Mouthpieces Got a new tenor mouthpiece

Tip opening numbers are (IMO) mostly meaningless. ie without the corresponding facing curve type and length.
Very true, imo. I'd probably add the baffle as a factor. But with the proper facing curve & length, an open tip should not be more resistant or difficult to play than a smaller tip, at least in my experience. Also, with a high, or med-high, baffle, I find a larger tip opening helps to balance out the brightness, deepening/thickening and warming the tone quality, preventing it from being too shrill. IOW, a lot of factors go into the design of a mpc.

@cappers, I suspect it's not necessarily the more open tip that is giving you problems with the Soloist E. As Pete suggests, it could be other factors, both in the mpc design and in how you are playing on each mpc.
 
Tip opening numbers are (IMO) mostly meaningless. ie without the corresponding facing curve type and length. Too often people talk about tip openings as if it is some kind of equation that corresponds to resistance or whatever.

If it’s the Soloist E, then that is not a particularly wide tip or short facing that might affect breath. I’d happily prescribe it for a beginner. I suspect some other factors could be involved.
Exactly the point I was trying to make, tip size is the only advertised guide on a mouthpiece, Pete's observations plus the other variables, ie reed choice, internal design, not forgetting the ligature 😉, all affect tone (in my case noise) production.

It's too easy to overthink things sometimes.
 
Exactly the point I was trying to make, tip size is the only advertised guide on a mouthpiece, Pete's observations
I have noticed over the years people are sometimes fixated on tip size as a useful measure for mouthpieces without realising just how vague and unuseful it can be. I used to get a lot of pro players saying they play 7* and so order a PPT 7* and then returning it for an 8* or 9*, seemingly thinking because they think they are a "7* player" (due to the fact they've been plying Link 7*), that the same tip opening would equate. It doesn't.
 
I'm not so sure about oral cavity, tongue position or jaw personally, seems to be too much added to the equation that I just find baffling. Embouchure and breath - it's what I do understand. Perhaps people just try to make it more complicated than it needs to be.

I saw so many students sidetracked by complex stuff teachers had told them, they missed the wood for the trees.
My current teacher is a bit like that....
his advice is often good, and to the point. But often he'll give advice that (from my perspective) completely misses the point. He'll observe some problem in my playing, assume that the reason for that problem is "X", and then give me advice how to fix "X". In reality the cause of the problem might be "Y" or "Z" or ...... I just need to practice more 😉
After 2 years of taking classes with him I have learnt to ignore some of his advice.
I can immagine that some students would miss the wood for the trees with his way of teaching.
 
Listening on a phone it sounds to me that you need to push more air through the horn. Don't blow into it. Blow through it.

I love my Soloists. D on alto, C** on tenor. A much more versatile piece than many give it credit for. Perhaps a little experimentation with reeds might open the door for you.

The most important thing imo when starting out, is a set up that is easy to play. There's so much to do, learn and acclimatise to that an easy blow let's you focus on one less thing. Later when everything else is becoming more automatic you can focus on adapting to a more demanding piece.

Do experiment with reeds though but above all be patient with yourself. Enjoy where you are and don't focus too much on where you think you should be.
 
I'm not so sure about oral cavity, tongue position or jaw personally, seems to be too much added to the equation that I just find baffling. Embouchure and breath - it's what I do understand. Perhaps people just try to make it more complicated than it needs to be.

I saw so many students sidetracked by complex stuff teachers had told them, they missed the wood for the trees.
Yes, all that stuff about vowel sounds, raise the tongue, lower the tongue, go "eee" go "ooooh" say "aaaaahh" - all a bunch of noise. The way to do it is to spend a lot of time doing tone exercises, internalizing how it FEELS in your body to do what makes a good sound (good being defined by you!), so you can do more of that and less of how if FEELS in your body to do what makes a sound you don't like.

Just as an experiment I tried to find out what "vowel sound" I was supposedly using when playing. So I played a note, middle of the range, medium dynamic, playing with what I consider a good sound - then I pulled the horn out of my mouth and vocalized - invariably the sound that came out was "uh". So what does that tell you?
 
Listening on a phone it sounds to me that you need to push more air through the horn. Don't blow into it. Blow through it.
Thank you @Colin the Bear

I agree, a lack of breath support especially when the going gets tough! Silly thing is I know this and when I concentrate and really use my belly to blow it sounds much fuller and richer.

I like the sound of the Soloist more than the 5C. I don't find it hard to blow but it can go 'off' if I'm not careful. I also think the RRs work better for me than the DCs although I prefer the liveliness of DCs.

This mauling of Georgia was with the Soloist and RR2.5.


I am very grateful for the help you guys are giving me. I'll discuss my problem with my teacher on the 5th.

Cheers.
 
This on the YTS-25 and 5C mpc with Rico Royal 2.5
Hangs head in shame 😱

Nice to hear your horn.
Back to something that was suggested in another thread.

"At home, after warming up, do the following.
Play the D major scale, (concert C), from D1 to D3, if possible, tonguing each note/tone, playing half notes at 80 bpm, up and down.
Take breaths as necessary with proper breath support.
Then do the same scale, at 80 bpm, quarter notes legato.
Follow this up by playing a tune you know well, reading or memorized, with feeling and expression.
Record with what you have and post it."
 
Thank you @Colin the Bear

I agree, a lack of breath support especially when the going gets tough! Silly thing is I know this and when I concentrate and really use my belly to blow it sounds much fuller and richer.

I like the sound of the Soloist more than the 5C. I don't find it hard to blow but it can go 'off' if I'm not careful. I also think the RRs work better for me than the DCs although I prefer the liveliness of DCs.

This mauling of Georgia was with the Soloist and RR2.5.


I am very grateful for the help you guys are giving me. I'll discuss my problem with my teacher on the 5th.

Cheers.
Better tone to my (phone) ear. I suspect your loss of control may be down to reed selection. I find a French cut reed suits my Soloists. Maybe a half step softer than you're using. Don't think that harder is better. What works is best.

Breathe in and hold. Breathe in some more and hold. Breathe in a little more and play from there.
 
It's National Cat day.
Thanks for the mauling. 🙀

Wood burning project, on cherry, for the grandkids.

IMG_4337.webp



Pic from web.
IMG_4724.webp
 
Thanks @Colin the Bear
I think the both the RR and the Alex DC are French cut, the DC being 'double cut'? I've got 2s and 2.5s in both.

Hearing myself again I also notice a choppiness. The tempo was slower than the band version which I play that at the right tempo. I think I was a bit tense, don't like recording myself and I wanted to 'get it right' so wasn't relaxed.

What a journey :rofl:
 
Thank you @Colin the Bear

I agree, a lack of breath support especially when the going gets tough! Silly thing is I know this and when I concentrate and really use my belly to blow it sounds much fuller and richer.

I like the sound of the Soloist more than the 5C. I don't find it hard to blow but it can go 'off' if I'm not careful. I also think the RRs work better for me than the DCs although I prefer the liveliness of DCs.

This mauling of Georgia was with the Soloist and RR2.5.


I am very grateful for the help you guys are giving me. I'll discuss my problem with my teacher on the 5th.

Cheers.
BREATHE.

You're taking wee little breaths that won't even sustain a phrase.

The analogy I use is to imagine that I am filling up my entire torso with air, starting with the area around my navel. Then as I breathe out, there's a big large diameter tube, that starts around the navel, and which I force in a controlled way up through the horn using the big muscles of my abdomen.

This is not anatomically accurate - your lungs aren't in your belly, that's full of intestines - but it is an analogy that helps me (and many others) to do the things that lead to getting a proper size breath.

Until you can establish a proper airstream and support, faffing around with different mouthpieces and reeds is a lost cause. There's no reason why a full grown adult human shouldn't be able to take a Selmer Soloist D or E and #2.5 reeds and play "georgia, georgia, the whole day through" on a single breath, then "just an old sweet song, keeps Georgia on my mind" in the next single breath.
 
Thank you @Colin the Bear

I agree, a lack of breath support especially when the going gets tough! Silly thing is I know this and when I concentrate and really use my belly to blow it sounds much fuller and richer.

I like the sound of the Soloist more than the 5C. I don't find it hard to blow but it can go 'off' if I'm not careful. I also think the RRs work better for me than the DCs although I prefer the liveliness of DCs.

This mauling of Georgia was with the Soloist and RR2.5.


I am very grateful for the help you guys are giving me. I'll discuss my problem with my teacher on the 5th.

Cheers.
You are Bill Clinton and I claim my £5... 😀
 
@turf3
BREATHE.

You're taking wee little breaths that won't even sustain a phrase.
I know!!! As I said I know that and can do it but it is my weakest area.
I agree, a lack of breath support especially when the going gets tough! Silly thing is I know this and when I concentrate and really use my belly to blow it sounds much fuller and richer.
I'll start with a full belly and chest and push with my abdomen when I blow, visualising I'm blowing right through the horn. But I think I take smaller breaths when the pace is on or I'm tense. I know I can do it just not consistently.

Not faffing with mpc or reeds. As mentioned I will stay on the 5C with RR2.5 (might try RR2) until if have decent breath support.

Again thanks to everyone for the on-line diagnostics and suggestions :thumb:
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,237
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom