Mouthpieces Got a new tenor mouthpiece

Do not practice until you get it right. Practice until you don’t get it wrong.
I'm more moderate: I don't (well, try not to) practice more than I can not get wrong.
Corollary: before bed.
IMHO: Sleeping on something that's right improves the chances of it staying right and sleeping on something that's wrong increases the work required to get it right.
 
Gone back to the 5C for now. 😳

Much as I love the Soloist I can't control it as easily and it's hindering my development of a good tone. It's luscious but far less forgiving of poor air support and embouchure. I thought a tip increase of ~0.015 wouldn't make much difference but it does. When practicing quietly at home it's ok but in the band when I push it for volume and faster playing my tone goes down the drain. The 5C is more stable in my novice chops.

So back to basics and long tones. One exercise I found useful for both my breath support and the neighbour is 'super-soft long tones'. Play the long tones as softly as possible, barely audible just above the point where they stop sounding. Not as easy as said but helps breath support.

I've no problem eating humble-pie. I think joining a band so early boosted my confidence and ego too much..."hey I'm in a jazz band man, gotta get a big boy's mpc " :rolleyes: Lesson learnt!
 
Learn to do something correctly,
then practice.

Beginners may benefit with, one horn, one mouthpiece, and reeds may increase in strength, as necessary.
Spread the blueberry jam, too thin, and all you'll taste, is the unsweetened bread. 🧐
 
Learn to do something correctly,
then practice.

Beginners may benefit with, one horn, one mouthpiece, and reeds may increase in strength, as necessary.
Spread the blueberry jam, too thin, and all you'll taste, is the unsweetened bread. 🧐
Grasshopper, first learn to recognize the taste of blueberry and you can spread it as thin as you like.
 
I bought 2 named mouthpieces which I knew were too big a tip opening for me on a whim. First was an Ed Pillinger NYT from a lady in Germany, it was opened up for her by Kay Siebold and she insisted I would be fine with it or I could send it back . I used it for years and think I sold it to someone on here when I stopped playing tenor.

The second was a Goldbeck Superb, refaced by Sakshama (these were similar in appearance to the Link 4*), again a larger tip size than I normally use, again played straight out of the box (jiffy bag).

The numbers don't always stack up, for me at least.
 
Another day on the 5C and in all honesty I sound better on it. The Soloist has a nicer tone overall but it is easy to lose control of it, whereas the 5C is more steady.

I could persevere with the Soloist but my gut feeling is to get completely competent on the 5C first.

I think I sound better on the 5C now after using the Soloist for a couple of months.
Don't know if that would have happened due to practise or whether playing a wider tip has helped my embouchure and breath support?
 
Another day on the 5C and in all honesty I sound better on it. The Soloist has a nicer tone overall but it is easy to lose control of it, whereas the 5C is more steady.

I could persevere with the Soloist but my gut feeling is to get completely competent on the 5C first.

I think I sound better on the 5C now after using the Soloist for a couple of months.
Don't know if that would have happened due to practise or whether playing a wider tip has helped my embouchure and breath support?
The practice definitely helped. The wider tip may have had a positive effect. The important thing is you are comfortable now and ready to continue making progress.
 
The numbers don't always stack up, for me at least.
Tip opening numbers are (IMO) mostly meaningless. ie without the corresponding facing curve type and length. Too often people talk about tip openings as if it is some kind of equation that corresponds to resistance or whatever.
Don't know if that would have happened due to practise or whether playing a wider tip has helped my embouchure and breath support?
If it’s the Soloist E, then that is not a particularly wide tip or short facing that might affect breath. I’d happily prescribe it for a beginner. I suspect some other factors could be involved.
 
........

If it’s the Soloist E, then that is not a particularly wide tip or short facing that might affect breath. I’d happily prescribe it for a beginner. I suspect some other factors could be involved.
Indeed, you said the same to me when I queried purchasing it from you.

It is a lovely mouthpiece, maybe I need longer on it? Only had it a couple of months (~90hrs playing time) so maybe need longer to 'master' it. It is an easy blow and very versatile but it was easier to lose control of the tone. The switch back to the 5C until I'm fully competent on it was a suggestion from an experienced player.

"I suspect some other factors could be involved." Please enlighten me @Pete Thomas.
I'm in a bit of a trough at the moment, really trying to improve my tone and feeling that I'm not. If you think there's some other issue please tell me.

Thanks.
 
If only that kind of question could be answered online. It needs people to be physically present.
Fair enough. Seeing my teacher in a week or so.

I understand how oral cavity and throat shape, tongue position, jaw and embouchure and breath support can affect tone. Maybe I just need more time for it all to sync.

I have noticed that when I play at home or with my teacher, the music is at a slower tempo and generally less complex than many of the standards in the band. I think in the heat of the moment, playing 'live' one or more of the requirements for maintaining a good tone are lacking. In my case I think it is mostly breath support and throat shape.

Thanks.
 
I understand how oral cavity and throat shape, tongue position, jaw and embouchure and breath support can affect tone. Maybe I just need more time for it all to sync.
I'm not so sure about oral cavity, tongue position or jaw personally, seems to be too much added to the equation that I just find baffling. Embouchure and breath - it's what I do understand. Perhaps people just try to make it more complicated than it needs to be.

I saw so many students sidetracked by complex stuff teachers had told them, they missed the wood for the trees.
 
Facing length, facing curve, baffle. These are the controls for what works and what doesn’t.

I remember talking with Phil Barone, when I bought my tenor from him. I wanted a Hollywood mouthpiece too. I asked for a 7* tip (0.105”). He didn’t have one, and had stopped making mouthpieces at that time. He had an 8 (0.110”), and said I wouldn’t notice the difference. He was right, as in oh so many things. Crazy as a loon, but he knew his stuff.
 
I'm not so sure about oral cavity, tongue position or jaw personally, seems to be too much added to the equation that I just find baffling. Embouchure and breath - it's what I do understand. Perhaps people just try to make it more complicated than it needs to be.

I saw so many students sidetracked by complex stuff teachers had told them, they missed the wood for the trees.
To be fair my teacher hasn't really gone beyond embouchure including mpc position, and breath support, at least those are the things he pulls me up on.
When I mentioned 'voicing' methods he basically said there's lots of opinions out there.

I think my main issue is breath support.

It's good really as I was becoming overconfident and forgetting the basics. Weak foundations and all that.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,230
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom