Saxophones Has the internet changed players’ attitudes around saxophones and saxophone playing.

Perfect topic for the times Pete. For me the answer is no--unless I'm researching something for an article that is 😉--but based on what I'm seeing sometimes in the groups I play in, the answer is "yes".

That said, by far and away that is the minority of players I work with. I suspect forums like this tend to skew the results, and we think there are more than there are in the wild.
Your site brings great wealth to the sax community. Everything is well researched to the best of your abilities. I use it often. Proof there’s honest and trustworthy information available. Thank you for all your (and Pete’s) hard work. That’s tons of sorting facts from misinformation / lore or single opinionated nonsense. True historical information in one place is hard to find. I’m sure the good members of the Café community feel the same.
 
It seems more than obvious.
I belong to a generation who learned about saxophone players through the radio, the record shops and the summer festivals. I live close to Montreux, Switzerland.

My first smashing exposure to Michael Brecker ? Montreux 1978. David Sanborn ? Montreux 1981. Lockjaw and Zoot on the same stage ? Montreux 1977.

Today, the driving names mostly exist on the net. Chad LB or Patrick Bartley ? No chance to see/hear them in festivals I’m afraid. Those places are now devoted to general public DJs, taylors and swifts.

When you check Syos’ endorsers (endorsees ?), mostly verbose YT heroes. Please click … and listen to 7 minutes of blahblah. Imagine what the Brecker Bros did on stage in 7 minutes …

IA creatures are very likely the upcoming step. Tivon Pennicot must be some kind of funny anagram.
 
Do we now obsess more about gear rather than playing and actual music due to the online forums and more lately the proliferation of social media, YouTube, influencers etc?
Internet changed us all. I got into the Rock & Roll Saxophone world 27 years before I got internet. The The Rock & Roll Saxophone music was the entrance. Not saxes.

In the 70's and 80's it was letters and magazines that gave me information. It took 5-7 days for a letter to reach USA. Maybe 1-2 weeks for the reciever to answer and another week for the letter to reach me in Sweden. It was slow and I didn't write ****. I read my letter several times before I thought they were ready. The fax made my life more speedy. It was possible to order/buy things that I read about in magazines and the fax cut 1-2 weeks. And later on I started to buy saxes this way as well. Internet with complete on-line shops ...... . Most of it was good but we did many mistakes ..... . We lost something on our time journey.

Internet became the "truth". Forums sat the standard .... . " Even if we can find very reliable sourches that is close to the truth, the truth is often delivered by some amusing/forum internet writing and posted on internet; FB, insta, CS, SOTW ..... .

Now I must walk the dog. I think I'm will do some reed prep with the "magical steel" while I'm strolling in the woods with Milla. Forget wetstones, razor blades, sandpapper, light board .... . The trademarkt steel is the thing.
 
I agree. Online, are surrounded by people but are somewhat oblivious to it sometimes: unlike actually being sat around a table with a few people, or in a seminar with many - the restraints / components that regulate behaviour are not always in place online.
 
Stupidogenesis.
Society is making people in it stupider. Writing emails with ChatGPT, navigating 'blindly' with Google maps, 15 second tik tok instead of novels, (then sentences in 'best selling' books are getting shorter and range of vocabulary less), as attention span declines.
People are relying on technology to 'think' for them and IQ rates are falling as 'mental muscles' atrophy.
 
Do we now obsess more about gear rather than playing and actual music due to the online forums and more lately the proliferation of social media, YouTube, influencers etc?
I think the answer for to this question for me is yes and no.
Back when I started 50 years ago there was non of this to distract you so on the main you committed to your gear and got on with it, although what you did have was more local music shops selling gear but without the relentless pressure that you get online today, for example today you get some sellers that list everything as "Holy Grail" and "Killer" piece or horn, and many that say their product is a must have with mega prices to match.
But on the plus side (and this is going to contradict what I said above) more choice can be a good thing for all players moving forward.
 
Bot on the web. Aka sotw
Websites selling (user generated) data to other websites and for training AI may be something we have to accept. I really don't like that idea. An internet discussion reflects a lot of divergent opinions, it's what makes it interesting but I think it's best left up to the real people reading it it form their own opinions based on the arguments and evidence provided. Should AI be doing that and then (probably?) presenting one side of the argument as the truth?
 
