on your sound, so no need yet.

Mouthpiece is very personal. While the graftonite is an easy blow and a reasonable place to start, it's not a very flexible piece in my opinion.

While a synthetic reed is consistent, it's the inconsistency of cane that teaches your embouchure how to react and search for the sweet spot that each reed has.

I'm assuming that when you describe your sound as sharp but in tune, it might better be described as bright and harsh.

Some players strive for that sound. It's useful in certain ensembles.

However if it offends your ears it might be worth experimenting with reeds. There is a bewildering array of brands and cuts out there.

When it comes down to the very basis of sound production it starts with the reed. That's the place the sound begins it's journey. Everything after that is just shaping what you started with.

The mouthpiece is the interface between your embouchure and the reed. At this point in your journey and your level of practice, your chops are developed enough to be looking for a more expressive and flexible piece to suit your physiognomy and your idea of sound.

One way is to go to a store that stocks a good range and spend a day trying different pieces in different sizes with different reeds.

Another way is to buy used and sell on if they don't suit.

For a mellow sound, the accepted description is dark, the opposite of bright, I'd try a Selmer Soloist or S80, with a french cut reed, perhaps a D'addario Reserve.

Don't get misled by the idea that more money means better. Your setup needs to fit your chops and suit your needs. There's a lot of nonsense spouted in sales pitches for very expensive, mediocre, poorly finished kit.

When you decide on your next piece, spend some time searching for your sound and exploring the limits and range of your capabilities together.
Even worse - I have a C7 not a C3! But I have not been using that one for a while. I am using the Rico B3 with the legere no 2. The sound I am describing is100% "bright and harsh" - like Albert Ayler sharp, although I like his music, that not what I am aiming for in my playing. I got put off by cane reeds, when I hear people say that in a box usually a couple of them are bad. Firstly, I feel this is an unacceptable waste of money, and secondly, I don't think I am experienced enough to know when a reed is bad, unless it was glaringly unplayable of course. Then the cane reed gets damaged easily, which I found really annoying. So the synthetics just seemed like the logical choice.
 
I am using the word sharp to mean harsh
Yep, just be careful in this business, you’ll have all sorts of comments about pulling the mouthpiece off to play flatter etc.

Playing with too much jaw pressure is a completely normal problem, concentrating on the sides of the mouth will help alleviate as will trying to make sure that your bottom jaw/teeth aren’t providing the support to the reed but your lip (muscle) is.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom