Wow, what a tough crowd. I guess I have been out of the online community for a while. Trying to figure out when the world turned against Graftonite & Metalite MPs. Sure, they have always had their detractors b/c of their price, but quite frankly, what people are writing here is new to me.
My experience with them is mostly limited to the original ones. I have played, and even have had a couple of the newer, re-introduced ones. All played very well. I still recommend them to many students, and schools for their school horns.
Arnold Brilhart originally designed these MPs. The bari and soprano pieces are most definitely regarded as the best, while the alto & tenor pieces are regarded alright.
I originally was given a bari Graftonite piece by my tech in Halifax back around 2001 or so. He told me to try it on my Mark VI, and suggested that it would be a good backup--replacement--piece for my vintage, HR Berg that I was so protective of.
I must admit I was impressed. It did everything my Berg did, except "break" when pushed too hard. (You Berg bari players likely know what I'm talking about.) I ended up using the Graftonite piece for over a decade, and even added an original Metalite piece for when I really needed my VI to sound edgy.
π
I also added a Graftonite soprano to my collection and used it for years, before switching to a Runyon Custom--another brand that has fallen out of favour.
π
I have had a
series of articles on my site about these MPs for years. These were some of the most popular articles for a really long time. Why? B/C people really liked the old pieces, and really wanted them to be reintroduced again.
I realize there are many more MP choices out there now then there were say, 20, or even 10 years ago. However, I try to avoid making blanket statements about any brand of anything if I can avoid it. What works for me, or what I have experienced, might not jive what other people have experienced.
Look no further than Stephen Howard's insistence that JK has a problem with the rings on its rolled tone, SX90R leaking. My experience is 100% different.
I worked for a JK dealer, and even own a JK with this type of rolled tone holes. Guess what? It doesn't leak. Nor do any of the others the shop had/has for sale.
I am not saying that a Metalite or Graftonite MP is the right choice for everyone. Far from it. But that's why it's important to try gear BEFORE you buy it.
I realize that in this day on online shopping this concept has become old fashioned, and perhaps even quaint. But before you spend hundreds of $$ on anything, don't you want to make sure it's right for you? And let's face it, when it comes to MPs, necks, ligs, reeds, & horns, it is anything but
one size fits all.