Websites selling (user generated) data to other websites and for training AI may be something we have to accept. I really don't like that idea. An internet discussion reflects a lot of divergent opinions, it's what makes it interesting but I think it's best left up to the real people reading it it form their own opinions based on the arguments and evidence provided. Should AI be doing that and then (probably?) presenting one side of the argument as the truth?
Only time will tell. I truly believe in good intentions, but involving money corrupts things. So, what is the intention of AI ?? To make money or make life better ?? Like humans. It’s a choice AI can make . Money can make you comfortable, but it doesn’t necessarily make you a better person….or thing / Bot.
 
I think AI is here to stay, whether that's a good thing or bad thing time will tell, what I do know for humans is life will always change, it's not the same as it was 50 years ago and it will be different in 30 years from now, hopefully the young will adapt because there won't be a choice.
 
hopefully the young will adapt because there won't be a choice.

The very young won’t need to adapt as they are born into it. Instead of Sesame Street, the Wiggles, Balamory with real people and real song singing I remember from my children’s early days, I’m sure the current generation (e.g. my seven day old grand niece) will be fed AI and not even question that it wasn’t people she sang along during the toddler years.
 
I think AI is here to stay, whether that's a good thing or bad thing time will tell, what I do know for humans is life will always change, it's not the same as it was 50 years ago and it will be different in 30 years from now, hopefully the young will adapt because there won't be a choice.
50 years ? Life has drastically changed in the last five years since Covid. As technology advances change takes place more frequently. I remember when…..that is now last month.
 
The very young won’t need to adapt as they are born into it. Instead of Sesame Street, the Wiggles, Balamory with real people and real song singing I remember from my children’s early days, I’m sure the current generation (e.g. my seven day old grand niece) will be fed AI and not even question that it wasn’t people she sang along during the toddler years.
Mini Squealer has a special needs student that’s 3. The parents just bought him a iPad.
 
The kids on YouTube “The Graystones” are all pre-teens. One parent is heavily promoting their daughter at 12 on the side.
Is that wrong? Honestly, I don’t a see good healthy environment for the girl. Social media or the net can be a great thing. But dang, let the kids grow up without being your cash cow.
View: https://youtube.com/shorts/d9fKu2HgeQc?si=xAwvgzIbFgzoX9V_
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I find it faintly depressing that a thread relating to an expensive limited edition saxophone which probably few or none of us aspire to or care much about has garnered 185 posts and 3k views, in much the same time that a thread that allows us to get together, learn new skills and contribute to some fun recording has 39 posts and 1k views. And 3½ practical contributors...

Just sayin'...
 
There was a time earlier on prior to the explosion of posts on the Internet, where the Usenet (how many Gen-Z's remember that?) was many populated by those associated with academia - professors, college students, some R&D government offices, and a few alumni?
Upon its inception, the Internet was populated by mostly intelligent and creative people. Then came AOL and the lonely adults who made it a sort of playground. Fun for a time, but then the kids came online and ruined everything. As it became more mainstream, ignorance got on board and then dominated the web thoroughly. Now when it's not a means for commerce... which basically is the end for such means... it's simply a display of our ugliness that has always been there.

I am a dinosaur. I have no need for AI. I prefer to think critically. A lost art. But yeah... I found some really cool stuff online. Horns and mouthpieces too.
 
I find it faintly depressing that a thread relating to an expensive limited edition saxophone which probably few or none of us aspire to or care much about has garnered 185 posts and 3k views, in much the same time that a thread that allows us to get together, learn new skills and contribute to some fun recording has 39 posts and 1k views. And 3½ practical contributors...

Just sayin'...

You're right. I want more Rock & Roll Saxophone (tips and technique). It's a "narrow" subject.
 
I think we've reached a point in human de-evolution where there are vast numbers of non-sentient humans who are actually incapable of applying it.
I blame the parents who are irritated by critical thinking of their children.

I was baptized in the Pilgrims fathers church in Delftshaven. Not the church of the Pilgrim fathers, but the location where they prayed for a good journey to North America. They went from England to the Netherlands to find freedom for their religion. There is a Dutch thesis on the subject why they also left the Netherlands. After a few years they noticed that it was difficult to raise their children to become followers of their fate. The contact with Dutch children caused them to ask difficult questions to their parent and think for themselves. The parents didn't like it and went away.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,315
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom