Saxophones Has the internet changed players’ attitudes around saxophones and saxophone playing.

Intelligence, might be the ability to gather information.
Smart, might be the ability to use that information wisely.

Intelligent, there will be no places to buy Beer, on top of Pikes Peak, for the '67 Hill Climb.
Not Smart, only bringing one canteen of water, and two cases of Beer, for each person.

Old Mountain saying, snow melts slowly in mouth, bring lotsa water.
 
Has the internet changed players’ attitudes around saxophones and saxophone playing
Just quoting the title here....

I think one should hope so.
From what I learned on this forum (and the other one), there are lots of misconceptions about playing the saxophone. And lots of people swearing by some things that seem questionable to me. About all aspects of the horn and about playing it.
Preparation of reeds, the effect of reeds and mouthpieces on the sound. The effect of materials or finishings on the sound. .....
These days you can find all these different points of view and try and make something of it, explore different avenues and make up your own mind.
Without the internet you should rely on your teacher and his misconceptions (we all have them, I'm sure) to guide you along. My current teacher often jumps to conclusions and presents his solution as the only possible avenue, I have learnt to take his advice with a pinch of salt. Sometimes he is right, sometimes he is just plain wrong. Personally I find the wealth of information that can be found on the internet these days very valuable.

On the other hand, one could also get confused by the massive amount of misconceptions and disinformation. And not knowing what to make of it......
 
“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less.”
 “The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.”
 “The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master—that's all.”
 
Now I know why AI is stalled. How can it learn anything from our online encounters when we can't even agree what words mean?
I heard a good program which touches on your point on our Radio 4 (the 'serious' BBC radio channel). Am academic was on, making the point that in the early days of AI it had a whole pristine (well, OK) human-generated internet to train upon, and train it did. But now there is more AI out there, and more and more of the internet which is available as a training set, has fallen out the back end of an AI which put it there. In this way the thing becomes recursive and the 'quality' of the training set gets worse and worse - at just the time when attempts at increasing sophistication / ambition for what the AI is attempting to do, require more and more training data to get there. The whole program was optimistic (from the point of view of the future of civilisation) and perhaps pessimistic (from the point of view of anyone holding shares in tech companies, or who in any way relies for their prosperity on the stock market, which is perhaps all of us!).
 
on, making the point that in the early days of AI it had a whole pristine (well, OK) human-generated internet to train upon, and train it did. But now there is more AI out there, and more and more of the internet which is available as a training set, has fallen out the back end of an AI which put it there
Another way to think is that AI has been learning from websites and forums. Now that some forums are using AI “members” to contribute threads and posts, then AI is learning from those AI posts. Seems like it is basically eating itself and what it puts out (excretes?) becomes more and more divorced either from reality or from expert human knowledge that is based on experience. Instead we will get AI quoting AI sources which quote AI sources which quote AI sources ad infinitum.
 
Last edited:
Another way to think is that AI has been learning from websites and forums. Now that some forums are using AI “members” to contribute threads and posts, then AI is learning from those AI posts. Seems like it is basically eating itself and what it puts out (excretes?) becomes more and more divorced either from reality or from expert human knowledge that is based on experience. Instead we will get AI quoting AI sources which quote AI sources which quote AI sources ad infinitum.
Yes - that's the gist. So the thing trains for mediocrity; and that's good news for sharp thinkers. It'll certainly wipe out chunks of well-defined repeat-work white-collar labour in the same way that CAD and CNC machining has already wiped out a great deal of well-defined repeat-work blue-collar labour - what all those spare bodies will do, is yet to be seen. We can't all work in B&Q. (I'm not rejoicing in any of this, and I'm not insensitive to the plight of people whose livelihoods are under threat. My own career is a matter for history and without my wife's (white collar, probably under threat) income I'd be under considerable financial pressure.)
 
This just came up in the Conn 150 Anniversary thread and us possibly worthy of its own discussion.

The internet brought with it discussion groups (I fondly remember alt.music.saxophone for a start).

Do we now obsess more about gear rather than playing and actual music due to the online forums and more lately the proliferation of social media, YouTube, influencers etc?
YES.
 
I don't think it is ALL negative, of course.

On the good side, these chat boards (all instrument chatboards really not just sax) have gioven the opportunity to share opinion on a far wider variety of makes and models, the result being a renewed interest in a lot of vintage makers...plus the broadcasting of certain contemporary brand or model which ended up being pretty good, but usually got dismissed offhand or never considered as viable options.

Then when discussions are about music, and sharing favorite recording, things like that, etc. Or directing a newer player towards good resources for their development.

So all those I see as indubitably POSITIVE dynamics of Forums.

But yeah, the gear-based focus of most forum activity has gone overboard and it sorta becomes repetitive after a while. I often comment that, pre-internet, when musicians relationships with other musicians were in-person, face to face, the (musical) subject matter discussed in those contexts was really rarely about gear and equipment.
 
Another way to think is that AI has been learning from websites and forums. Now that some forums are using AI “members” to contribute threads and posts, then AI is learning from those AI posts. Seems like it is basically eating itself and what it puts out (excretes?) becomes more and more divorced either from reality or from expert human knowledge that is based on experience. Instead we will get AI quoting AI sources which quote AI sources which quote AI sources ad infinitum.
Like AI is talking into a mirror.
 
This just came up in the Conn 150 Anniversary thread
Equally.
Reading the various "history of..." threads, like the "left hand table.." threads. Isn't is amazing that the few folks who care deeply about that kind of thing can share, correct, add to and built upon each other's knowledge and lay down a record; to the edification of us all? The sort of discussion that, at best before the internet, would slosh around workshops and factories for a generation and then be lost.

But, and here's the rub, can you pick apart how "we now obsess" about gear from how (some of) we obsess about history or chord patterns or whatever? The internet is good for the goose and gander.
 
I remember when I was at school (late 90's), first learning the saxophone. I had one 15 Minute 1-2-1 lesson a week, and we had the 'local' music shop, which involved walking into the town center to it.

I can picture the shop now, with rows, and rows of music books to browse, for all kinds of instruments. Orange box reeds were the only reed I was aware of, it wasn't a 'saxophone' or 'woodwind' shop, just 'music shop'

There was no online streaming, it was still CD's

I still have lessons with my current teacher, and I've picked his brains about issues I've had with playing, I've instantly jumped to it must be setup, or reeds, for it to be mostly down to my technique.

My last lesson we were chatting, apparently I have a good understanding of rhythm, the theory around it, but the practical side leaves a lot to be desired. I need to develop my internal beat.
I've seen it with another player who is very knowledgeable, via online videos, but similarly struggles implementing it in a musical manner.

I've purchased a few online courses, but for me, it lacks the personal feedback. The other player I mentioned is solely self taught through online videos. The problem being, when playing with others its dynamic, timing isn't always millisecond perfect, there's a need to adapt to what's happening around you.

In short yes, I think the internet has changed things, some good, some bad.

Great we can access so much music, purchase equipment online, even learn, but I think it also takes away some of the joy of music, playing with others, and there always seem to be something that will fix something, rather than just good ole' practice!
 
The problem being, when playing with others its dynamic, timing isn't always millisecond perfect, there's a need to adapt to what's happening around you.
Usually one person is in charge of time keeping. Concentrate on that person.

In a concert band it’s the conductor. In a big band or small jazz or rock or pop group, it’s the drummer. If that person falls down on the job, someone else will take over. (Bass player in a small group, percussionist or lead trumpet or whatever in a large one.) The person taking over may not be aware that they have been elected, and that’s when train wrecks occur.

When you practice, use the metronome. Record yourself with it, and be brutally honest with yourself. If you haven’t done this before, learn to subdivide. That means, for example, if you are running a scale in eighth notes (quavers) you are thinking sixteenth notes (semiquavers). Make your eighth notes (quavers) fall exactly on the sixteenth note (semiquaver) boundaries. This is how you build precision.

You have to learn to be always aware of the time, and match your internal clock to the time keeper (metronome, conductor, drummer). This is often more important than being in tune.
 
That means, for example, if you are running a scale in eighth notes (quavers) you are thinking sixteenth notes (semiquavers). Make your eighth notes (quavers) fall exactly on the sixteenth note (semiquaver) boundaries. This is how you build precision.
I’ve never heard of that concept before, sounds interesting.
Usually one person is in charge of time keeping. Concentrate on that person.
This is very true when starting out. After a while it’s ideal for everyone to lock together in time by developing their own internal metronome.
 
@skeller047 this is my point, I've a good understanding of the theory/logic behind all of that... but the practicalities are different.

Playing with the orchestra is fine, with a conductor & percussion, but if it comes to a solo suddenly it can become quite lonely and exposed.

Same with a metronome, fine putting notes on the beat, but I struggle with Syncopation, and keeping off the beat. It's developing the internal feel of where the beat is, and being able to place the note in the correct place.

I've yet to see any 'you tube' video that goes into any real depth on how to achieve that, my teacher has and this is the biggest challenge I'm currently facing with my playing.

Similarly the player who can recite various scales, and theory surrounding them, but can't implement that knowledge for example improvising.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,325
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom